What the subject says..  Do you want to see SA3 happen? While I am generally the biggest fan of the whole  idea of Sonic being in the world, I can get past it because the SA1 and 2  are pretty good games ( Sonic, Tails, Knuckles in SA1 and Sonic/Shadow in SA2). My problem with those two games are also presentation-wise. The voice acting,  lip-synching and stuff like that can simply be improved in a new Sonic Adventure. Also, less glitches. That's a must.

           Also, I'd love to see the levels be more open than before. The first SA offered a healthy amount of exploration in its levels, while SA2 really didn't.. It felt more linear, but that wasn't really a deal-breaker for me. Even if I do like the more open  level design SA1 has to offer.

           Finally, no useless characters. Keep  characters like Big away from a new Sonic Adventure. It's not hard.

          So....Do you want  to see SA3 happen?
        
    

I played it on XBLA, and that compared to the game more then 10 years ago......it is like watching a beloved cartoon from your youth and discovering how bad it is as an adult.

The story is terrible, voice acting and character development is childrens level, the mech/jewel hunting missions were tedious. As for the Sonic/Shadow levels, those types of levels are recreated successfully in better games like Sonic Generations.

Give me a Chao simulator. That is what I would buy. Gimme more chao parks, more competitions, online competitions, in-depth breeding and chao customization mechanics and ways to customize your parks.

I'd like to see Sonic take a dirt nap.

I just want my chao garden back!

Nope, but I would love a Sonic's Chao Garden Adventure!

Sonic Team would fuck it up, by keeping all the things people hated about the first two. If there were a Sonic Adventure reboot, then I'd be okay with it. Give me one gameplay style, and not a pointlessly edgy story. Have Sonic, Tails, and Knuckles playable. Don't have all the pointless characters like Boobbat Girl, Crocodile Guy, and Optimus Prime.

Not really. I never liked the Knuckles or Tails sections. Give me more Sonic Generations. If you want another character Shadow is fine as a palette swap.

Wouldn't mind playing a Chao simulator (like others have said).

Yes, but Sonic Team isn't the same anymore. What the hell happened to them?

Who cares? I play Sonic games solely for the gameplay. A return of the Chao garden is a must. It was like another game inside of a game. :0