Yeah, I agree with KylieDog on this one actually. Their list pre-seventh-gen kind of holds up as a list of "classics", that although I wouldn't personally put the games on my own list of 10/10 games, I can see where they're coming from.

Then we reach the seventh gen and it completely falls apart. Multiple titles that I don't think will be remembered in the future for being classics in the same way Ocarina / Gran Turismo / Halo are.

No Red dead redemption or bioshock?

Bayonetta definitely deserves its space there. GTA4 is the only one I disagree with.

Two Halo's I don't agree. The first one was incredible, (and deserves the spot) but the third one was decadent.

That list failed 50%

Congrats to The Last of Us! Great list overall in my opinion.

Way too many Mario Games

What are we , like 12 years old ?

hmm not a bad list I guess as they are all subjective.

For me gran turismo 2 was better but I guess the first set the standard for all simulators to beat.

Pretty good list except for GTA4 & LBP .

Rock band too.