The main concerns should be:
-Streamlining the site, making content more accessible, and making it speedier.
-Attracting great users and great talent (reviewers, writers, etc.).
The second will naturally follow if the first. I was a mod when the new rules were put in place that made banning more protracted and arduous (instead of worthless trolls being banned immediately, they had to be banned for 1 day, then 3 days, etc.), and I even remember the day when ioi basically said "oops" and accidentally unbanned everyone on the site. There have been a lot of great users on this site but many of them have been chased away by the sheer magnitude of bad posting and stupid comments. However, I look forward to these changes if they ever come to fruition. The site can still focus a lot on news and reviews but none of the elements of the site need to come at the expense of the others. Making the site into different entities or sections just makes it even more confusing. And if Vgchartz isn't a good name, maybe it's time to change it. It wouldn't be the first time a site changed its name.
If the site has to import writers and reviewers while some of Vgchartz's best contributors are posting on NeoGAF then clearly something is wrong. Make the forums quicker and crack down on worthless posters (there are several in this thread alone). Stop trying to separate the site into different sections and just make one comprehensive, well designed site. I'm aware that there's a lot of data on the site but maybe we don't need to have dozens of hyperlinks placed at every possible open space. It's a damn shame that even the game pages are clunky and confusing now. If moderators and game DB administrators and poll admins go out of their way to make your site better, don't then go and make their job more difficult.
And you can say I'm wrong, but the results are on my side. A clunky site and a languishing community. It's time to strip away the badges and Facebook imitation and just be a great site about videogames.