| CrashMan said: ^ That argument gets thrown around all the time. But how could god be All Good before he created anything. He alone existed and if there was no evil, how could he be good? If I have a gun, and I give it to my friend KNOWING he is going to go kill someone, I am as morally responsible for that person's death as my friend is. How does that NOT apply to god. The one thing god can't do is force a free willed individual to do something. It can't be done. Also think about this. If god is all powerful, he then has the power to create another all powerful being. That being would then have the power to force god to perform an action that is evil, or imperfect, or force god not to know something, or even make god not all powerful or not exist. Regardless of whether god WOULD do that, (and how presumptuous it is of those people on here saying god COULD do things but WOULDN'T, how the hell do YOU know what god would do) it is possible and therefore proof that god can't can't be ALL Powerful, ALL Perfect, ALL Knowing, and ALL pressent (ie containing these attributes under all conditions). |
Ok. Let's say you are right. God is not all knowing.
Does this mean God can't exist? Or does this mean he's just not all knowing? If Christians are wrong in some areas about god. This does not mean that he doesn't exist.
That's like saying I saw a Lion in the park today and he had three ribbons in his hair, then he disapeered in thin air. Then we go to the park... find two ribbons on the ground and you say "See that lion never existed."
As for how could god be all Good if no evil existed? Simple. Good and Evil were created... just like everything else.
To you and I Good and Evil might be different. If my brother is about to hurt your brother and possibly kill him, and you kill my brother to save yours... I may see that as evil. You may see that as good. Our definitions are different.
The only person with an accurate definition of Good, is the person who created good in the first place.
If no one created good, then all of our definitions of good and evil are equally valid. My definition of good is equal to Charles Manson's defintion of good, the only difference is that the sociatal norms trend more toward my way, so my way of good is the version we go off of more then the serial killers.
If god exists and said "Blue is Green, and Green is Blue, you jackasses have been screwing it up." Then Blue is really Green, Green is really Blue. If God created everything, then basically God is whatever he wants to be. He's god.
Furthermore, if there is a god. It's highly likely he's a lot smarter then we are and can think and understand stuff we couldn't possibly begin to understand.
I mean when a Nuclear Physisicst starts talking about how a Nuclear Reactor works, and you can't understand it... do you go "That's bullshit!" no of course not... he just knows more about the subject then you do. You gotta take his word for it. Maybe he's BSing you, but you don't know either way, and if he's the expert you are likely going to take his word for it if you can't figure out nuclear physics yourself.
The whole proving there is a god to atheists thing though seems like a fruitless endevour. There is no proof either way, but even if there was a mountain of proof that god existed, plenty of people wouldn't believe it.
God could come down to earth today. Say "Hey, Kasz, I exist, watch me do some crazy stuff." then perform miracle after miracle out of nowhere, and i wouldn't believe it was him based on that, because God could do a bunch of miracles, satan could do a bunch of miracles, some sort of alien could be doing mriacles, guy from the future, i could be hallucinating...
anyway any great number of things could be the cause of it. (Demons, Ra, guy from the past but from a more advanced era, human adbucted but given great power, computer simulation created into this world to screw with people (which would make this world a computer simulation.))
The only thing that would make me believe it was in fact god would be if I felt personally that it was god.
That's where i think most people fail in pushing religion. At best you should just state what your believe and why you believe it, and hope that people get the same inner revelation and feeling that you do. A basic feeling of connection to the origin of the universe.
Otherwise you are basically trying to teach someone to snowboard who has never heard of snow before.









