By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Console versions of Battlefield 3 getting low scores

pezus said:
Boutros said:
Andrespetmonkey said:
Boutros said:
VGKing said:
Boutros said:
And why is it lower exactly?

Don't tell me it's just because of the graphics..


Because the console versions are inferior. Not only in graphics but in number of online players.

It would be unfair to consumers if game journalists reviewed the best version of the game(PC) and gave console versions the same score.
DICE did it to themselves for hyping their Frostbite 2 engine so much. There's a huge difference between the PC and console versions. The most obvious difference is the graphics. 

Did you just say ''number of online players''? roflmao

As if it changes anything that there's 500k online players at the same time or 200k.


There's no actual content that's been cutted for the console versions so there's no reason to give it a lower score.

24 players instead of 64. Conquest maps are being cut in half. Graphics are significantly worse (still brilliant though) and I'm guessing there's a few more bugs. 
But no PC elitist here, I'm getting it for ps3 :D

Less players isn't exactly changing the experience if the maps are smaller.

 

VGC gave Black Ops Wii the same score as the HD version depsite weaker graphics, weaker performance, no split-screen mode, lack of zombie content, etc.

So I don't see why Battlefield 3  is any different.

The big maps are what differentiates BF from other shooters, so having smaller maps and fewer players definitely lessens the experience.

I wouldn't say it lessens it, I got the same "battlefield" feeling when playing BFBC2 on PS3 as I did when playing BF2 on PC. The maps are still very, very big on consoles and 12 vs 12 is actually a lot of players when you see it in action.



Around the Network
Mummelmann said:
Unlike most other shooters, BF3 is actually developed first and foremost with PC in mind, makes sense that it would get higher scores on a superior platform.
To suggest that 85 is a mediocre score though, that is something I cannot fathom on this site. I have even enjoyed games that were in the 70's on Metacritic!! Imagine that!!!

Thank you. Dead island has a meta of only 71 but it's still in my top 5 games of this year. 



Andrespetmonkey said:
Mummelmann said:
Unlike most other shooters, BF3 is actually developed first and foremost with PC in mind, makes sense that it would get higher scores on a superior platform.
To suggest that 85 is a mediocre score though, that is something I cannot fathom on this site. I have even enjoyed games that were in the 70's on Metacritic!! Imagine that!!!

Thank you. Dead island has a meta of only 71 but it's still in my top 5 games of this year. 


Same here, I'm enjoying the hell out of Dead Island! It has flaws, some are even quite big but its still a hugely entertaining product at the core and the gameplay is simple yet very engaging imo.



85 is a great score but i mean this game was hyped to almost cure cancer



Mummelmann said:
Unlike most other shooters, BF3 is actually developed first and foremost with PC in mind, makes sense that it would get higher scores on a superior platform.
To suggest that 85 is a mediocre score though, that is something I cannot fathom on this site. I have even enjoyed games that were in the 70's on Metacritic!! Imagine that!!!

Why not?  In an period with week after week games getting + 90 reviews it shouldn't be strange that an game getting 85 on metacritic feels weak or mediocre.



 

Around the Network
pezus said:
Andrespetmonkey said:
pezus said:
Boutros said:
Andrespetmonkey said:
Boutros said:
VGKing said:
Boutros said:
And why is it lower exactly?

Don't tell me it's just because of the graphics..


Because the console versions are inferior. Not only in graphics but in number of online players.

It would be unfair to consumers if game journalists reviewed the best version of the game(PC) and gave console versions the same score.
DICE did it to themselves for hyping their Frostbite 2 engine so much. There's a huge difference between the PC and console versions. The most obvious difference is the graphics. 

Did you just say ''number of online players''? roflmao

As if it changes anything that there's 500k online players at the same time or 200k.


There's no actual content that's been cutted for the console versions so there's no reason to give it a lower score.

24 players instead of 64. Conquest maps are being cut in half. Graphics are significantly worse (still brilliant though) and I'm guessing there's a few more bugs. 
But no PC elitist here, I'm getting it for ps3 :D

Less players isn't exactly changing the experience if the maps are smaller.

 

VGC gave Black Ops Wii the same score as the HD version depsite weaker graphics, weaker performance, no split-screen mode, lack of zombie content, etc.

So I don't see why Battlefield 3  is any different.

The big maps are what differentiates BF from other shooters, so having smaller maps and fewer players definitely lessens the experience.

I wouldn't say it lessens it, I got the same "battlefield" feeling when playing BFBC2 on PS3 as I did when playing BF2 on PC. The maps are still very, very big on consoles and 12 vs 12 is actually a lot of players when you see it in action.

Lessens it a bit, hence the score ;). BF2 had HUGE maps though, I thought BFBC2 was quite different from it.

Meh, I disagree. And I've yet to see a review that lowered the score because of smaller maps and player count, (I'm sure some are out there, but I've yet to see one meaning this isn't an issue to most people) Most of the lower scores are given because it's not the technical wonder it is on PC.



pezus said:
Andrespetmonkey said:
pezus said:
Andrespetmonkey said:
pezus said:
Boutros said:
Andrespetmonkey said:
Boutros said:
VGKing said:
Boutros said:
And why is it lower exactly?

Don't tell me it's just because of the graphics..


Because the console versions are inferior. Not only in graphics but in number of online players.

It would be unfair to consumers if game journalists reviewed the best version of the game(PC) and gave console versions the same score.
DICE did it to themselves for hyping their Frostbite 2 engine so much. There's a huge difference between the PC and console versions. The most obvious difference is the graphics. 

Did you just say ''number of online players''? roflmao

As if it changes anything that there's 500k online players at the same time or 200k.


There's no actual content that's been cutted for the console versions so there's no reason to give it a lower score.

24 players instead of 64. Conquest maps are being cut in half. Graphics are significantly worse (still brilliant though) and I'm guessing there's a few more bugs. 
But no PC elitist here, I'm getting it for ps3 :D

Less players isn't exactly changing the experience if the maps are smaller.

 

VGC gave Black Ops Wii the same score as the HD version depsite weaker graphics, weaker performance, no split-screen mode, lack of zombie content, etc.

So I don't see why Battlefield 3  is any different.

The big maps are what differentiates BF from other shooters, so having smaller maps and fewer players definitely lessens the experience.

I wouldn't say it lessens it, I got the same "battlefield" feeling when playing BFBC2 on PS3 as I did when playing BF2 on PC. The maps are still very, very big on consoles and 12 vs 12 is actually a lot of players when you see it in action.

Lessens it a bit, hence the score ;). BF2 had HUGE maps though, I thought BFBC2 was quite different from it.

Meh, I disagree. And I've yet to see a review that lowered the score because of smaller maps and player count, (I'm sure some are out there, but I've yet to see one meaning this isn't an issue to most people) Most of the lower scores are given because it's not the technical wonder it is on PC.

Well I know at least 1up mentions it. We'll see how it goes when more reviews roll out. Bigger maps and more players is a part of why it's a technical wonder on the PC though

I guess so, ahh well, as long as it doesn't bother me I don't really mind if it bothers others. 



Boutros said:
pezus said:
Boutros said:
Andrespetmonkey said:
Boutros said:
VGKing said:
Boutros said:
And why is it lower exactly?

Don't tell me it's just because of the graphics..


Because the console versions are inferior. Not only in graphics but in number of online players.

It would be unfair to consumers if game journalists reviewed the best version of the game(PC) and gave console versions the same score.
DICE did it to themselves for hyping their Frostbite 2 engine so much. There's a huge difference between the PC and console versions. The most obvious difference is the graphics. 

Did you just say ''number of online players''? roflmao

As if it changes anything that there's 500k online players at the same time or 200k.


There's no actual content that's been cutted for the console versions so there's no reason to give it a lower score.

24 players instead of 64. Conquest maps are being cut in half. Graphics are significantly worse (still brilliant though) and I'm guessing there's a few more bugs. 
But no PC elitist here, I'm getting it for ps3 :D

Less players isn't exactly changing the experience if the maps are smaller.

 

VGC gave Black Ops Wii the same score as the HD version depsite weaker graphics, weaker performance, no split-screen mode, lack of zombie content, etc.

So I don't see why Battlefield 3  is any different.

The big maps are what differentiates BF from other shooters, so having smaller maps and fewer players definitely lessens the experience.

It's not like the maps are small in the console version. It's just that they are smaller.

I'm pretty sure it makes little to no difference especially since big maps aren't always more fun.

Size doesn't matter like my mom always told me (joke).

We really know it was your girlfriend propping up your ahem EGO telling you that.
btw BF3 limited ed just arrived by courier ,now I will get to see what it's like although  don't know what I will do with the ulimited paintball card



Research shows Video games  help make you smarter, so why am I an idiot

Boutros said:
Andrespetmonkey said:
Boutros said:
VGKing said:
Boutros said:
And why is it lower exactly?

Don't tell me it's just because of the graphics..


Because the console versions are inferior. Not only in graphics but in number of online players.

It would be unfair to consumers if game journalists reviewed the best version of the game(PC) and gave console versions the same score.
DICE did it to themselves for hyping their Frostbite 2 engine so much. There's a huge difference between the PC and console versions. The most obvious difference is the graphics. 

Did you just say ''number of online players''? roflmao

As if it changes anything that there's 500k online players at the same time or 200k.


There's no actual content that's been cutted for the console versions so there's no reason to give it a lower score.

24 players instead of 64. Conquest maps are being cut in half. Graphics are significantly worse (still brilliant though) and I'm guessing there's a few more bugs. 
But no PC elitist here, I'm getting it for ps3 :D

Less players isn't exactly changing the experience if the maps are smaller.

 

VGC gave Black Ops Wii the same score as the HD version depsite weaker graphics, weaker performance, no split-screen mode, lack of zombie content, etc.

So I don't see why Battlefield 3  is any different.



Yeah, like Pezus said, large maps quite are important in Battlefield. It gives a thrilling sense of scale to each game making it feel like a large... well... battlefield.

pezus said:
Andrespetmonkey said:
pezus said:
Andrespetmonkey said:
pezus said:
Andrespetmonkey said:
pezus said:
Boutros said:
Andrespetmonkey said:
Boutros said:
VGKing said:
Boutros said:
And why is it lower exactly?

Don't tell me it's just because of the graphics..


Because the console versions are inferior. Not only in graphics but in number of online players.

It would be unfair to consumers if game journalists reviewed the best version of the game(PC) and gave console versions the same score.
DICE did it to themselves for hyping their Frostbite 2 engine so much. There's a huge difference between the PC and console versions. The most obvious difference is the graphics. 

Did you just say ''number of online players''? roflmao

As if it changes anything that there's 500k online players at the same time or 200k.


There's no actual content that's been cutted for the console versions so there's no reason to give it a lower score.

24 players instead of 64. Conquest maps are being cut in half. Graphics are significantly worse (still brilliant though) and I'm guessing there's a few more bugs. 
But no PC elitist here, I'm getting it for ps3 :D

Less players isn't exactly changing the experience if the maps are smaller.

 

VGC gave Black Ops Wii the same score as the HD version depsite weaker graphics, weaker performance, no split-screen mode, lack of zombie content, etc.

So I don't see why Battlefield 3  is any different.

The big maps are what differentiates BF from other shooters, so having smaller maps and fewer players definitely lessens the experience.

I wouldn't say it lessens it, I got the same "battlefield" feeling when playing BFBC2 on PS3 as I did when playing BF2 on PC. The maps are still very, very big on consoles and 12 vs 12 is actually a lot of players when you see it in action.

Lessens it a bit, hence the score ;). BF2 had HUGE maps though, I thought BFBC2 was quite different from it.

Meh, I disagree. And I've yet to see a review that lowered the score because of smaller maps and player count, (I'm sure some are out there, but I've yet to see one meaning this isn't an issue to most people) Most of the lower scores are given because it's not the technical wonder it is on PC.

Well I know at least 1up mentions it. We'll see how it goes when more reviews roll out. Bigger maps and more players is a part of why it's a technical wonder on the PC though

I guess so, ahh well, as long as it doesn't bother me I don't really mind if it bothers others. 

I doubt it bothers many but if I can choose between 10 chocolate bars or 9 chocolate bars I'd pick the 10!

Not if I had to spend £600 on a new PC to run those 10 chocolate bars when I already have all I need to run 9 chocolate bars.