The only thing I don't understand is how more Nintendo games didn't make it. What is Zelda SS? Seems like it should be up there. GTA4 gets SO much hate, but it deserves what it got. There hasn't been a game yet that's reach it's size and scope. Technically, it's the most impressive game this gen console wise. Nothing even comes close.

^^^size and scope??? LOL Just Cause2 says hi

Why isn't Demon's Souls on that list, Bioshock, Uncharted 2, LBP and Batman AC do deserves to be there though.

No, SMG2 should be at the top. Way too many games to make a list of what would come after.

Like many have already said this a million times, GTA4 should be out of the list. It should be higher 80s or lower 90s at best. I expected MGS4 or Halo 3 to be there. Also, I'm surprised at BM:AC. Is the game as good as the critics say? Lack of Zelda SS or even Zelda TP makes me sad =(

I agree about both Galaxies. They're truly masterpieces, and it's really difficult to choose one over the other.

GTA4 is the one i highly disagree with it... However, thiss a decent list of games, that depending on taste.

The 2 best games by far this gen imo are demon soul's and deus ex, and neither are up there... but meh that's me.

The orange box is dumb to have in this list because its a collection of games, not a single game. If you buy it on steam, it lists them all as separete games O_o.

I agree with the Mario Galaxies, Bioshock and the Orange Box (should be 1, imo). GTA IV was a technical achievement so maybe thats why it has such a score. It fails as a videogame trying too much to be a real life simulator though.

Also, Twilight Princess has a 95 too (96 for the GC version). Little Big Planet has nothing to do there, give that spot to Zelda pls.

Skyrim on 360 at 96 lol I guess the one on pc is at 115

Halo 3 was a perfect game.