By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Digital Foundry writer backtracks Killzone comment

selnor1983 on 27 November 2013
Aldro said:
selnor1983 said:
Aldro said:
selnor1983 said:
Aldro said:

This topic should be closed because it is poorly worded. In no way does the poster "backtrack" anything. He simply states that both Ryse and Shadow Fall look the best on respective platform and both are doing stuff that he could see be "on the top" but he still says he prefers Killzone.

And thats that ^^

(And anyone with any knowledge on specs will tell you that the PS4 has an advantage over X1 in terms of it. Make of that, what you will. Hell just factor in the vast differences in game design for KZ and Ryse. Ryse SHOULD be better looking due to what it is.)

Of course its relevant. You keep clinging to the first page statement in retaliation to the Sony fans outrage. When questioned about it he says he prefers the AESTHETICS of Killzone. He could put either at the top.

 

What this is called is trying to please the parties in the forum.

Then the thread explodes into a load of dual owners saying Ryse has it.

ROFL.

This isn't about the thread though, it's about the Digital Foundry guy.

He can put either at top => They are tied, especially for respective consoles. Technically I assume, presumably Visually as well.
He prefers Killzone solely due to the aethetics BECAUSE they are tied. So Killzone wins visually FOR HIM. That is stated twice.
His original post, here, was:

^And so he still thinks that. It's what he prefers in terms of best looking.


How can this be so hard to grasp? Your comments on the DF topic VS Ryse was all about how Ryse was the greatest looking one according to DF. Well you were wrong. You're in a position here where all you can try to fight for, is a draw. That is pretty hilarious.

The members arent finished withhim yet. They are pressing him again. Hes looking pretty stupid right now. Waiting for his next response.

The article though is technical analysis. Which says Ryse. So Technically Ryse, artstyle Killzone for him.

We shall see what he says next.

No because of what you already shared:
""Honestly, I could put either game at the top of the list."

And

Like I said its not finished yet. Wating for him to reply. Hes again being directly questioned as to why he categorically in the article said Ryse was better than the rest.

Cmon Darky reply already.



Around the Network
littlejang on 27 November 2013

selnor is a lieier..



TheEspionage on 27 November 2013

Both look good so who cares about which looks the best. Two completely different artsyles from what could be considered the two best graphical minds in the industry. If this wasn't a sony vs Microsoft thing I think most people wouldn't care that much.



curl-6 on 27 November 2013



bananaking21 on 27 November 2013
selnor1983 said:

I only posted Darks comments. I have never once quoted anyone else. Read the thread. They are all his posts. Jesus Christ. Your trying to cherrypick Artstyle here now as technical analysis? Like I said theres more to come from him. They are chewing him up and spitting him out. They are again asking about the Ryse comment being better than all other launch games. Awaiting another reply.

Poor guy shuldnt have tried to keep fanboys happy. LOL.


according to this comment you killed any credibility the guys has for making a objective judgment about which game looks better. if he does make these calls to make fanboys happy then he doesnt make them based on the truth and on what game looks better. therefor his objectove opinion is invalid according to you. so when he does say ryse is the best looking game (which he doesnt btw) but even if he did, it doesnt matter, because he just said it to make fanboys happy. so you taking his words doesnt mean shit, because you just questions his credibility. congrats, you just shot down your own argument and have no legs to stand on what so ever to claim that ryse is the best looking game between the two. 



Around the Network
Shyakugaun on 27 November 2013
Mmmfishtacos said:
Trying a bit to hard. Killzone is running at a higher res more constant fps. And looks better over all.


I played both, i beat both (probably 1 of the only few ppl who has), And honestly Ryse is the more breath taking of the two, you need to see it in person, and in motion to understand.  It doesnt take away from how stunning Killzone looks, i was just more impressed on a regular basis with Ryse during my Playthroughs.



Aldro on 27 November 2013
bananaking21 said:
selnor1983 said:

I only posted Darks comments. I have never once quoted anyone else. Read the thread. They are all his posts. Jesus Christ. Your trying to cherrypick Artstyle here now as technical analysis? Like I said theres more to come from him. They are chewing him up and spitting him out. They are again asking about the Ryse comment being better than all other launch games. Awaiting another reply.

Poor guy shuldnt have tried to keep fanboys happy. LOL.


according to this comment you killed any credibility the guys has for making a objective judgment about which game looks better. if he does make these calls to make fanboys happy then he doesnt make them based on the truth and on what game looks better. therefor his objectove opinion is invalid according to you. so when he does say ryse is the best looking game (which he doesnt btw) but even if he did, it doesnt matter, because he just said it to make fanboys happy. so you taking his words doesnt mean shit, because you just questions his credibility. congrats, you just shot down your own argument and have no legs to stand on what so ever to claim that ryse is the best looking game between the two. 





Mmmfishtacos on 27 November 2013

Your going to feel pretty foolish when df vs killzone come out.

let me spell this out one last time. Higher fps, higher res, more open world. Killzone looks better over all. Df likes the looks of killzone better than rise. Killzone also scored better with the critics. Its best just to admit you where wrong and move on. Your on tye lossing side of this battle.



Aldro on 27 November 2013
KylieDog said:
selnor1983 said:

ROFL. Some people only read what they want to read.


VGChartz needs a hilarious user quotes thread.  This should go in it.





selnor1983 on 27 November 2013
bananaking21 said:
selnor1983 said:

I only posted Darks comments. I have never once quoted anyone else. Read the thread. They are all his posts. Jesus Christ. Your trying to cherrypick Artstyle here now as technical analysis? Like I said theres more to come from him. They are chewing him up and spitting him out. They are again asking about the Ryse comment being better than all other launch games. Awaiting another reply.

Poor guy shuldnt have tried to keep fanboys happy. LOL.


according to this comment you killed any credibility the guys has for making a objective judgment about which game looks better. if he does make these calls to make fanboys happy then he doesnt make them based on the truth and on what game looks better. therefor his objectove opinion is invalid according to you. so when he does say ryse is the best looking game (which he doesnt btw) but even if he did, it doesnt matter, because he just said it to make fanboys happy. so you taking his words doesnt mean shit, because you just questions his credibility. congrats, you just shot down your own argument and have no legs to stand on what so ever to claim that ryse is the best looking game between the two. 

He does say Ryse. In the official article posted on DF.

But after being attacked by fans he said Killzone. Then later reveals he Artistically prefers Killzone.

The debate between him and them is not over yet. Waiting on his reply.