By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Website Topics - How do you feel about the performance of the VGChartz mod team?

 

How is the VGChartz mod team doing?

It's doing a great job. 299 32.97%
 
It's doing okay. 143 15.77%
 
It's not doing well. 432 47.63%
 
Total:874
Carl2291 said:

I dont have an agenda and I have questioned/ disagreed with moderations here in the past since I have been on the team.

I told you what I saw, what others saw and (I assume) what Mr Khan saw. Like I said earlier, you could have just said that the "PC master race" would be disgusted with it and there would probably have been no problem. You didnt though, you posted a gif of some kid crying. Look at it from someone elses point of view and see how it would offend someone to be compared to that kid in the gif.

Edit - And yeah, on the length it was wrong because whoever unbanned you made the mistake of not putting a note in your mod history.

My assumption honestly was that the kid was having some kind of epileptic seizure, which was an endeavor to goad the PC base with comparisons to an individual with medical problems, or some kind of ableist insult.

A more non-controversial choice for the future would be a simple "head explode" gif.



Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.

Around the Network
ClassicGamingWizzz said:
Another awsome ban by no other than Mr Khan , i think this one sees attacks to people in every posts , my last ban 7 or 8 months ago was by him and it was similar, a shit ban where he assumes people is attacking a fanbase.

this post by Rol says it all :

"Because if every little thing is moderated, then these forums quickly turn into a place that is ruled by sissies who cry for mommy at every opportunity."

And is what some moderators here do, they ban everytime one of these butthurt sissies reports.

BTW , i was banned for flaming 5 days by mr khan 7 months ago last year, for basicly nothing , then conegamer banned me months ago BUT AXUMBLADE UNBANNED ME , the ban was 1 day and had no effect , then this guy bans me 3 days ? If i had a ban that was removed and it was 1 day , the next ban should be 1 day no? seriously this is BS.

I dont know how the hell mr Khan is still a mod here or anywhere, its not only me who say it just read this thread and now Axumblade is not even in the site and you can´t call him when you see these bans.
No wonder why people is going away left and right.

Might as well quote this directly, so you can see my reply to carl above for my interpretation of what the gif meant.

The matter with you being unbanned, really, should have been left with a note on your mod record, then it would only have been for a day had the record called for it. That one's on Axum.



Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.

JayWood2010 said:
ClassicGamingWizzz said:


I dont know how the hell mr Khan is still a mod here or anywhere, its not only me who say it just read this thread and now Axumblade is not even in the site and you can´t call him when you see these bans.
No wonder why people is going away left and right.

Nobody knows why he is a mod, or at least this is the impresssions ive gotten from people i talk with.  Dont argue it though, there really is no use.  In other words your wasting your time.  When all is said and done the mods will always have each other on their side whether the community agrees or not(These guys are friends afterall).  The pezus ban will forever stick in my head.  

#UndergroundMovement




The key is we became friends after we became mods. I really didn't know much about a lot of the team until i joined up (or they joined after i did). Mostly just Smeags i was really tight with (though i like to think i was a deciding factor in getting Kresnik on board )



Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.

Fusioncode said:
morenoingrato said:
ClassicGamingWizzz said:

 

You just just assuming the kid is whiny little cry baby and you see he whine where , its a gif. KId is a mess yes  that is why i posted it, its disgusted with something. Same way pc master race would be with the thread , they would feel disgusted by the thread. You just assuming i posted it to call pc master race guys whiny little kids cause it fits your agenda of defending the moderation.

 

Have a nice day.

Was flamebait, and you know it.

Feels so good to be one who reported you.

 

Moderated - Kresnik.

Why was this moderated?

He's taunting CGW; look at his reactions in this thread over the past couple days and then imagine the possible reaction from this comment. Saying you reported another user in the forums really does add nothing and we've had several cases in the past where users have been warned or banned for the same thing. 

 

JayWood2010 said:
ClassicGamingWizzz said:


I dont know how the hell mr Khan is still a mod here or anywhere, its not only me who say it just read this thread and now Axumblade is not even in the site and you can´t call him when you see these bans.
No wonder why people is going away left and right.

Nobody knows why he is a mod, or at least this is the impresssions ive gotten from people i talk with.  Dont argue it though, there really is no use.  In other words your wasting your time.  When all is said and done the mods will always have each other on their side whether the community agrees or not(These guys are friends afterall).  The pezus ban will forever stick in my head.  

#UndergroundMovement

 

Actually I've disagreed with several moderations whilst I've been a moderator and also had other mods disagree with me. But that's good, as the whole job would be easy (and we wouldn't need as big a mod team) if we all agreed all the time. The point is to get a variety of different viewpoints and come to an agreement at the end of it, something I feel like we achieve at least 95% of the time. 

Similarly I could only really say that Smeags and Krezzy were my "friends" on this site before I became a moderator, though I can't say that's the case now. Having said that, if one of those two (or another mod) did something that I disagree with or feel is wrong, then I will say so. Heck a couple days ago I disagreed with Axum and how he slipped up by not putting in a mod note about the overruled ban, hence giving CGW a ban which was unjust in length. We have disagreements but given what we're doing that's natural, which we can then discuss and debate so everyone receives fair and just action. So at the end of the day, the community benefits at the end of it.



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.

Mr Khan said:
JayWood2010 said:





The key is we became friends after we became mods. I really didn't know much about a lot of the team until i joined up (or they joined after i did). Mostly just Smeags i was really tight with (though i like to think i was a deciding factor in getting Kresnik on board )


I know this.  Mod chat, its not surprising really.  Im glad you guys are friends though.




       

Around the Network
Conegamer said:
Fusioncode said:


Not what im saying.  Im saying that you all disregard the community and just use each other instead, which more likely than not will agree with each other.   Now i cant speak for th community 4 years ago but since ive visited this site activley iv become one of the most active people on this site.  And from day 1 ive continued to see the same results.  A lot of bans are nitpicky, some people do have more leverage than others, continued stealth trolling from users is still rampant,  and on occasions ive even seen mods make rules up as they go along.  

When it all comes down to it you all can do whatever you all want.  Youre leaders of the community without any real leadership.  All we can do is question you guys, but in the end we really dont have much say as the past has proven.




       

JayWood2010 said:

Dont argue it though, there really is no use.  In other words your wasting your time.  When all is said and done the mods will always have each other on their side whether the community agrees or not(These guys are friends afterall).  The pezus ban will forever stick in my head.  

#UndergroundMovement

-

JayWood2010 said:

Im saying that you all disregard the community and just use each other instead, which more likely than not will agree with each other.   Now i cant speak for th community 4 years ago but since ive visited this site activley iv become one of the most active people on this site.  And from day 1 ive continued to see the same results.  A lot of bans are nitpicky, some people do have more leverage than others, continued stealth trolling from users is still rampant,  and on occasions ive even seen mods make rules up as they go along.  

When it all comes down to it you all can do whatever you all want.  Youre leaders of the community without any real leadership.  All we can do is question you guys, but in the end we really dont have much say as the past has proven.


Soooooo...

Whats the problem this time? What are you disagreeing with? What is to question?

Or is this just a rant about how you dont like how we run things again?



                            

JayWood2010 said:

Not what im saying.  Im saying that you all disregard the community and just use each other instead, which more likely than not will agree with each other.   Now i cant speak for th community 4 years ago but since ive visited this site activley iv become one of the most active people on this site.  And from day 1 ive continued to see the same results.  A lot of bans are nitpicky, some people do have more leverage than others, continued stealth trolling from users is still rampant,  and on occasions ive even seen mods make rules up as they go along.  

When it all comes down to it you all can do whatever you all want.  Youre leaders of the community without any real leadership.  All we can do is question you guys, but in the end we really dont have much say as the past has proven.

Well, we're still members of the community. Bans aren't nitpicky and no users have leverage over others, it's all a matter of following the rules and moderating people who break them. Ofcourse users have a say in what happens and what we do, we listen to the feedback and I at the very least take things onboard when examples are pointed out and I can learn from these mistakes (something I feel I have done). 

You know, this would be much easier if you could, say, provide examples of moderations which you have problems with. Else it's just guesswork on our part and you just criticising for the sake of it, and how can we improve with that? The answer to that should be clear.

 

EDIT - Seeing your latest post makes me believe that this is indeed targeted at a certain user and perhaps a certain post. So if you provide examples then this would be highly useful!



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.

Carl2291 said:
JayWood2010 said:

 


Soooooo...

Whats the problem this time? What are you disagreeing with? What is to question?

Or is this just a rant about how you dont like how we run things again?


Youre always such a lovely person, have i ever told you that :3

Obviously im replying to somebody as you can see in my posts above but youre more than welcome to make a sarcastic/condesending remark :)   But yes there is problems with the mods and im certainly not going to lie about that just to make you all feel better. I absolutely have no faith you all will fix them

EDIT: ConeG Id really prfer you dont reply to me at all.  I choose to ignore most of your posts for a reason




       

JayWood2010 said:
Carl2291 said:


Soooooo...

Whats the problem this time? What are you disagreeing with? What is to question?

Or is this just a rant about how you dont like how we run things again?


Youre always such a lovely person, have i ever told you that :3

Obviously im replying to somebody as you can see in my posts above but youre more than welcome to make a sarcastic/condesending remark :)   But yes there is problems with the mods and im certainly not going to lie about that just to make you all feel better.

Are you interested in telling us what's bothering you this time around or are you still only interested in vague statements once more?



Signature goes here!