By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo - First Sonic: Lost World Review is in from IGN! And it doesn't look good...

Nem on 19 October 2013
S.T.A.G.E. said:
Nem said:
S.T.A.G.E. said:
Sonic is a tough entity to control in a 3D world. He's definitely better off in 2D.


I have to disagree. The speed leveles on Sonic adventure 2 were a joy to play. I dont know what was wrong with those that led to them trying to redefine the gameplay.

Of course, 2D Sonic is pretty good aswell though.


There will never be a 3D version that is as beloved as the top three. You can rant that would just make it that much more crazy.


I'm not sure what you mean with top 3.

Do you mean the first 3 games on the mega drive/genesis? Those are definitly my favorite ones. Maybe i wasnt very clear. I love most of all the 2D Sonic gameplay on Sonic 1 to 3 + Knuckles and Sonic CD.

From the 3D gameplay, i think Sonic adventure 2 was the pinnacle of the series and it got worse since. I havent tried this new game yet though.

Ideally i would like for SEGA to continue the Sonic "4" franchise with a proper full game instead of droplet digital games and the 3D Series with Sonic adventure. I dislike how childish they are making Sonic. Sonic was always aimed at a teenager croud. SEGA is trying to follow Nintendo and Mario, but i doubt that will work. They need direction and have a 2D and a 3D series of games would be the best for Sonic just like it is for Mario, instead of this scratching around looking to see where it can stick.



Around the Network
S.T.A.G.E. on 19 October 2013
Nem said:
S.T.A.G.E. said:
Nem said:
S.T.A.G.E. said:
Sonic is a tough entity to control in a 3D world. He's definitely better off in 2D.


I have to disagree. The speed leveles on Sonic adventure 2 were a joy to play. I dont know what was wrong with those that led to them trying to redefine the gameplay.

Of course, 2D Sonic is pretty good aswell though.


There will never be a 3D version that is as beloved as the top three. You can rant that would just make it that much more crazy.


I'm not sure what you mean with top 3.

Do you mean the first 3 games on the mega drive/genesis? Those are definitly my favorite ones. Maybe i wasnt very clear. I love most of all the 2D Sonic gameplay on Sonic 1 to 3 + Knuckles and Sonic CD.

From the 3D gameplay, i think Sonic adventure 2 was the pinnacle of the series and it got worse since. I havent tried this new game yet though.

Ideally i would like for SEGA to continue the Sonic "4" franchise with a proper full game instead of droplet digital games and the 3D Series with Sonic adventure. I dislike how childish they are making Sonic. Sonic was always aimed at a teenager croud. SEGA is trying to follow Nintendo and Mario, but i doubt that will work. They need direction and have a 2D and a 3D series of games would be the best for Sonic just like it is for Mario.


Top 3 as in the first game, the seccond and the third. Sega Generations was great, but thats about it for me.



Nem on 19 October 2013
S.T.A.G.E. said:
Nem said:
 


I'm not sure what you mean with top 3.

Do you mean the first 3 games on the mega drive/genesis? Those are definitly my favorite ones. Maybe i wasnt very clear. I love most of all the 2D Sonic gameplay on Sonic 1 to 3 + Knuckles and Sonic CD.

From the 3D gameplay, i think Sonic adventure 2 was the pinnacle of the series and it got worse since. I havent tried this new game yet though.

Ideally i would like for SEGA to continue the Sonic "4" franchise with a proper full game instead of droplet digital games and the 3D Series with Sonic adventure. I dislike how childish they are making Sonic. Sonic was always aimed at a teenager croud. SEGA is trying to follow Nintendo and Mario, but i doubt that will work. They need direction and have a 2D and a 3D series of games would be the best for Sonic just like it is for Mario.


Top 3 as in the first game, the seccond and the third. Sega Generations was great, but thats about it for me.


I agree with that acessment. But i enjoyed Adventure 1 and 2 aswell.

Oh i dislike the modern stages on generations though, but they are tolerable cause they go 2D sometimes aswell.



Moonhero on 19 October 2013

It's a game on Nintendo, not made by Nintendo. Did anyone think it would get a fair shot?



Ask stefl1504 for a sig, even if you don't need one.

S.T.A.G.E. on 19 October 2013
Nem said:
S.T.A.G.E. said:
Nem said:
 


I'm not sure what you mean with top 3.

Do you mean the first 3 games on the mega drive/genesis? Those are definitly my favorite ones. Maybe i wasnt very clear. I love most of all the 2D Sonic gameplay on Sonic 1 to 3 + Knuckles and Sonic CD.

From the 3D gameplay, i think Sonic adventure 2 was the pinnacle of the series and it got worse since. I havent tried this new game yet though.

Ideally i would like for SEGA to continue the Sonic "4" franchise with a proper full game instead of droplet digital games and the 3D Series with Sonic adventure. I dislike how childish they are making Sonic. Sonic was always aimed at a teenager croud. SEGA is trying to follow Nintendo and Mario, but i doubt that will work. They need direction and have a 2D and a 3D series of games would be the best for Sonic just like it is for Mario.


Top 3 as in the first game, the seccond and the third. Sega Generations was great, but thats about it for me.


I agree with that acessment. But i enjoyed Adventure 1 and 2 aswell.

Oh i dislike the modern stages on generations though, but they are tolerable cause they go 2D sometimes aswell.


Agreed.



Around the Network
eyeofcore on 19 October 2013

forums.sonicretro.org/indexD­OTphp?showtopic=31396&st=1965&­p=764883entry764883



Areym on 19 October 2013

Ouch. This was actually one of the better looking games for the Wii U. Poor Sonic might be running out of steam.



"Trick shot? The trick is NOT to get shot." - Lucian