SlayerRondo said:
So you call the arguments used by Ricky Gervais underdeveloped but then call all athiest who seek to provide arguments against the existence of god are attention whores and not just people seeking to eliminate a commonly held false belief. You then follow this up with the notion that athiest only exist because there is a god without explaining how that makes sense in any way, which is akin to saying if you have to prove something wrong it must be right. All you have done is slander athiest rather than just deal with the arguments they have presented. |
I am not talking about all atheists, just the Rickys of the world and those, like Hitchens, who went and put out books that rehashed old arguments that got refuted. You even had the likes of Hawkings doing the Grand Design, which was not built on solid theological arguments, but old ones that were dealt with awhile ago. Hawkings goes off and declares philosophy dead, for example:
https://www.facebook.com/notes/magis-center-of-reason-and-faith/the-grand-design-or-the-murky-metaphysics-of-stephen-hawking/208376042533858
http://www.butterfliesandwheels.org/2007/are-the-new-atheists-avoiding-the-real-arguments/
When you don't bring anything new to the table, but rehas old arguments and toot a horn as if it is significant, you are an attention whore, railing against things, in hopes to change the world. This is particularly true when you have financial gain for doing such. You hope you can be THE one who does the FINAL nail in the coffin, and then win the world over. It is a religious impulse to convert people to something. In the case of doing what Ricky is doing, it is an attempt to convert people to nothing actually, except one where you stand in awe of Ricky's said genius.
And my calling Ricky an attention whore is accurate (as it would be for anyone working in the media) because his career lives or dies based upon how much people pay attention to him and what he does. Hitchens lived in the same realm also. Others selling books likewise did this. Heck, even Taleb, who wrote "Antifragile" has to be a degree of an attention whore, to get his book sold. And he is very anti-social by the way, and unreachable.