3D Mario games are sometimes my favorite mario games. Nintendo has done a good job making them. Which one is the best and why? sorry these posts are short i just dont know what else to say.

Tagged as I'm gonna get SM3DW this weekend and then maybe I can formulat a better answer.

I don't consider Super Mario 3D Land and World to be 3D Mario games. They are isometric platformers, not 3D platformers. Also, I look at Super Mario Galaxy 1 and 2 the same way I look at New Super Mario Bros U and New Super Luigi U. It's more of a glorified expansion pack to me. An amazing expansion pack, but still largely two parts of one game. With that, the best 3D Mario game is Super Mario Galaxy 1 + 2.

Super Mario Galaxy.
About as close to perfection as a video game can get.

The only correct answer would be Super Mario 64.

I was going to saying Mario 64 but then again I just finished Super Mario 3D World and I still have that lingering feeling from playing it, I've never seen such a creative game in my life, how every level is so unique and new.

12 WORLDs!!! EVERY LEVEL was SHOCKLY new from the previous level.

You guys should watch the gameplay for the last stage in Super Mario 3D World on youtube, the stage is like 5-7 mins long.

Super Mario 64.

I recently played Mario Galaxy again with a few friends and was totally confused by how often the game uses the pointer function of the Wiimote and stupid, gimmicky stuff. Super Mario 64 is pure 3D jump 'n' run, Mario Galaxy is more like "we tossed in every gimmick we could" and I don't like it when games feel bloated.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dIYvd5aqeV8

Very hard to decide between Super Mario Galaxy and Super Mario 3D World.

Saw that champion road video and I get the feeling from the video alone that the Perfect Run was much harder. I'll probably see it when I actually play it, but I remember The Perfect Run as being a total hell.