By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Digital Foundry writer backtracks Killzone comment

JerCotter7 on 27 November 2013

Why are people arguing with Selnor? He did this all last gen as well and he was wrong every time. You can say which you prefer visually easily. Depends if you like realism or sci-fi. But from a technical perspective Ryse isn't on the same level as KZ. But it is the only game anywhere close to it.



Around the Network
Xenostar on 27 November 2013

For those that want to still argue about turds the only thing you should ever take from a DF article is the technical analysis.

Once they start talking about art styles your into the realms of personal opinion and the opinion of some guy with a capture card is no more important than anyone else's.



curl-6 on 27 November 2013

This takes me back to Resistance Fall of Man versus Gears of War back in '06...



bananaking21 on 27 November 2013
selnor1983 said:
bananaking21 said:
selnor1983 said:

I only posted Darks comments. I have never once quoted anyone else. Read the thread. They are all his posts. Jesus Christ. Your trying to cherrypick Artstyle here now as technical analysis? Like I said theres more to come from him. They are chewing him up and spitting him out. They are again asking about the Ryse comment being better than all other launch games. Awaiting another reply.

Poor guy shuldnt have tried to keep fanboys happy. LOL.


according to this comment you killed any credibility the guys has for making a objective judgment about which game looks better. if he does make these calls to make fanboys happy then he doesnt make them based on the truth and on what game looks better. therefor his objectove opinion is invalid according to you. so when he does say ryse is the best looking game (which he doesnt btw) but even if he did, it doesnt matter, because he just said it to make fanboys happy. so you taking his words doesnt mean shit, because you just questions his credibility. congrats, you just shot down your own argument and have no legs to stand on what so ever to claim that ryse is the best looking game between the two. 

He does say Ryse. In the official article posted on DF.

But after being attacked by fans he said Killzone. Then later reveals he Artistically prefers Killzone.

The debate between him and them is not over yet. Waiting on his reply.

but he only makes his discisions to please fanboys. thats what YOU said. so it doesnt matter now, does it?

dude you killed your own argument, give it a rest. 



Dark_Feanor on 27 November 2013

I realy don´t care any more.

Just play the games and have fun with then.



Around the Network
FanboysMakeMeLaugh on 27 November 2013

On a technical level, Ryse is lacking in every category against KZ:SF.

Some guy's opinion can't change the objective facts of the matter.

Fact > Opinion and you seem to be lacking in one department.



selnor1983 on 27 November 2013
bananaking21 said:
selnor1983 said:
bananaking21 said:
selnor1983 said:

I only posted Darks comments. I have never once quoted anyone else. Read the thread. They are all his posts. Jesus Christ. Your trying to cherrypick Artstyle here now as technical analysis? Like I said theres more to come from him. They are chewing him up and spitting him out. They are again asking about the Ryse comment being better than all other launch games. Awaiting another reply.

Poor guy shuldnt have tried to keep fanboys happy. LOL.


according to this comment you killed any credibility the guys has for making a objective judgment about which game looks better. if he does make these calls to make fanboys happy then he doesnt make them based on the truth and on what game looks better. therefor his objectove opinion is invalid according to you. so when he does say ryse is the best looking game (which he doesnt btw) but even if he did, it doesnt matter, because he just said it to make fanboys happy. so you taking his words doesnt mean shit, because you just questions his credibility. congrats, you just shot down your own argument and have no legs to stand on what so ever to claim that ryse is the best looking game between the two. 

He does say Ryse. In the official article posted on DF.

But after being attacked by fans he said Killzone. Then later reveals he Artistically prefers Killzone.

The debate between him and them is not over yet. Waiting on his reply.

but he only makes his discisions to please fanboys. thats what YOU said. so it doesnt matter now, does it?

dude you killed your own argument, give it a rest. 

I was talking about the thread on gaf. As far as Im aware the Articles on DF are a Technical analysis. Whereas in the forum he gives alot of opinion and aethestic reasons.



ethomaz on 27 November 2013
Dark_Feanor said:
I realy don´t care any more.

Just play the games and have fun with then.

You will need to go with another game because both are deception in a game form but they looks pretty



Xenostar on 27 November 2013
selnor1983 said:
bananaking21 said:
selnor1983 said:
bananaking21 said:
selnor1983 said:

I only posted Darks comments. I have never once quoted anyone else. Read the thread. They are all his posts. Jesus Christ. Your trying to cherrypick Artstyle here now as technical analysis? Like I said theres more to come from him. They are chewing him up and spitting him out. They are again asking about the Ryse comment being better than all other launch games. Awaiting another reply.

Poor guy shuldnt have tried to keep fanboys happy. LOL.


according to this comment you killed any credibility the guys has for making a objective judgment about which game looks better. if he does make these calls to make fanboys happy then he doesnt make them based on the truth and on what game looks better. therefor his objectove opinion is invalid according to you. so when he does say ryse is the best looking game (which he doesnt btw) but even if he did, it doesnt matter, because he just said it to make fanboys happy. so you taking his words doesnt mean shit, because you just questions his credibility. congrats, you just shot down your own argument and have no legs to stand on what so ever to claim that ryse is the best looking game between the two. 

He does say Ryse. In the official article posted on DF.

But after being attacked by fans he said Killzone. Then later reveals he Artistically prefers Killzone.

The debate between him and them is not over yet. Waiting on his reply.

but he only makes his discisions to please fanboys. thats what YOU said. so it doesnt matter now, does it?

dude you killed your own argument, give it a rest. 

I was talking about the thread on gaf. As far as Im aware the Articles on DF are a Technical analysis. Whereas in the forum he gives alot of opinion and aethestic reasons.


No even DF articles are littered with opinions among the technical analysis. 



bananaking21 on 27 November 2013
selnor1983 said:

I was talking about the thread on gaf. As far as Im aware the Articles on DF are a Technical analysis. Whereas in the forum he gives alot of opinion and aethestic reasons.


bullshit. you made this thread about something he said on gaf. so when you think its pro ryse post it. when its pro killzone, state its just an opinion and has no merit. again, bullshit.