By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - Uncharted 3 Review Thread!

Tagged games:

Aldro said:
Khuutra said:
ethomaz said:

Aldro said:

 Can you calculate the metacritic of UC3 after the 5/10 from AV Club?
Jesus christ, all reviews we have gathered and as soon as one 5/10 comes up, BAM its on Meta.

C

4754 / 51 = 93.21

That would work for the gamerankings average, not the metascore; it's not clear how the AV club is weighted by Meta.

..

93.9 was rounded down to 93. So clearly the numbers isn't in favour of the game.

Now its down to 93.21 with one mixed review, and that review being a 5/10.

 

I think its safe to say Uncharted 3 is fucked of recieving 94. Despite 10 100's flooding in with great weight.


But without knowing how the reviews are weighted you can't really say that 93.9 was rounded down to 93, because you don't know that it was at 93.9.



Around the Network

5/10 for uncharted 3?

This should prove that review scores and metacritic are useless.



Lol what 5/10? Does that reviewer have some kind of problem? And ofcurse metactitic incuded them on metacritic. Their are stil alot of reviews yet on their list.



http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=130023&page=1# Official Playstation Vita Thread! Come in and join!!!

Anyone thinking this game can score 94 on Meta is outright naive.

Jesus fucking christ.

@Khuutra
Yes I know that, but by "regular" calculations, it was 93,9 and that wasn't enough to give it 94. I know Metacritic has this weight system, but if you look past it for a second and realize that 93,9 disregarding the weight wasn't enough to put the game up to 94 then it's safe as hell to say the 93,2 is not going to get 94. As soon as one 100 was added and the 93,9 became 94,03 or whatever, meta became 94.

Clearly there is some connection and the weight is balanced to the point where a 0,9 will be narrowed down to 0 but as soon as its 1.01 its 1.

Just for fun sakes:
Lets say we had 5 reviews. Reviews that have no special weight.

All these 5 gave UC3 a 10/10.

(4754+500) / 56 = 93.82

It's over guys. The amount of 9's that will be arriving. The high possibility of another 8. And maybe the chance of another fanboy to review the game just might throw it a 6 or 5/10.

All of that versus A LOT of 10/10's. It ain't happening.

Uncharted 2 started at 98 metacritic, was about to finish at 97 but got fucked over as like 10 or so reviews were added afterwards (find any game that has 105 reviews like UC3. Some games get away with 80 reviews. Total bogus).



wait meta actually includes that AV joke review?! WTF!?

hence why meta = shit. -_-



In-Kat-We-Trust Brigade!

"This world is Merciless, and it's also very beautiful"

For All News/Info related to the PlayStation Vita, Come and join us in the Official PSV Thread!

Around the Network

SpikeTV is giving Goty award is based on what criteria?



Sorry for English :/

Oh my..the first mixed review.Hopefully it's the last.



lmfao they pointed out 'not crouching' as a negative point!? I mean really? hahahhahaha



In-Kat-We-Trust Brigade!

"This world is Merciless, and it's also very beautiful"

For All News/Info related to the PlayStation Vita, Come and join us in the Official PSV Thread!

Wow I can't believe A.V gave it a 5/10. I know how you feel Uncharted fans. When Gameshark gave Gears 3 a 67, the meta for Gears 3 went from 92 to 91 just from one bum review. Hopefully no more crap reviews for Uncharted 3.



Aldro, are you putting that troll review up or is it too petty to do so (I've read the review and it's pretty poor)?