I've definitely stayed in the community for the fan content - some of it is brilliant

+ I'm really glad to have you with us, SuperMario :)

Scarier than her in party of one, i say

Breaking a Pinkie Promise opens the gates of hell

I know that one cannot simply choose a favorite Pony, but I have a dilemma!

I've pin-pointed my favorite two ponies: Fluttershy and Rarity, but I don't know who I like better T_T. Am I becoming a Brony?

Uh, watch more episodes with one of them in? Green Isn't Your Colour had both featured.

If you're watching episodes purely because you want to, that makes you a brony.

The answer is Fluttershy.

I have absolutely no idea what you were trying to tell me in the bolded...

He's saying watch more episodes to better refine your judgment (and arrive at the natural conclusion: Fluttershy!), and that "Green Isn't Your Color" is a good episode, as it puts focus on the relationship between Rarity and Fluttershy

Nah. I pick Rarity.

And to Soleron. No, I basically forced myself to watch another 4 episodes. And although I can appreciate MLP for what it is now. I hardly think I'll be watching it again. I simply watched enough to become familiar with the exploding phenomenon it has become. I hate being in the dark about the new fads that are going around. I at least want to understand them.

That said, Rarity is the best Pony. My job here is done.

Rarity is not the best pony, but she is the most underrated.