By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Console versions of Battlefield 3 getting low scores

So Call of Duty will probably be the better game (on consoles...). EA sure fooled us! I feel sorry for the millions of people who preordered based on those misleading trailers.



Around the Network
wfz said:

Battlefield is all about multiplayer. The single player campaign, if you read the reviews, is clearly what is bringing down the score (for the PC version at least, I haven't read the 360/ps3 reviews). That's fine by me, because I'm not buying this game for an amazing single player experience (even though it undoubtedly is still pretty cool).

 

It just doesn't get any better than Battlefield multiplayer. =)


On PC with the larger player numbers, I just don't feel that the console versions will be anywhere near as good, which is why I am actually leaning towards CoD, as I prefer those intimate spaces compared to Battlefield's seemingly empty battlefields (on console!)

As for the SP that has been criticsed, it seems they just tried to copy CoD, which is definitely the wrong approach, as CoD is a really really good coridoor shooter, so BF 3 should be showing its openness, not copying linearity (though some reviews have actually been quite positive, the general impression seems to be that it is slightly lacklustre which is a shame)

Having said that, I am not too excited about either of them, certainly nowhere near as much as Revelations or Uncharted, and if I buy CoD MW 3, it will mostly be for couch spec ops once I get bored of playing FIFA 12



Jay520 said:
Boutros said:
Andrespetmonkey said:
Boutros said:
VGKing said:
Boutros said:
And why is it lower exactly?

Don't tell me it's just because of the graphics..


Because the console versions are inferior. Not only in graphics but in number of online players.

It would be unfair to consumers if game journalists reviewed the best version of the game(PC) and gave console versions the same score.
DICE did it to themselves for hyping their Frostbite 2 engine so much. There's a huge difference between the PC and console versions. The most obvious difference is the graphics. 

Did you just say ''number of online players''? roflmao

As if it changes anything that there's 500k online players at the same time or 200k.


There's no actual content that's been cutted for the console versions so there's no reason to give it a lower score.

24 players instead of 64. Conquest maps are being cut in half. Graphics are significantly worse (still brilliant though) and I'm guessing there's a few more bugs. 
But no PC elitist here, I'm getting it for ps3 :D

Less players isn't exactly changing the experience if the maps are smaller.

 

VGC gave Black Ops Wii the same score as the HD version depsite weaker graphics, weaker performance, no split-screen mode, lack of zombie content, etc.

So I don't see why Battlefield 3  is any different.



Yeah, like Pezus said, large maps quite are important in Battlefield. It gives a thrilling sense of scale to each game making it feel like a large... well... battlefield.

I agree, but I think BFBC2 and BF3 on consoles still give you that same thrill with 24 players. 24 players is actually a lot when you see it in action and the maps are still massive.



yo_john117 said:
Yeah the console versions look less than great. I'm sure BF3 for the consoles is still ridden with tons of bugs.


I've been playing since about 1am and have yet to see any bugs. 

 

OT:

1) 85 is not mediocre... its great. 90+ is amazing. Mediocre would be more around 70-75.

2) Of course the PC version will score better... it was MADE FOR PCs. It has better graphics, larger multiplayer, among other things.

To me this disparity of 5pts+/- is pretty much on par for the differences inherent to the game itself.

I've put in almost 4hrs of multiplayer. The game has only had one small few seconds of lag. No bugs that I can see anywhere. Just about full 24player loads for every match accross Rush and Conquest. No issues with leveling up and unlocking items. No issues overall at all.

Its just been a very fun game and I really like all the tight close quarter urban maps btw. These make for some great fire fights. Conquest version of Metro is freaking bad ass.

Now, does this mean is a perfect game? no, I'd like to see demolition a little more realistic as right now I have to blast a wall 2-3 times with a rocket launcher for it to break open... I'd also like to see less of the blur from suppression, etc. I also want the Karkand expansion maps NOW lol...



Consoles are so last generation. The PC is the only truly next gen platform. Consoles are mostly for soccer moms, the elderly and little girls.



Around the Network
Paul said:
Consoles are so last generation. The PC is the only truly next gen platform. Consoles are mostly for soccer moms, the elderly and little girls.

Argh, I came here to say that joke!

Ahem... to get back on topic, fortunately I have a good enough PC to play the game. It feels good to be a PC gamer :)



http://www.xg247.co.uk/news/10/battlefield-3-xbox-360-servers-have-taken-a-day-one-tumble-back-soon-as-possible/

Battlefield 3 Xbox 360 Servers have taken a day one tumble, “back as soon as possible”
Those Xbox 360 servers are encountering a minor tumble.
By Sam ClayCommunity Xbox 360 Xtreme2 hours ago(0)
Looks like people want to play this new 'Battlefield 3' video game or somin?

Well, if you've got the game on the Xbox 360 and attempting to play it online right this very second, well sadly, you can't, the servers are encountering a minor tumble.

"We're aware of the server issues on the Xbox 360 and are working to correct them as soon as possible. #BF3"


Maybe they weren't equipped to handle all those million preorders?



http://xbox360.ign.com/articles/121/1210685p1.html

IGN: Battlefield 3 Consoles Review
9/10



Andrespetmonkey said:
pezus said:

I doubt it bothers many but if I can choose between 10 chocolate bars or 9 chocolate bars I'd pick the 10!

Not if I had to spend £600 on a new PC to run those 10 chocolate bars when I already have all I need to run 9 chocolate bars.


Think of it more as 3 cookies with milk vs one cookie



@TheVoxelman on twitter

Check out my hype threads: Cyberpunk, and The Witcher 3!

Well thats what they get for buying a game based on PC graphics honestly i think its still a great game on Xbox 360 but it definitely doesn't look like the trailer they have been showing.