Woah, that setlist is great and it's not even full. I'm intrested.

You're pretty quick to pass judgement on a game that's not even out yet.

And you wonder why I call you trollofwale.

This could be big amongst casual gamers.

But WOW, is the Wii getting a lot of music-based games.

Currently: DDR, GH3, Boogie
Coming: Band Mashup, Rock Band, Samba de Amigo, and I think there's a couple more too

At least half are Wii exclusive. Seem Wii is starting to own this genre

 Have you never seen Demo guys before?  70-80% of demo guys look like they've never picked up the game before.

 I get that you're not excited for the game and I'm cool with that; not everyone has to like every game.  What bothers me is you're hating it for the absolute wrong reasons.

1. Graphics-- the game doesn't even have a release date yet.  There is a lot of time left to work on that.
2. Content-- 30 songs is a lot of songs and the fact that each song has at least 4 variations makes that 30 seems even more impressive.   When you add on that this is a brand new franchise and that this is more of a battle of the bands that isn't just a guitar Hero clone it is pretty impressive content wise.
3. Controls-- With every Wii game you have to be worried about controls but I'm not too worried.  You can't tell that it's bad execution by a single video and even from a small series of videos you never know until people actually get their hands on the game and start commenting on the game.  Everyone thought Lair had fantastic controls until people actually started playing it. 

Right now we're still just looking at the concept of the game.  That concept is to battle with people with popular songs in unusual styles.  That's pretty cool.  If the game was coming out next week and it still looked like that and we hadn't heard anything on the controls then I would be worried, but the game isn't coming out next week so we know nothing. 

@twesterm

I don't hate the game, I'm just not excited from what I've seen so for (which is the only thing I can base it on, the video preview). I mean, you can look at the bottle half full like you, and expect them to fix all the graphical and all the issues. Or you can look at it like me and expect another Boogie-wannabe.

I mean, I don't expect everybody to agree with me, but I've seen way too many games with good potential and very easily fixed problems, but they still come out unfixed and gets horrible review and never been seen again.

Yes, I'm looking at you Lair and your control issues.

 Perhaps hate is the wrong word there, but the point of my post remains the same.  It's still too early to say things like Also, Gosh, work on the graphics. I know it's for casual fans, but what the hell is that I'm looking at? and Good idea, bad execution, just like Boogie.

Like I said, right now we're just at the concept stage.

I am standing correct on how terrible it looks though, Unless they make it better, that will remain my major complain.

It might be too early to judge the game itself, but they put themselves up for this ridicule when they decided to unleash those 2 videos.

Still, I'm not hoping for much, Apparently I hated SIngstar but the European digs it, so i guess people all have different taste.

game is by THQ... not a good thing, and the tracklist is shitty, buy rockband instead, best rhythm game ever

Hmm, looks like the Music Rythym genre is starting to mature.

Guitar Hero innovates by introducing the genre. (DDR doesn't count, don't ask)
Everyone imitates it as much as they can (Band Mashup, Rock Band, moar Guitar Hero)
Soon it will saturate.