By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - Which Naughty Dog team is better?

 

Which Naughty Dog team is better?

The team behind Uncharted 3. 2 2.63%
 
The team behind The Last of Us. 25 32.89%
 
They're both amazing. 49 64.47%
 
Total:76
VGKing said:
You should replace the word "studio" with "teams".

No one can answer the question but if I had to I'd say the first team seeing as how they've made 3 great games.

Both teams worked on uncharted 1&2 it only after part 2 did they spilt into two. 



 

Bet with gooch_destroyer, he wins if FFX and FFX-2 will be at $40 each for the vita. I win if it dont

Sign up if you want to see God Eater 2 get localized!! https://www.change.org/petitions/shift-inc-bring-god-eater-2-to-north-america-2#share

Around the Network
VGKing said:
You should replace the word "studio" with "teams".

No one can answer the question but if I had to I'd say the first team seeing as how they've made 3 great games.


Technically they've both made 3 great games this gen. Seeing as they all worked on Uncharted 1 and 2 together.



I find UC2 to be a much better game than TLOU. Just feels more fun and the atmosphere isn't so gory and dark (something I'm getting tired of from video games).



Dgc1808 said:
Naughty Dog has addressed this A Team B Team crap before. It's not as if there's a division between the work force and it's now two separate entities under the same label. There are people in ND that have worked on U2 and U3. There are people that have worked on U3 and TLoU. There are people that have worked on all 3 games. It's not that they have become 2 completely separate teams, they've just become a 2 game developer instead of one at a time.


I see your point, and yes they have said that there are people who have worked on both games. That makes perfect sense, but the key people who are behind the game, for example, game directors, lead designers and head producers are different for each game, essentially making 2 teams in one amazing studio.

That's not to say that they still don't act as one studio, they are still one studio, but they have split some of their workers in order to increase efficiency. That being said I don't think we'll ever see them label themselves as team A and team B, they are Naughty Dog, that's who they are.



Dgc1808 said:
Naughty Dog has addressed this A Team B Team crap before. It's not as if there's a division between the work force and it's now two separate entities under the same label. There are people in ND that have worked on U2 and U3. There are people that have worked on U3 and TLoU. There are people that have worked on all 3 games. It's not that they have become 2 completely separate teams, they've just become a 2 game developer instead of one at a time.

Yup, this. There is no clear division between the two teams and therefore no team that is better than the other.



Around the Network

Uncharted 2 team, which I also presume is TLOU team.



TheNoobHolocaust said:
VGKing said:
You should replace the word "studio" with "teams".

No one can answer the question but if I had to I'd say the first team seeing as how they've made 3 great games.


Technically they've both made 3 great games this gen. Seeing as they all worked on Uncharted 1 and 2 together.

Unlikely. The original team wasn't split. They obviously hired more people as making 2 games at once with the same workforce as you made 1 before is impossible.



Well the team behind the Last of Us was a lot of who worked on U2, and I'd have to say that team was better. But only by a little, because honestly all of Naughty Dog is amazing :)



I make videos that are sometimes funny I think?

Check out my Youtube gaming channel here!

i count them as the same entity just like i count all the same AC makers the same



I haven't played either of them and unfortunately won't get the chance to, but I think Unchartered 3 looks more fun.



    

NNID: FrequentFlyer54