By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Why not to buy Wii U: Activision is better than Nintendo

Turkish said:
happydolphin said:
Turkish said:

Thats so very not Nintendo, to buy studios from others lol. Anyway, I just proved Nintendo hasnt made any new hardcore IPs with the Wii, exceot for Xenoblade then. lol

1 case was sufficient to disprove your sweeping generalization. lolz?
Also, my second post to you might also help. HTH


Not.at.all. If it wasnt for some fans Xenoblade wouldnt even have released in the West lol.

In that case you probably don't understand logic.

Your initial claim:

"Sorry but none of those games are "big" and none of them are hardcore.", in regards to a list that included Xenoblade Chronicles.

Read this wikipedia entry on Counterexample. Me pointing out that Xenoblade Chronicles is hardcore (for older gamers) and a Nintendo game basically disproves your claim.

Did I misinterpret what you were trying to say in your initial claim? If so, my bad, but I only read what was written, help me read it differently.



Around the Network
Gilgamesh said:
Chrizum said:
Gilgamesh said:
Aielyn said:
Gilgamesh said:
Significant_leap said:
"Activision better than Nintendo"
that just made my day xD


Alright we get it, you are highly negative towards the article, there's no point in posting pointless comments over and over like you've been doing, if your that disgusted with the guy that wrote it go post a comment on his website, not this thread.

... excuse me, but you are clearly highly positive towards the article, and you had nothing further to say about it when you made the thread. Hypocrisy, much?

Clearly you haven't noticed I do sometimes post a lot of articles. I just look for popular article and post them here, most I don't even care about that's why I don't post in them, I'm just delivering some news and discussion worthy threads.

Don't shoot the messenger.

Oh Gilgamesh you crack me up time and time again. If there would be an award for "most useless thread starter" it would go to you every single time. People can't repeatedly post how they disagree with the articles you post yet you repeatedly post the same kind of articles while you so called "don't even care" about them.

Try posting articles you do care about or stop policing your threads if you care so little for them.

I don't care if you disagree, the problem I have is when users spam the thread with pointless comments like "the article is junk..." and that's it. If you agree say why, is you disagree say why, your comments don't add anything to the thread.

But that's exactly your problem: you just post the article and watch the shitstorm unfold. If you care so much about a quality discussion, try participating in it instead of just trollishly pasting articles without anything adding to the table yourself.



Gilgamesh said:

I don't care if you disagree, the problem I have is when users spam the thread with pointless comments like "the article is junk..." and that's it. If you agree say why, is you disagree say why, your comments don't add anything to the thread.

Don't be butthurt! At least I read the article.

And though there are truths in it (I won't disagree), most of it is just misinformation or misworded.

I mean if you're going to be controversial, at least be careful in how you word or bring things forward. To say 9 Mario games came out and prove that as abuse of a franchise without admitting the fact that they are from different franchises (above and beyond listing them) is misleading, and that's not okay.



Gilgamesh said:
I don't care if you disagree, the problem I have is when users spam the thread with pointless comments like "the article is junk..." and that's it. If you agree say why, is you disagree say why, your comments don't add anything to the thread.

As opposed to spamming the forums with pointless threads that are just a link to an article with an excerpt, and that's it?

Seriously, the hypocrisy...



happydolphin said:
Turkish said:
happydolphin said:
Turkish said:

Thats so very not Nintendo, to buy studios from others lol. Anyway, I just proved Nintendo hasnt made any new hardcore IPs with the Wii, exceot for Xenoblade then. lol

1 case was sufficient to disprove your sweeping generalization. lolz?
Also, my second post to you might also help. HTH


Not.at.all. If it wasnt for some fans Xenoblade wouldnt even have released in the West lol.

In that case you probably don't understand logic.

Your initial claim:

"Sorry but none of those games are "big" and none of them are hardcore.", in regards to a list that included Xenoblade Chronicles.

Read this wikipedia entry on Counterexample. Me pointing out that Xenoblade Chronicles is hardcore (for older gamers) and a Nintendo game basically disproves your claim.

Did I misinterpret what you were trying to say in your initial claim? If so, my bad, but I only read what was written, help me read it differently.

Maybe you find it difficult to read, right after I said that none of them were hardcore, I said and quote myself "Xenoblade is not developped by Nintendo", when I made that comment I didnt know Monolith was owned by Nintendo. Blkpaladdin then notified me of them owned by Nintendo, did you already forgot you found it necessary to tell me they were owned by Nintendo too? It was like 30 minutes ago lol. Contrarily if I did knew they were owned by Nintendo, I wouldve said "only 1 new hardcore IP this whole gen just before the arrival of the new console".



Around the Network
Aielyn said:
Christhor said:
This article is complete bullshit. However, Nintendo really should stop with the rehashes that are New Super Mario Bros. There is no innovation in those, just Nintendo taking advantage of their casual fans. Who naturally eats all of them up, because that's how their brains function.

The only one that lacked innovation, so far, was the original NSMB (and even that provided two player simultaneous multiplayer as a special mode) - it gets a pass because the 2D Mario before it came out something like 15 years earlier, they had to reestablish the subfranchise.

NSMB Wii introduced a first for the series - simultaneous multiplayer story mode. The first time ever that Mario and Luigi could actually interact with each other in a 2D Mario title.

As for NSMB2, it's bringing DLC, Coin Rush mode, and a remarkably different element to the story - this million-coin-collection theme. And even in this game, you still have the simultaneous multiplayer.

NSMB U is, at minimum, bringing a new feature in the form of the Upad play element. There is likely more, given that we didn't even learn about DLC in NSMB2 until a week ago, just a couple of months before release.

Why are they rehashes? Because they're all 2D platformers? Because they all use a similar art style? The various NSMBs are no more rehashes than the various 3D Zeldas, the Calls of Duty, and... well, pretty much every other franchise, ever.


I'll give you NSMB (since it was the first game in a "new" franchise) and NSMB Wii for implementing something from other franchises. However, having DLC is not an innovation, not in the slightest. That new mode makes the game not a rehash in the same way Zombie mode or whatever it is called, makes CoD not a rehash. And that's just the thing, these new installments of this series are rehashes. Just like Call of Duty, among various other franchises. And that's the difference between my viewpoint and the viewpoint of a lot of Nintendo fans. At least I am consistent in what is a rehash, where as I have seen a lot of Nintendo fans saying these are not rehashes.

Again, while the article was bullshit (could barely read the first paragraph), it seems like Nintendo MIGHT be going down the same line that Activision is. At least with this particular franchise. Which is sad.



Turkish said:

Maybe you find it difficult to read, right after I said that none of them were hardcore, I said and quote myself "Xenoblade is not developped by Nintendo", when I made that comment I didnt know Monolith was owned by Nintendo. Blkpaladdin then notified me of them owned by Nintendo, did you already forgot you found it necessary to tell me they were owned by Nintendo too? It was like 30 minutes ago lol. Contrarily if I did knew they were owned by Nintendo, I wouldve said "only 1 new hardcore IP this whole gen just before the arrival of the new console".

@bold. Yes, I noted that. If so, your reply was horribly worded.

Okay, so if you honestly weren't trolling, why would you follow-up with this?

"If it wasnt for some fans Xenoblade wouldnt even have released in the West lol."

Why not just admit that Nintendo did release a core IP and you just ignored it. What's your point? This is an honest question.



Chrizum said:
Gilgamesh said:
Chrizum said:
Gilgamesh said:
Aielyn said:
Gilgamesh said:
Significant_leap said:
"Activision better than Nintendo"
that just made my day xD


Alright we get it, you are highly negative towards the article, there's no point in posting pointless comments over and over like you've been doing, if your that disgusted with the guy that wrote it go post a comment on his website, not this thread.

... excuse me, but you are clearly highly positive towards the article, and you had nothing further to say about it when you made the thread. Hypocrisy, much?

Clearly you haven't noticed I do sometimes post a lot of articles. I just look for popular article and post them here, most I don't even care about that's why I don't post in them, I'm just delivering some news and discussion worthy threads.

Don't shoot the messenger.

Oh Gilgamesh you crack me up time and time again. If there would be an award for "most useless thread starter" it would go to you every single time. People can't repeatedly post how they disagree with the articles you post yet you repeatedly post the same kind of articles while you so called "don't even care" about them.

Try posting articles you do care about or stop policing your threads if you care so little for them.

I don't care if you disagree, the problem I have is when users spam the thread with pointless comments like "the article is junk..." and that's it. If you agree say why, is you disagree say why, your comments don't add anything to the thread.

But that's exactly your problem: you just post the article and watch the shitstorm unfold. If you care so much about a quality discussion, try participating in it instead of just trollishly pasting articles without anything adding to the table yourself.

*for happydolphin aswell,

I understand where your getting at but you make it sound as though all my threads are similar which is far from the truth. I like bringing the latest news to VG Chartz and often check video game news sites for the latest info. This article was one of top ones I found and I read through it and thought it was be a good discussion thread (even if it may be fairly one side), there has been people in here that agree with the article so just because the majority agree it's rubish doesn't mean everyone else does, you have good point's though that most of those Mario games are different genres, I don't think many will disagree with that.



happydolphin said:
Christhor said:
This article is complete bullshit. However, Nintendo really should stop with the rehashes that are New Super Mario Bros. There is no innovation in those, just Nintendo taking advantage of their casual fans. Who naturally eats all of them up, because that's how their brains function.

You should try playing NSMB to the end, the Wii one and the DS one each bring new elements and are actually quite fun and challenging.

The WiiU one and NSMB2 each are bringing new to the table. NSMB2 for one I know is bringing in a coin rush mode with a golden Mario, it looks like a lot of fun. NSMBU looks to have really nice visuals for a Mario game so I'm kind of excited.

Of course I wish Nintendo should make more games for older gamers in house, they are more than capable of it (Twilight Princess), but as a manufacturer they don't need to ensure that. All they need to ensure is that there are games for older gamers and younger gamers alike, whether via 1st, 2nd or 3rd party efforts.

As a Nintendo fan I agree with you, but from a business perspective, it isn't a necessity. It is expected, but counter-intuitively, it isn't needed.


I've played and beaten both NSMBs. A relative of mine always forces me to play them whenever I visit them. And my opinion agrees with yours, the games are fun. However, the new things they are adding just seem more like bells and whistles too me. They are still releasing the same game barely altered.

From a business standpoint, it makes a lot of sense. As NSMB is selling like crazy, while seemingly being one of the cheapest franchises to make new installments for. But again, even though it makes sense from a business perspective (the same way all the CoD games do), they can still be considered old hat.



I knew this thread would attract the usual Nintendo bashers



If it isn't turnbased it isn't worth playing   (mostly)

And shepherds we shall be,

For Thee, my Lord, for Thee. Power hath descended forth from Thy hand, That our feet may swiftly carry out Thy command. So we shall flow a river forth to Thee And teeming with souls shall it ever be. In Nomine Patris, et Filii, et Spiritūs Sancti. -----The Boondock Saints