By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General - On what basis was 'HELL' invented?

Joelcool7 said:
Galaki said:
Joelcool7 said:

A huge misconception occurred in your post. In Christianity getting to heaven is not something reached through good deeds at all. It is something reached by accepting Jesus Christ as your Lord and Savior. If you accept Christ as your Lord and Savior then chances are you will follow his teachings which included good deeds.

However the Bible clearly states several times that you can't buy your way into heaven with good deeds. Nothing buys you into heaven accept receiving the salvation offered to us through Jesus's death and resurrection.

Don't you think that's conflicting and opens to whatever how you want to cherry pick it to fit your own view on?

Whats conflicting about it? If you believe in God your going to follow his teachings. Also people do cherry pick what they want thats just the way it is. Some people even conclude that good works will get them to heaven because Jesus taught we should be good people. If you believe and follow Christ you are saved.

Which implies that, I don't have to do good. Just as long as I believe in God before I die. I will "naturally" be good then. There's no reason for you to be good from the begining to the end, since, all sins are forgiven as soon as you turn-to-God.

And who is judging your good deeds? Based on what standards? How would you know if someone is "buying their way" with good deeds?



Around the Network

As Jon Stewart Said in his Earth Book, you go to hell for 3 reasons...

1) You were being bad on Earth
2) You were being good but didn't follow the right religion.
3) You were being good, followed the right religion, but didn't follow the right religion up to standard.

 

I do #1, but not #2 or #3.  Then again, I don't believe in heaven or hell - which means alot of religious people will say that I'm going to hell.



"Naturally the common people don't want war: Neither in Russia, nor in England, nor for that matter in Germany. That is understood. But, after all, IT IS THE LEADERS of the country who determine the policy and it is always a simple matter to drag the people along, whether it is a democracy, or a fascist dictatorship, or a parliament, or a communist dictatorship. Voice or no voice, the people can always be brought to the bidding of the leaders. That is easy. All you have to do is TELL THEM THEY ARE BEING ATTACKED, and denounce the peacemakers for lack of patriotism and exposing the country to danger. IT WORKS THE SAME IN ANY COUNTRY."  --Hermann Goering, leading Nazi party member, at the Nuremberg War Crime Trials 

 

Conservatives:  Pushing for a small enough government to be a guest in your living room, or even better - your uterus.

 

snakenobi said:

I have been reading alot about different religions and how they describe afterlife.

Western religions state that there is eternal heaven or hell afterlife and the eastern side believes in nirvana(equivalent to heaven) and rebirth(they think repeated rebirths are as good as hell).

The problem is that they say afterlife is dependent on your deeds in this life.

What I don't understand is who define's what deed is good and what deed is bad?

Our society defines what is good or bad according to the time period in which we live in.Simple example - nudity and greed was seen as something else before than what it is seen as today.And as we all know,good and bad are very much effected by the economic condition of this world.

We can all go back to the old moral values that life should be just about benefiting humanity but where does that leave room for enjoyment if we are just working.I mean whats the point of living.

The question here is why does GOD have to create such a world where we just fight each other based on money and work.Its like we are his playtoys.Some people here might argue and say he is just testing us but why is he testing us,for his own enjoyment?

 

 

I strongly believe in afterlife but have serious problems figuring the connection between rebirth and previous life and your status that you get after rebirth.The western religions way of heaven is much easier than eastern religions but fact that once we go in heaven,what do we do out there?If there is no time then how will we enjoy things in heaven as time is closely related with what you do with your life.

The first premise of "why hell?" is: Matthew 25:41
"The question here is why does GOD have to create such a world where we just fight each other based on money and work"
That`s not the world God made. God made us of free will, a heart and a mind. It`s what you do with them that matters.

If men to this day still can`t make uo their mind on what is good and bad, i don`t think a person should rely too much on humanity.
Look at it this way. If right and wrong are changing time after time, what exactly is changing? The meaning or the existance of such values?
There are many sources that claim what is good and what is wrong.
I could say that God being good made us in His image therefore, at our very core, not only resides the true definition of goodness but that in the end isn`t that what people yearn?

Look closely and you`ll find your answers.

"once we go in heaven,what do we do out there?"
No one knows.



d21lewis said:
It really makes you think.

I laughed at this comment in the other thread (considering your avatar) and I laughed now again! Good stuff.

OT I'm sitting this one out.



Its like the kid and the ant farm. Sometimes you just want to "shake things up" to see how the ants respond.



Around the Network
Galaki said:
Joelcool7 said:
Galaki said:
Joelcool7 said:

A huge misconception occurred in your post. In Christianity getting to heaven is not something reached through good deeds at all. It is something reached by accepting Jesus Christ as your Lord and Savior. If you accept Christ as your Lord and Savior then chances are you will follow his teachings which included good deeds.

However the Bible clearly states several times that you can't buy your way into heaven with good deeds. Nothing buys you into heaven accept receiving the salvation offered to us through Jesus's death and resurrection.

Don't you think that's conflicting and opens to whatever how you want to cherry pick it to fit your own view on?

Whats conflicting about it? If you believe in God your going to follow his teachings. Also people do cherry pick what they want thats just the way it is. Some people even conclude that good works will get them to heaven because Jesus taught we should be good people. If you believe and follow Christ you are saved.

Which implies that, I don't have to do good. Just as long as I believe in God before I die. I will "naturally" be good then. There's no reason for you to be good from the begining to the end, since, all sins are forgiven as soon as you turn-to-God.

And who is judging your good deeds? Based on what standards? How would you know if someone is "buying their way" with good deeds?


You don't have to be good in a way. You have to follow Christ which means well you sorta do have to be good. Since Christs teachings were very explicit on how to act and live our lives. Yes their is a good reason to be a good person from beginning to end, because if you accept Christ and follow his teachings then you will be good.

Christianity is a faith based on forgiveness. Its also a faith that acknowledges man's flaws their is no such thing as a good man. No such thing as a sinless man, we all sin. As such yah we are going to be forgiven for the things we do, if we ask for that forgiveness and genuinely do believe and follow Christ.

The Bible clearly says no man should judge another man. It says that you will be judged as you judge others. Only God can judge and while we have guidlines to life set out in the Bible their is no way we could fathom or understand how he will pass judgement. We only know that if we follow his teachings and accept his forgiveness it will be granted.

How would we know if someone was buying their way to heaven? How could someone buy their way to heaven when eternal life is not conditional on deeds? Someone doing good deeds constantly to try and get to heaven will be no more likely to go there then the man who turns his life around.

It does say in the Bible good deeds and living a good life will be rewarded with treasures that are eternal in heaven. However it does not say that deeds can get you to heaven.



-JC7

"In God We Trust - In Games We Play " - Joel Reimer

 

Joelcool7 said:

You don't have to be good in a way. You have to follow Christ which means well you sorta do have to be good. Since Christs teachings were very explicit on how to act and live our lives. Yes their is a good reason to be a good person from beginning to end, because if you accept Christ and follow his teachings then you will be good.

Christianity is a faith based on forgiveness. Its also a faith that acknowledges man's flaws their is no such thing as a good man. No such thing as a sinless man, we all sin. As such yah we are going to be forgiven for the things we do, if we ask for that forgiveness and genuinely do believe and follow Christ.

The Bible clearly says no man should judge another man. It says that you will be judged as you judge others. Only God can judge and while we have guidlines to life set out in the Bible their is no way we could fathom or understand how he will pass judgement. We only know that if we follow his teachings and accept his forgiveness it will be granted.

How would we know if someone was buying their way to heaven? How could someone buy their way to heaven when eternal life is not conditional on deeds? Someone doing good deeds constantly to try and get to heaven will be no more likely to go there then the man who turns his life around.

It does say in the Bible good deeds and living a good life will be rewarded with treasures that are eternal in heaven. However it does not say that deeds can get you to heaven.

Circular reasonings.

Point 1. God is a tyrant. According to you, not me :)

Point 2. If we are all sinners. A little more sins doesn't really do anything, would it? I.E. I robbed 10 banks, would it matter if I rob just 1 more?  If everything we do or not do may or may not be sins, how do we know what to do and not to do? Shouldn't it be clear for the people who wish to follow?

Point 3. Which backs up my argument with Point 2. If you are told that you can't judge what's right or wrong, how do you (or anyone) know what you're doing is right or wrong?

Point 4. Again, God is a tyrant. :) At least, tell us, clearly, what is right and wrong. If we aren't allowed clear paths that we can then judge ourselves and others, there's no way to know what's right or wrong.

Point 5. Lastely, it again goes back to previous points. How do you suppose we follow God if God gives no path for us to follow?

 

We are all judges. We judge ourselves and other people. We assume. By simply saying you follow God, you're not following. Since you said it yourself as pointed out above. God gives you no path to follow. You are unable to tell what's right or wrong. You are not allowed to judge.

It's like saying. I, God, wants everyone to follow me. It's the only path to Heaven. But, you can't follow me and I am not going to give you direction.



Galaki said:
Joelcool7 said:

You don't have to be good in a way. You have to follow Christ which means well you sorta do have to be good. Since Christs teachings were very explicit on how to act and live our lives. Yes their is a good reason to be a good person from beginning to end, because if you accept Christ and follow his teachings then you will be good.

Christianity is a faith based on forgiveness. Its also a faith that acknowledges man's flaws their is no such thing as a good man. No such thing as a sinless man, we all sin. As such yah we are going to be forgiven for the things we do, if we ask for that forgiveness and genuinely do believe and follow Christ.

The Bible clearly says no man should judge another man. It says that you will be judged as you judge others. Only God can judge and while we have guidlines to life set out in the Bible their is no way we could fathom or understand how he will pass judgement. We only know that if we follow his teachings and accept his forgiveness it will be granted.

How would we know if someone was buying their way to heaven? How could someone buy their way to heaven when eternal life is not conditional on deeds? Someone doing good deeds constantly to try and get to heaven will be no more likely to go there then the man who turns his life around.

It does say in the Bible good deeds and living a good life will be rewarded with treasures that are eternal in heaven. However it does not say that deeds can get you to heaven.

Circular reasonings.

Point 1. God is a tyrant. According to you, not me :)

Point 2. If we are all sinners. A little more sins doesn't really do anything, would it? I.E. I robbed 10 banks, would it matter if I rob just 1 more?  If everything we do or not do may or may not be sins, how do we know what to do and not to do? Shouldn't it be clear for the people who wish to follow?

Point 3. Which backs up my argument with Point 2. If you are told that you can't judge what's right or wrong, how do you (or anyone) know what you're doing is right or wrong?

Point 4. Again, God is a tyrant. :) At least, tell us, clearly, what is right and wrong. If we aren't allowed clear paths that we can then judge ourselves and others, there's no way to know what's right or wrong.

Point 5. Lastely, it again goes back to previous points. How do you suppose we follow God if God gives no path for us to follow?

 

We are all judges. We judge ourselves and other people. We assume. By simply saying you follow God, you're not following. Since you said it yourself as pointed out above. God gives you no path to follow. You are unable to tell what's right or wrong. You are not allowed to judge.

It's like saying. I, God, wants everyone to follow me. It's the only path to Heaven. But, you can't follow me and I am not going to give you direction.


When did I say that? Dude you totally don't understand Christianity. Fact is the Bible is a path to follow, Jesus laid it out perfectly throughout the Bible exactly how we are supposed to live. Just because he forgives people for their sins doesn't mean he's a tyrant.

We are all judges, however we are supposed to control ourselves and not judge others. Its very important not to pass judgement on someone else , rather try and understand why they did what they did. Often their are very reasonable reasons for someone doing something and when their aren't its usually a mental disability and such. Nobody does anything for no reason at all and judging everything everyone does when you yourself do tons of things is just plain wrong.

Umm your misreading facts, since Adam and Eve ate of the tree of good and evil they did understand what was right and wrong.

Lets rephrase what you said logically

I God, want everyone to follow me. All those who do accept forgiveness will be granted it and live forever in heaven. I sent my son and the Bible to guide you in how to live a life that is pleasing to me and will help you.

Also I can't see how I in any way insinuated God is a tyrant. Forgiving all our sins, sending his son to die and always loving us. I can't see that as tyranny.



-JC7

"In God We Trust - In Games We Play " - Joel Reimer

 

Joelcool7 said:

When did I say that? Dude you totally don't understand Christianity. Fact is the Bible is a path to follow, Jesus laid it out perfectly throughout the Bible exactly how we are supposed to live. Just because he forgives people for their sins doesn't mean he's a tyrant.

We are all judges, however we are supposed to control ourselves and not judge others. Its very important not to pass judgement on someone else , rather try and understand why they did what they did. Often their are very reasonable reasons for someone doing something and when their aren't its usually a mental disability and such. Nobody does anything for no reason at all and judging everything everyone does when you yourself do tons of things is just plain wrong.

Umm your misreading facts, since Adam and Eve ate of the tree of good and evil they did understand what was right and wrong.

Lets rephrase what you said logically

I God, want everyone to follow me. All those who do accept forgiveness will be granted it and live forever in heaven. I sent my son and the Bible to guide you in how to live a life that is pleasing to me and will help you.

Also I can't see how I in any way insinuated God is a tyrant. Forgiving all our sins, sending his son to die and always loving us. I can't see that as tyranny.

I have not read the Bible so I was just taking your words for it.

According to your reasoning, it's quite contradicting. You're not supposed to judge but you're the judge, or restraining yourself from judging. So, are you supposed to or not?

Tyranny in term of, my way or the highway.



Galaki said:
Joelcool7 said:

When did I say that? Dude you totally don't understand Christianity. Fact is the Bible is a path to follow, Jesus laid it out perfectly throughout the Bible exactly how we are supposed to live. Just because he forgives people for their sins doesn't mean he's a tyrant.

We are all judges, however we are supposed to control ourselves and not judge others. Its very important not to pass judgement on someone else , rather try and understand why they did what they did. Often their are very reasonable reasons for someone doing something and when their aren't its usually a mental disability and such. Nobody does anything for no reason at all and judging everything everyone does when you yourself do tons of things is just plain wrong.

Umm your misreading facts, since Adam and Eve ate of the tree of good and evil they did understand what was right and wrong.

Lets rephrase what you said logically

I God, want everyone to follow me. All those who do accept forgiveness will be granted it and live forever in heaven. I sent my son and the Bible to guide you in how to live a life that is pleasing to me and will help you.

Also I can't see how I in any way insinuated God is a tyrant. Forgiving all our sins, sending his son to die and always loving us. I can't see that as tyranny.

I have not read the Bible so I was just taking your words for it.

According to your reasoning, it's quite contradicting. You're not supposed to judge but you're the judge, or restraining yourself from judging. So, are you supposed to or not?

Tyranny in term of, my way or the highway.


When did I say "Your the judge" I said we all judge as you said however we aren't supposed to according to the Bible. Judge lest you be judged. In other words we all sin and make mistakes and acting all high and mighty judging others for their mistakes is wrong as we too have made plenty of mistakes.

As for my way or the highway, I don't claim to understand everything going on in Gods mind. But I'd say if I created a universe for these creatures that I loved and spent alot of effort making. Then those ingrates turned on me, decided they were better then me and stopped listening to me. I'd find it very hard to say "Okay do what ever you want".

Infact if I was God I'm not sure I'd send my son to save all those sorry asses either. I mean obviously they aren't listening to your commands. They don't give a crap about what you say. Why in the world should I go out of my way to improve their lives?

But its a good thing I'm not God. I probably would have smited the whole earth by now lol! Their probably would be no free will I would expect my creations to have some sense of loyalty.

But God sent his son to die so that not only would he save us from our sins but teach us how to live! Just be glad I'm not God lol!



-JC7

"In God We Trust - In Games We Play " - Joel Reimer