Soul Eater is amazing!

I would recommend you look at this thread: http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=138808&page=1
It could help you quite a lot.

Half the site has one of these. It might be good to invest the time into it if you like anime 

http://myanimelist.net/

Fairy Tail is a great but is more similar to One Piece (which is a good thing).

hmm...like Naruto/Bleach. Well if you mean something that's funny with intermittent action/battle scenes I'd go with To Aru no Index, Tiger and Bunny, and Basquash. Gurren Laggen would also be one to check out I think.

I'd suggest taking a look at:

- Hunter x Hunter (preferably the one from 1999 and not the remake from 2011, as the older one has better production value and voice actors)

- Soul Eater

- Kekkaishi

- Full Metal Alchemist/ Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood (you've probably seen that before, as it's one of the most popular ones)

- Hikaru no Go

but then again I'm not a fan of Naruto or Bleach, so I guess I have a different taste in anime

YuYu Hakusho is pretty damn similar to Bleach.

Yu Yu Hakusho <-- Spirit Detective (fav)

Kenichi: The Mightiest Disciple

Heroic Age <-- (2nd fav)

Samurai Champloo
Black Blood Brothers
GunGrave
Yu Yu Hakusho
Scr-y-ed
Black Cat
Black Lagoon
Darker than Black
Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood

Fullmetal Panic

You should go for Queen's Blade. Totally like Naruto and Bleach, tons of characters with fighting.