By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo - Iwata says he has no plans to resign - was ''misinterpreted''

 

Is Iwata staying a good thing for Nintendo?

Yes, he has done a good job 39 26.90%
 
Yes, but he has to fix some things 64 44.14%
 
No, with Iwata nintendo has no chance 20 13.79%
 
Doesn't matter, Nintendo is doomed anyways 6 4.14%
 
Doesn't matter, Nintendo... 9 6.21%
 
Is nintendo still around? 7 4.83%
 
Total:145
RolStoppable said:
Mr Khan said:
I could see the negative interpretation, that they are now certain they won't meet that goal so he's just claiming it was a bluff or was never said.

Well, they won't meet that goal, because the Wii U is in a deep hole.

Regardless, it doesn't matter whether or not he said that.


Uh.... not necessarily?  They're basing the 1billion yet profit on the strength of 3DS in western markets with the release of Animal Crossing and Pokemon X/Y, and they're probaby assuming they won't need to cut the price of Wii U based on the strength of the upcoming software lineup.

If 3DS continues to climb, and software and hardware sales show good YoY increases in the west, and they can avoid a Wii U price cut on the strength of Wind Waker, DKC, and 3D World, then they should be able to come close, and possibly exceed their targets.  I don't think the "1 billion yen profit" commitment was made in jest.

Surely, Iwata would come under great pressure next January if it becomes clear they cannot reach their goal.  He's not saying so right now, obviously, because they still hope they can make their goal. 



The Screamapillar is easily identified by its constant screaming—it even screams in its sleep. The Screamapillar is the favorite food of everything, is sexually attracted to fire, and needs constant reassurance or it will die.

Around the Network
wfz said:

I feel like whenever VGC talks about video game news, the articles and discussions presented only ever show half the relevant content.

Copy/pasted from NeoGAF:

As first posted in January, Iwata mentioned his "commitment" to a business profit goal of ¥100 billion (US$ 1.1 billion) by the end of the next business year ending in March, 2014. When asked how he would take responsibility if Nintendo did not meet this mark, Iwata replied, "I ask that you understand my use of the word 'commitment.'"

Some in the Japanese media took Iwata's language to mean he would step down should Nintendo fail to reach the magic number.

At a recent investor's meeting, Iwata was asked directly if he would quit if Nintendo doesn't meet his previously stated target. So, will he?

"I don't recall saying I'd resign," Iwata replied. According to Nikkan Sports, the Nintendo honcho went on to say that the game maker should put tremendous effort into achieving its goal and not think about failure. Sounds like Iwata plans on sticking around!

http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=606926

OG: http://kotaku.com/nintendo-boss-didnt-say-hed-quit-yo-606796935

Reason why I don't take investors meeting to heart. Moreso with our asian brothers, even the japanese themselves misunderstand each other... :/



 And proud member of the Mega Mario Movement!

He won't jump but will be pushed next year I think. And it's my opinion he should go too.



Nem said:
I got nothing against him either. I dont think he does a bad job. Its just nintendo doesnt have the resources to properly support two systems at once. They need to expand on the development side.

The problem stems from poor planning and resource management, which as President and CEO, more or less falls at Iwata's feet. It's one thing to say he's a cool guy with a previously strong track record, but he is not doing a good job of guiding the company right now.



I believe in honesty, civility, generosity, practicality, and impartiality.

I think Iwata has done a pretty good job with Nintendo. The DS and the Wii were very tough successes to follow up on, and that he managed to do it with at least one is impressive, and I seriously think the Wii U still has a chance to sell as many lifetime units as the Wii did last gen.

My problem is that he still makes talky-down games for kids. It's not like I want an M-rated Mario game with blood, sex, and guts (although that would definitely be interesting) but that I want something like Batman: The Animated Series. Something clean and energetic enough for kids, but complex and subtle enough for me to enjoy as an adult. Nintendo doesn't really deliver on that too often. Practically the only series that does this somewhat regularly is Zelda.



Around the Network
Mythmaker1 said:
Nem said:
I got nothing against him either. I dont think he does a bad job. Its just nintendo doesnt have the resources to properly support two systems at once. They need to expand on the development side.

The problem stems from poor planning and resource management, which as President and CEO, more or less falls at Iwata's feet. It's one thing to say he's a cool guy with a previously strong track record, but he is not doing a good job of guiding the company right now.


That is a bit harsh.

But yeah, theres room for improvement.



I think Iwata deserves time to see this through. During his reign we have seen the ultra successful Wii, DS, and a now strong showing from the 3DS. Wii U isnt doing too good at present, but its early days and this gen hasnt really started yet. There is plenty of time to turn things around, look at 3DS and PS3 fortunes these days.



I don't think he needs to be completely gone from Nintendo or anything, I'd like to see him stay on, but I think he needs help and doesn't understand the Western market and is also to beholden to the whims of what Miyamoto wants.

NOA should be given more autonomy to help the company, like Howard Lincoln and Minoru Arakawa were. There would be no Retro Studios, no GoldenEye, no Donkey Kong Country, no Star Wars games, etc. without them, they spear headed all those initiatives, today NCL doesn't allow NOA to do anything.



wfz said:

I feel like whenever VGC talks about video game news, the articles and discussions presented only ever show half the relevant content.

Copy/pasted from NeoGAF:

As first posted in January, Iwata mentioned his "commitment" to a business profit goal of ¥100 billion (US$ 1.1 billion) by the end of the next business year ending in March, 2014. When asked how he would take responsibility if Nintendo did not meet this mark, Iwata replied, "I ask that you understand my use of the word 'commitment.'"

Some in the Japanese media took Iwata's language to mean he would step down should Nintendo fail to reach the magic number.

At a recent investor's meeting, Iwata was asked directly if he would quit if Nintendo doesn't meet his previously stated target. So, will he?

"I don't recall saying I'd resign," Iwata replied. According to Nikkan Sports, the Nintendo honcho went on to say that the game maker should put tremendous effort into achieving its goal and not think about failure. Sounds like Iwata plans on sticking around!

http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=606926

OG: http://kotaku.com/nintendo-boss-didnt-say-hed-quit-yo-606796935

I'm going to quote this too because I can see people continuing to talk as though the initial 'quote' was correct and this doesn't exist.

Iwata reigned over Nintendo's most successful years, calling for his blood after 1-2 poor years (years between console generations are always lower on profit anyway) is premature.



hsrob said:
wfz said:

I feel like whenever VGC talks about video game news, the articles and discussions presented only ever show half the relevant content.

Copy/pasted from NeoGAF:

As first posted in January, Iwata mentioned his "commitment" to a business profit goal of ¥100 billion (US$ 1.1 billion) by the end of the next business year ending in March, 2014. When asked how he would take responsibility if Nintendo did not meet this mark, Iwata replied, "I ask that you understand my use of the word 'commitment.'"

Some in the Japanese media took Iwata's language to mean he would step down should Nintendo fail to reach the magic number.

At a recent investor's meeting, Iwata was asked directly if he would quit if Nintendo doesn't meet his previously stated target. So, will he?

"I don't recall saying I'd resign," Iwata replied. According to Nikkan Sports, the Nintendo honcho went on to say that the game maker should put tremendous effort into achieving its goal and not think about failure. Sounds like Iwata plans on sticking around!

http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=606926

OG: http://kotaku.com/nintendo-boss-didnt-say-hed-quit-yo-606796935

I'm going to quote this too because I can see people continuing to talk as though the initial 'quote' was correct and this doesn't exist.

Iwata reigned over Nintendo's most successful years, calling for his blood after 1-2 poor years (years between console generations are always lower on profit anyway) is premature.


Nintendo's been decling for about 4 years now from the peak days of the Wii/DS and he's botched both the 3DS and Wii U launches despite having ample time to learn from his mistakes. Ken Kutaragi was given the axe after a few months of the PS3, even though he basically built the entire Playstation division and the PS1 + PS2 sold 250+ million consoles worldwide.

I agree he should be given some slack, but I think he should also acknowledge he needs some help as he's obviously made several poor decisions in guiding the company since the Wii peaked in 2009 or so and consequently put the company in bad positions with both the 3DS and again with the Wii U.

There should not be such wild highs and lows, of the Wii being the fastest selling console ever for its first few years, to then rapidly declining, and then the successor to Wii being basically the slowest selling console out of the gate since the Dreamcast or Saturn. Unacceptable, especially when they had years to prep for this launch.