First off, i consider 94%+ A must have"System Seller" game even if it dosent move consoles, 92%+ a AAA game that you simply must buy if you own that console and 90%+ a AAA title that cannot be knocked back if you are into that genre... onto the lists.

 *Minimum 20 reviews

XBOX 360 

1 -  The Orange Box - 96.057%

2 -  Bioshock - 95.235%

3 - Call Of Duty 4 - 94.087%

4 - Oblivion - 93.941%

5 - Gears Of War - 93.781%

6 - Halo 3 - 93.357%

7 - Rock Band - 93.137%

8 - Guitar Hero 2 - 91.959%

9 - Mass Effect - 90.721%

10 - GRAW - 90.506%

WII

1 -  Super Mario Galaxy - 97.235%

2 -  Zelda - 93.968%

3 - Resident Evil 4 - 90.995%

4 - Metroid Prime 3 - 89.619%

5 - Guitar Hero 3 - 86.692%

6 - Zack & Wiki - 85.575%

7 - Super Paper Mario - 85.282%

8 - WarioWare - 81.908%

9 - Madden 07 - 81.106%

10 - Trauma Centre - 80.750%

PS3

1 -  Call Of Duty 4 - 93.432%

2 -  Oblivion - 93.216%

3 - Rock Band - 90.835%

4 - Uncharted- 89.773%

5 - Ratchet & Clank - 88.549%

6 - Burnout Paradise - 87.359%

7 - Ninja Gaiden Sigma - 87.076%

8 - Resistance - 86.632%

9 - GRAW 2 - 86.483%

10 - Virtua Fighter 5 - 86.468%

We know who has the best games available =]
xbox360 wins

thats only becasue of the 1 year head start

so? what does that matter you still can buy those games=]

This is why I wonder why people call me a fanboy when I point out that the PS3 has no AAA games. I mean seriously, just look at the list. The PS3 does not have a single exclusive game in the 90's. The 360 has 5 and the Wii has 2 (3 if you count RE4).

Xbox has the most quality games, it's really impressive. I'm so glad I can play all oof them :) But, say, 2-3 years from now, Wii will reign supreme.

@ Starcraft

Uncharted is basically there. And the Wii's only one is SMG. Zelda is a gc game and RE4 has been ported 3 times now it doesn't count.

360 wins this round, but i bet in a years time wii will win this top 10 gamer rankings contest

The problem with this, is that all the sources Gamerankings have are AMERICAN. 75% of the reviews are American, 20 % Japaneese and 5 % European. GR doesn't count Japaneese, so it's 93 % American reviews and 7 % European. Since 360 is a much more liked console in USA, it will of course win.

I am NOT saying that Wii/Ps3 has better games (even though for me, they are) but that Gamerankings isn't objective, beacause NO reviewer is objective, and EVERYONE is nationalistic (is this a word in English?) in some way.

The 1 year head start does make a difference. Seeing as in 2005/early 2006 high def gaming was new to the console front and even crap games were getting higher marks. Also COD4 gets better marks on the 360 than the PS3, when it is a better game on the PS3???? And Oblivion as well, when the PS3 version is better???

Wierd????

Also, 360 top ten is FPS city is it not!!!