By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Politics - a increasingly apartheid Israel?

 

What should be done with Israel?

Nothing 17 26.56%
 
International Condeming 6 9.38%
 
Sanctions 7 10.94%
 
Reduction of aid to Israel 12 18.75%
 
Just let them sort it out themselves, no aid 20 31.25%
 
other 2 3.13%
 
Total:64

Let them sort themselves out, no aid.



Around the Network
Kasz216 said:
the2real4mafol said:
If anyone can defend this action, they are basically saying to me that segregation between black and white people in the USA (especially the southern states) in the 1950's and 1960's was just, which it was not. Anyway, bring it on!

It's only a comparble situation if you consider the Palestinian territories part of Israel.  Also you know... if they were actually being segregated. (they aren't.)


Even then... not really afterall people of Palestinians who actually LIVE in Israel and are Israeli citizens still have to use the regular buses.

Additionally, they haven't actually stopped anyone from using normal bus lines.  Instead just having a discounted one for palestinian workers.  If you read the article you posted.

A similar situation would be if the US had special discounted busses for Mexican day labourers who came from mexico to work in the US and then return to Mexico... though the mexican labourers aren't actually forced to use the discounted bus, you'd just be stupid not to.  Meanwhile for mexican US citizens it's buisness as usual.

I mean there is a lot of shit you can critisize israel for, but this is just such a reach I can only conclude you didn't even read the entirity of the article you posted.  On balance, as it stands now, this is a huge net positve for Palestinian workers.  Could Israel abuse it in the future?  Sure, anything can be abused in the future.  Right now your ciritisizing something that will greatly improve the lives of Palestinian workers because I can imagine bus fare is expensive as hell.

The only people I can think of that should actually be against this are MAYBE Stickball and Kantor who think race based advantages and even then this is more based on roughly "nationalism" then race.  So probably not.

Maybe some libretarians would be against it on Social engineering terms. 

In some ways, they are segregated though. There have a massive wall right in front of them, Palestinians are contained within their region, like they are prisoners. There are certainly denied freedom of movement, thanks to Israel. Even though, most of them are not fanatics and just want to live their normal lives. 

As for the bus thing, it says that palestinians get their own buses because Israelis think they are "security risk". How is that not racist? That assuming all Arabs are dangerous, unstable loonies that love to blow shit up. Most Arabs are not like this. But If it the buses are cheaper for them anyway, i guess that's good but that wasn't so obvious in the article. Part of my problem, is that the "security risk" excuse could be used to segregate palestinians against anything in the future, even if it's not like that now.

Also, i wish conservatives could stop calling people like me who criticise Israel, anti-semitic it's really pathetic. (that's not aimed at anyone here) But Zionism is just a bad ideology like all the other forms of nationalism and fascism. 

Anyway, i think it's about time the US stood back and let Israel run itself.



Xbox Series, PS5 and Switch (+ Many Retro Consoles)

'When the people are being beaten with a stick, they are not much happier if it is called the people's stick'- Mikhail Bakunin

Prediction: Switch 2 will outsell the PS5 by 2030

the2real4mafol said:
Kasz216 said:
the2real4mafol said:
If anyone can defend this action, they are basically saying to me that segregation between black and white people in the USA (especially the southern states) in the 1950's and 1960's was just, which it was not. Anyway, bring it on!

It's only a comparble situation if you consider the Palestinian territories part of Israel.  Also you know... if they were actually being segregated. (they aren't.)


Even then... not really afterall people of Palestinians who actually LIVE in Israel and are Israeli citizens still have to use the regular buses.

Additionally, they haven't actually stopped anyone from using normal bus lines.  Instead just having a discounted one for palestinian workers.  If you read the article you posted.

A similar situation would be if the US had special discounted busses for Mexican day labourers who came from mexico to work in the US and then return to Mexico... though the mexican labourers aren't actually forced to use the discounted bus, you'd just be stupid not to.  Meanwhile for mexican US citizens it's buisness as usual.

I mean there is a lot of shit you can critisize israel for, but this is just such a reach I can only conclude you didn't even read the entirity of the article you posted.  On balance, as it stands now, this is a huge net positve for Palestinian workers.  Could Israel abuse it in the future?  Sure, anything can be abused in the future.  Right now your ciritisizing something that will greatly improve the lives of Palestinian workers because I can imagine bus fare is expensive as hell.

The only people I can think of that should actually be against this are MAYBE Stickball and Kantor who think race based advantages and even then this is more based on roughly "nationalism" then race.  So probably not.

Maybe some libretarians would be against it on Social engineering terms. 

In some ways, they are segregated though. There have a massive wall right in front of them, Palestinians are contained within their region, like they are prisoners. There are certainly denied freedom of movement, thanks to Israel. Even though, most of them are not fanatics and just want to live their normal lives. 

As for the bus thing, it says that palestinians get their own buses because Israelis think they are "security risk". How is that not racist? That assuming all Arabs are dangerous, unstable loonies that love to blow shit up. Most Arabs are not like this. But If it the buses are cheaper for them anyway, i guess that's good but that wasn't so obvious in the article. Part of my problem, is that the "security risk" excuse could be used to segregate palestinians against anything in the future, even if it's not like that now.

Also, i wish conservatives could stop calling people like me who criticise Israel, anti-semitic it's really pathetic. (that's not aimed at anyone here) But Zionism is just a bad ideology like all the other forms of nationalism and fascism. 

Anyway, i think it's about time the US stood back and let Israel run itself.

A)Again.  Do you see all of the Palestinian territories as a part of Israel?

If so.  Ok, You believe in a one state solution and that's a difference of opinion between us.  You also disagree with both the Israelis and Palestinians. 

Otherwise, it's one country preventing people an area wanting to be a country from entering lands they claim.  Is it wrong the US just doesn't let anyone from Mexico or Canada into the country unless we check them?

Though you know... massivly off topic.

 

B)  That's what the article says.  It's not quoting anyone, or anything for that matter.  They just said that's why because "Readership! Scandolous!"

I mean, lets look at this with common sense. 

Israeli settelrs are afraid of terrorists so they give the Palestinians their own cheap bus.

So the plan to stop this is to

1) Give Palestinians a cheaper bus they can ride on.

2) NOT force Palestinians to ride on that bus, letting them still ride on the buses here.

Maybe it's me, but that sounds like a plan to INCREASE terrorist attacks.  Since now you don't have to worry about blowing up as many of your own countrymen.

3) Israeli's aren't afraid of Palestinians riding on buses with them, they are afraid of people from the Palestinian territories riding on buses with them.  Which you know.  Considering they are technically still at war that's a perfectly reasonable worry.

Would you consider it racist if South Koreans were afraid to ride on the same bus as North Koreans?  I'd think not, and to my knowledge North Koreans don't have a history of a small group of themselves suicide bombing others in public.

 

Again note, this is only for people in the Palestine territories, who are still at war with Israel.  Palestinians in Israel?  No change.  To call it racist is to not really understand the word.



I recently realized what the fundamental problem of the middle-east conflict is:

The fact that Israel doesn't even really know what it wants - this is, what to do with the palestinians. Their leaders do not want the peace process because there is simply no solution that wouldn't split the population. Both the one-state solution and the two-state-solution would piss a lot of people off. They don't even have a plan, so instead of actually going into the peace process, their leaders are simply doing anything to avoid it.

If a powerful person (like Obama?) actually wanted to solve the middle-east process, the solution isn't finding the perfect solution, but forcing the Israeli government to finally decide what they want.



Kasz216 said:
the2real4mafol said:

In some ways, they are segregated though. There have a massive wall right in front of them, Palestinians are contained within their region, like they are prisoners. There are certainly denied freedom of movement, thanks to Israel. Even though, most of them are not fanatics and just want to live their normal lives. 

As for the bus thing, it says that palestinians get their own buses because Israelis think they are "security risk". How is that not racist? That assuming all Arabs are dangerous, unstable loonies that love to blow shit up. Most Arabs are not like this. But If it the buses are cheaper for them anyway, i guess that's good but that wasn't so obvious in the article. Part of my problem, is that the "security risk" excuse could be used to segregate palestinians against anything in the future, even if it's not like that now.

Also, i wish conservatives could stop calling people like me who criticise Israel, anti-semitic it's really pathetic. (that's not aimed at anyone here) But Zionism is just a bad ideology like all the other forms of nationalism and fascism. 

Anyway, i think it's about time the US stood back and let Israel run itself.

A)Again.  Do you see all of the Palestinian territories as a part of Israel?

If so.  Ok, You believe in a one state solution and that's a difference of opinion between us.  You also disagree with both the Israelis and Palestinians. 

Otherwise, it's one country preventing people an area wanting to be a country from entering lands they claim.  Is it wrong the US just doesn't let anyone from Mexico or Canada into the country unless we check them?

Though you know... massivly off topic.

 

B)  That's what the article says.  It's not quoting anyone, or anything for that matter.  They just said that's why because "Readership! Scandolous!"

I mean, lets look at this with common sense. 

Israeli settelrs are afraid of terrorists so they give the Palestinians their own cheap bus.

So the plan to stop this is to

1) Give Palestinians a cheaper bus they can ride on.

2) NOT force Palestinians to ride on that bus, letting them still ride on the buses here.

Maybe it's me, but that sounds like a plan to INCREASE terrorist attacks.  Since now you don't have to worry about blowing up as many of your own countrymen.

3) Israeli's aren't afraid of Palestinians riding on buses with them, they are afraid of people from the Palestinian territories riding on buses with them.  Which you know.  Considering they are technically still at war that's a perfectly reasonable worry.

Would you consider it racist if South Koreans were afraid to ride on the same bus as North Koreans?  I'd think not, and to my knowledge North Koreans don't have a history of a small group of themselves suicide bombing others in public.

 

Again note, this is only for people in the Palestine territories, who are still at war with Israel.  Palestinians in Israel?  No change.  To call it racist is to not really understand the word.

A.) I want a two state solution, but i just don't how they would agree to split it up, i guess Palestinians would get the southern half, since gaza and the west bank are in the southern half anyway. But it just seems both sides have opportunities to make that happen and they just do what they can to continue fighting each other instead. It's like they like war. Also, i currently see the occupied terrorities as apart of Israel, because of Israel's increased presence in such places.

B.) My problem here is that like people in the west, Israelis are assuming that Muslims/ palestinians are terrorists. It's a very bad stereotype.

1 and 2)  Thats fair enough i guess

3) I doubt that the 2 Koreans are scared of each other, it's just there governments that people are scared of. It's very hard to distinguish between a North Korean and South Korean. Without North Korean government, North Korea would just be Korea.

Maybe that isn't racist, but the way things are in Israel, the whole situation is just illmoral.



Xbox Series, PS5 and Switch (+ Many Retro Consoles)

'When the people are being beaten with a stick, they are not much happier if it is called the people's stick'- Mikhail Bakunin

Prediction: Switch 2 will outsell the PS5 by 2030

Around the Network
the2real4mafol said:
Kasz216 said:
the2real4mafol said:

In some ways, they are segregated though. There have a massive wall right in front of them, Palestinians are contained within their region, like they are prisoners. There are certainly denied freedom of movement, thanks to Israel. Even though, most of them are not fanatics and just want to live their normal lives. 

As for the bus thing, it says that palestinians get their own buses because Israelis think they are "security risk". How is that not racist? That assuming all Arabs are dangerous, unstable loonies that love to blow shit up. Most Arabs are not like this. But If it the buses are cheaper for them anyway, i guess that's good but that wasn't so obvious in the article. Part of my problem, is that the "security risk" excuse could be used to segregate palestinians against anything in the future, even if it's not like that now.

Also, i wish conservatives could stop calling people like me who criticise Israel, anti-semitic it's really pathetic. (that's not aimed at anyone here) But Zionism is just a bad ideology like all the other forms of nationalism and fascism. 

Anyway, i think it's about time the US stood back and let Israel run itself.

A)Again.  Do you see all of the Palestinian territories as a part of Israel?

If so.  Ok, You believe in a one state solution and that's a difference of opinion between us.  You also disagree with both the Israelis and Palestinians. 

Otherwise, it's one country preventing people an area wanting to be a country from entering lands they claim.  Is it wrong the US just doesn't let anyone from Mexico or Canada into the country unless we check them?

Though you know... massivly off topic.

 

B)  That's what the article says.  It's not quoting anyone, or anything for that matter.  They just said that's why because "Readership! Scandolous!"

I mean, lets look at this with common sense. 

Israeli settelrs are afraid of terrorists so they give the Palestinians their own cheap bus.

So the plan to stop this is to

1) Give Palestinians a cheaper bus they can ride on.

2) NOT force Palestinians to ride on that bus, letting them still ride on the buses here.

Maybe it's me, but that sounds like a plan to INCREASE terrorist attacks.  Since now you don't have to worry about blowing up as many of your own countrymen.

3) Israeli's aren't afraid of Palestinians riding on buses with them, they are afraid of people from the Palestinian territories riding on buses with them.  Which you know.  Considering they are technically still at war that's a perfectly reasonable worry.

Would you consider it racist if South Koreans were afraid to ride on the same bus as North Koreans?  I'd think not, and to my knowledge North Koreans don't have a history of a small group of themselves suicide bombing others in public.

 

Again note, this is only for people in the Palestine territories, who are still at war with Israel.  Palestinians in Israel?  No change.  To call it racist is to not really understand the word.

A.) I want a two state solution, but i just don't how they would agree to split it up, i guess Palestinians would get the southern half, since gaza and the west bank are in the southern half anyway. But it just seems both sides have opportunities to make that happen and they just do what they can to continue fighting each other instead. It's like they like war. Also, i currently see the occupied terrorities as apart of Israel, because of Israel's increased presence in such places.

B.) My problem here is that like people in the west, Israelis are assuming that Muslims/ palestinians are terrorists. It's a very bad stereotype.

1 and 2)  Thats fair enough i guess

3) I doubt that the 2 Koreans are scared of each other, it's just there governments that people are scared of. It's very hard to distinguish between a North Korean and South Korean. Without North Korean government, North Korea would just be Korea.

Maybe that isn't racist, but the way things are in Israel, the whole situation is just illmoral.

 

Well first off Jewish and Palestinian people don't really look all that different.  Dressed the same you'd be hard pressed to tell them apart by looking at them. 

Genetically they're VERY similar.

http://epiphenom.fieldofscience.com/2009/01/shared-genetic-heritage-of-jews-and.html

You may be getting confused by the more successful Jews like John Stewart and Louis Black who have intermixed so much with europeons they're essentially white ethnicity wise.  Only not seen as such due to culture.

 

Secondly, that North Koreans and South Koreans look exactly the same makes it MORE terrifying, not less.  If your main worry is Al Queda and muslins are only like 10% of your population... you've mostly only got to worry about 10% of your population. (Barring the occasional white or black Al Queda operative.)

If your afraid of North Koreans, and 97% of your country is Koreans.   ANYBODY could be a North Korean Spy.



Kasz216 said:
the2real4mafol said:
Kasz216 said:

A)Again.  Do you see all of the Palestinian territories as a part of Israel?

If so.  Ok, You believe in a one state solution and that's a difference of opinion between us.  You also disagree with both the Israelis and Palestinians. 

Otherwise, it's one country preventing people an area wanting to be a country from entering lands they claim.  Is it wrong the US just doesn't let anyone from Mexico or Canada into the country unless we check them?

Though you know... massivly off topic.

 

B)  That's what the article says.  It's not quoting anyone, or anything for that matter.  They just said that's why because "Readership! Scandolous!"

I mean, lets look at this with common sense. 

Israeli settelrs are afraid of terrorists so they give the Palestinians their own cheap bus.

So the plan to stop this is to

1) Give Palestinians a cheaper bus they can ride on.

2) NOT force Palestinians to ride on that bus, letting them still ride on the buses here.

Maybe it's me, but that sounds like a plan to INCREASE terrorist attacks.  Since now you don't have to worry about blowing up as many of your own countrymen.

3) Israeli's aren't afraid of Palestinians riding on buses with them, they are afraid of people from the Palestinian territories riding on buses with them.  Which you know.  Considering they are technically still at war that's a perfectly reasonable worry.

Would you consider it racist if South Koreans were afraid to ride on the same bus as North Koreans?  I'd think not, and to my knowledge North Koreans don't have a history of a small group of themselves suicide bombing others in public.

 

Again note, this is only for people in the Palestine territories, who are still at war with Israel.  Palestinians in Israel?  No change.  To call it racist is to not really understand the word.

A.) I want a two state solution, but i just don't how they would agree to split it up, i guess Palestinians would get the southern half, since gaza and the west bank are in the southern half anyway. But it just seems both sides have opportunities to make that happen and they just do what they can to continue fighting each other instead. It's like they like war. Also, i currently see the occupied terrorities as apart of Israel, because of Israel's increased presence in such places.

B.) My problem here is that like people in the west, Israelis are assuming that Muslims/ palestinians are terrorists. It's a very bad stereotype.

1 and 2)  Thats fair enough i guess

3) I doubt that the 2 Koreans are scared of each other, it's just there governments that people are scared of. It's very hard to distinguish between a North Korean and South Korean. Without North Korean government, North Korea would just be Korea.

Maybe that isn't racist, but the way things are in Israel, the whole situation is just illmoral.

 

Well first off Jewish and Palestinian people don't really look all that different.  Dressed the same you'd be hard pressed to tell them apart by looking at them. 

Genetically they're VERY similar.

http://epiphenom.fieldofscience.com/2009/01/shared-genetic-heritage-of-jews-and.html

You may be getting confused by the more successful Jews like John Stewart and Louis Black who have intermixed so much with europeons they're essentially white ethnicity wise.  Only not seen as such due to culture.

 

Secondly, that North Koreans and South Koreans look exactly the same makes it MORE terrifying, not less.  If your main worry is Al Queda and muslins are only like 10% of your population... you've mostly only got to worry about 10% of your population. (Barring the occasional white or black Al Queda operative.)

If your afraid of North Koreans, and 97% of your country is Koreans.   ANYBODY could be a North Korean Spy.

There's not much difference at all in culture for them either from the looks of it, just a different language, talking about this, just makes the conflict between Israel and Palestine look rediculous. I guess it's all due to politics. Also, i had no idea John Stewart was Jewish. Never heard of Louis Black.

But as for Korea, i just feel that if any North Koreans actually escaped to the south, they wouldn't do that and i doubt the North has money to send spies south, when it can barely feed it's army. There is always the risk though, i guess but any North Korean spies were probably killed during the Park regime in the 1960's and 1970's.   



Xbox Series, PS5 and Switch (+ Many Retro Consoles)

'When the people are being beaten with a stick, they are not much happier if it is called the people's stick'- Mikhail Bakunin

Prediction: Switch 2 will outsell the PS5 by 2030

Must be a pain in the ass for Obama... The Jewish lobby was and is huge in USA and is important for the $$$..

but the muslim one is getting huge aswell and with an rise of the muslim demographic in the USA it also increase how important they are for votes and for $$$$$... You had the same effect in West European countries where the pro israel political parties died or changed into pro palestina parties....


I believe Israel is fucked. They can't count on their best friend anymore..



 

Well first off, there should be no foreign aid to anyone.

But as far as this, I don't really care. Leave them be, it's their country.



The settlements are a very bad idea because it forces either this or an Israeli minority in their own country.