I disagree with all of it!


Gta iv... no way just no.

There are cases where games ARE overrated though.

Grand Theft Auto IV being the perfect example.

Yes because all that is holy and true in theworld resides on youtube..............

You probably didn't watched it buy anyway. It's a game show call extra credits, they talk about game developing and other cool stuff about video games. 

The writer worked on various AAA games and it's now giving class about game developing.

The animator (which right now is not the same, but at the time of this episode she was) is a game developer which is currently working at Retro Studios.

So this guys know their stuff.

Skyrim I agree with and COD and GTA.

I thought Halo 1 & 2 were overrated but I haven't played that much of 4 to say.

It's all opinion I mainly like JRPGS so anything thats not one is usually overrated to me lol

I appreciate the time and effort that OP took in making this, and I respect his opinions. But I can't say I agree with any of the 10 games being overrated aside from MW2 but that's because I dislike every CoD game after Modern Warfare. That said, MW2 is probably the best CoD since MW. I really liked Sonic Adventure 2, one of my favourite games when I was growing up. And I think FF7 is one of the best games of all time, loved the Chocobo side quest, Sephiroth, and the whole first disc of the game especially was amazing. But hey, opinions are like butts, right?

I pretty much agree with all except for Twilight Princess. While the game was in fact very highly rated, at the same time it deserved. Maybe I'm just a huge fan of the Zelda titles with the darker stroytelling and atmosphere (namely TP and Majora's Mask), but I loved that game none the less. My only complaint on it ever was the small ammount of swords to unlock, but other than that, beautiful game.

That homoerotic clown guy did kindof weird me out though...

I like pretty much every game I play, so I don't really see games as disappointing.

I agree with all of those, except Twilight Princess, since I never played it. A lot of those wouldn't make it in my top 10 though.

That's so weird, because Chrono Trigger still doesn't have nearly as much publicity as Final Fantasy or many other games.  It's highly rated, sure... but for good reason.  There were a handful of firsts that happened with Chrono Trigger.  It also has a very different story for its time, and even now it is pretty timeless.  To say it's all nostalgia and that it doesn't have much going for it definitely ignores how well the game was created.

Also, your argument for FF7 completely falls apart when you say Chrono Trigger should be in an overrated list. 
http://www.metacritic.com/game/ds/chrono-trigger
http://www.metacritic.com/game/playstation/final-fantasy-vii

So if you look at the data, by what definition makes Chrono Trigger more overrated than FF7?