Metroid Prime 2 was decent, not as good as Prime, but still better than some devs' best work. the WiiMote controls on Prime 3 were amazing.

So Fallout 3 is too RPGish to be in the list but System Shock 2 isn't.

What no Resistance game at all? Uhm..

But I'm glad Killzone is low.

Not sure if the list is mediocre or the entire FPS genre is mediocre.

I must be the only one who never enjoyed Halo: Combat Evolved, I got this and kung fu chaos with my xbox and ended up playing kung fu chaos 10 times more than Halo lol

No real arguments here. Overall a good list, good to see two Halo games make the top 10 and every shooter Halo made the top 100 Halo, Halo 2, Halo 3, Halo 3 ODST, Halo 4, Halo Reach. That just shows Halo is one one of the best games of all time. (Opinion)

Just came to make sure CoD 4 scored high. I'm pleased with 5.

Halo 3 deserves much higher in my opinion.

That is debatable, some like it because it is even darker, even more hopeless and twisted than Prime 1

...yes, I didn´t have the WOW factor of the first Prime...but the A Link to the past second world mechanic was something else

absolutely shocking list

I get the impression this list was made to cause rage. OSDT ahead of Halo 3? Killzone 3 on the list but not Killzone 2? Other great FPS series excluded entirely?

Surrrre :P