Final Fantasy 5:

• I liked the idea of the two worlds being combined
• I liked the first overworld theme

Dead Island
+ Love the open world
+ Intense atmosphere
- Hate that you can't respec
- Sewers, blah. Too sewer sections right next to each and weren't that fun to begin with

Halo: Reach...

I liked the return of the firefight mode from ODST and some of the new abilities like the jetpack boost.

Sadly, I did not care for the campaign that much (I actually enjoyed ODST's better even though it was shorter), and the multiplayer remained basically unchanged from Halo 3.

I guess I just got caught up in the Halo hype, and then after I finished the game realized that I don't really care that much for Halo anymore. I loved the original on Xbox, and played lots of multiplayer with my friends back in the day, but once COD4 Modern Warfare came out, I never looked at Halo the same way again, especially for its multiplayer.

Super Smash Bros. Brawl...

I liked the vast amount of classic tunes and remixes on the sound track. That's about it. Easily the biggest disappointment of this generation for me.

Gears of War:
- Love how gritty it is, the environment is cool and the enemies are scary/tough looking
- Love the chainsaw on the lancer

Bad Company 2:
- Love dedicated servers
- Love the spawn system (you can spawn at your base or on teammates I think)
- Love how its more team-oriented/objective based

MadWorld had a really cool art style. Too bad the gameplay felt so damn repetitive.

Final Fantasy 6
1) I liked the Characters
2) I liked the Story.

WTF?!!

Uncharted:

1) I liked the characters & story
2) The witty humor

The graphics and music in Chrono Cross.
KIllzone 3's graphics.