So abnoxious.

lol typo =P

I loved TLOU, Starhawk, Twisted Metal, God of War Ascension
KZ mercenary was also pretty great and I'm sure Shawdow fall will be just as great. Although the PS4 launch lineup did get pretty depressing scores..only if second son were a launch title...that being said the only Nintendo games I enjoyed on that list were..
Dark Moon, NSMB Wii U and NSMB 2..and I didn't even like them that much..they were all just good, which is pretty sad considering its a company that depends on its first party rather than 3rd party software unlike Sony or Microsoft.

The ones I left above are the ones I have played, and none of them would I rate below an 8/10. Many of the ones you listed are also Vita titles, and for some reason Vita games have been being judged extra hard, as if every game has to justify a Vita purchase and if they fall short then they are a terrible game all together. Gravity Rush is a 95 to me for just being so inventive, Uncharted GA is about right, The Last of Us is a 100, Soul Sacrifice is a 90, LBP Vita is also a 10, Unit 13 is a solid 83 to me. Phenomenal games brought down by people who just didn't understand what they were even going for :P

I will be picking up Puppeteer and Beyond sometime this month. I have a hunch like most of this list, my opinon will differ vastly from the media.

90%+

• The Last of Us - 95
• Journey - 92

80-89%

• LittleBigPlanet Vita - 88
• MLB: The Show 13 - 87
• MLB: The Show 2012 - 87
• Gravity Rush - 83
• God of War Ascension - 80
• Uncharted: Golden Abyss - 80
• Puppeteer - 80

70-79%

• The Unfinished Swan - 79
• Killzone: Mercenery - 78
• Motorstorm RC - 78
• Soul Sacrifice - 77
• Starhawk - 77
• Twisted Metal - 76
• Ratchet & Clank: Into the Nexus - 75
• Sly Cooper: Thieves in Time - 75
• Killzone: Shadow Fall - 74
• Playstation All-Stars - 74
• Little Big Planet Karting - 73
• Rain - 72
• Unit 13 - 71
• Beyond: Two Souls - 71

60-69%

• Ratchet & Clank: Full Frontal Assault -64

50-59%

• Knack - 59

Average Metascore of the 25 games above = 77.8% (78%) which isn't bad at all, espeically considering the huge amount of exclusives Sony has put out compared to the competition.

Sony's top 10 games from 2012-2013 average 85.1% (85%) which is great, their top 20 games average a very good 80.4% (80%), there's nothing to be disappointed about, there's a lot of good/great quality exclusives from Sony that have released during the last couple of years and things will only get better in the future.

So you're making your lists based on what games were "hyped" on the internet forums?  That seems like a rather nebulous and bullshit way to make a list that just happens to disclude every poorly scoring game Nintendo published in that time.  

I wonder if you add up the sales of all these games who wins, Sony or Nintendo? can someone do it?

A first party game has always been understood as made by a first party developer when these lists are made.

As long as there are review sites like Polygon or Quarter-To-Three trolling Sony games, we can't talk metacritic seriously.