I was just about to ask about Microsoft's list until I realized that would be about 3 games.

Sony and Nintendo definitely haven't been disappointments these past couple years. Aggregate scores don't do most of those games justice.

Nintendo by a country mile.

well, Wii party just sold about 8m, i guess is just another average underground game

EDIT: This comment wouldnt post on my phone

Nintendo always does a great job with their first party games and I think The Legend of Zelda ALBW and Super Mario 3D World will join the list with very high scores.

That's an average 78. Not bad I think, considering how many games there are.

Knack's score is 59 btw, not 52.

Game and Wario is missing on that list.

And some of those games are not 1st party. Layton? Unfinished Swan?

Speaking about sony, a lot of theips above thatdid badly were new IPs or experimental in some way - the likes of Beyond, Starhawk, the Ratchet games or PSASBR. Some few paid off, the rest got average score for the most part. Thats the nature of taking risks and sony are known for this.

Nintendo - no commentto make as I dont have any nintendo gaming devices or games.

Bought Puppeteer, Id say buy it if you want a treat. Game is fun and has impressivee 3D

Very disapointed in this comment.  Moderators should not comment with this type of behavior nor act so emotional and defensive.

This thread is asking an actual question>. If you actually enjoyed the last two years then say so, after all, reviews dont matter if you like the game. I like how some people came in here and just said no they liked the games.  That is all that matters.  personally I've only bought two (Journey and TLoU) but i usually only buy games that are reviewed exceptionally well.  ive rented a lot of them though and they were mostly average(Hated Sly Cooper though, no offense to anybody)

and im it is bullshit? For leaving out wonderful amazing games like The Wonder Book, Sports Champions 2, Eyepet Adventures, or Top Darts?  Or was you under the impression I was just leaving out Nintendo games and Sony didnt have any other games?

That is why i did notable games. Games we "Hardcore" gamers actually give a shit about.

Any ways this thread came about because after the last bunch of big games for sony this year (Besides GT6) I was noticing I havent bought many sony games since Uncharted 3.  Not like ive bought many WiiU or X360 games either.  Frankly X360 has been shit with First party for the last few years and WiiU has been bad as well.  But you know, Im just a fanboy who is blinded by the gods of MSFT and Nintendo correct?

I havent got to play that game yet.  Ive had it on gamefly for a while though.  Looks like a lot of fun :D  I didnt know it had 3D O.o  Unfortutely i dont have 3D though :/