By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Portable gaming: Dedicated gaming device vs. Smart Phones etc.

 

Who's side are you on?

Captain America/Portable Consoles 5 45.45%
 
Iron Man/Smart Phones 1 9.09%
 
Spider-Man/Both sides bec... 2 18.18%
 
Hulk/Leave me outta this shit! 0 0%
 
Deadpool/ I just want to have fun 3 27.27%
 
Total:11

So you're away from home and you want to play video game to pass the time.  What do you want turn on?

The pro-smart phone/iPad/etc argument :  You don't want to play full fledged video games on the go anymore than you want to watch a movie on the go.  Save the movies and the big budget games for your living room.  You just want some entertainment.  You want some simple, mindless, bite-sized fun, don't you?  That's where the smart phone excells.  For a couple of dollars (or sometimes, for free), you get unlimited entertainment.  You get your web browser, you get your movies, you get apps on top of apps, and you get video games.  Are they graphical masterpieces or the deepest experiences?  Not usually.  Yeah, there are games from Camelot that do boast amazing graphics and there are versions of Street Fighter and even RPG's but most of what you are going to find are time wasters.  Time wasters.  And in the end, isn't that what you want?  Isn't that what video games are?

The pro-portable console argument :  You consider yourself a gamer?  Then you know Mario.  You know Pokemon.  You know Kratos.  You know you aren't going to get games of this quality from a smart phone.  Video games aren't just time wasters, they're experiences.  The graphics and sounds and even the stories pull you into their world.  You want your music, movies, and browser?  Portable consoles have that, too.  And let's not forget one little thing--buttons!  Since you were a kid, you've been pressing buttons.  A touch screen is good but let's be honest.  Suppose Nintendo released their next portable. Let's call it the Gameboy 3.  It the Gameboy 3 were just a touch screen with motion controls and touch screen games, I would quit gaming.  Those $1-$2 games are available on our PSP's, DSi's, 3DS's, and likely, our PSV's, too.  But our Wipeouts, our Super Marios, and Mario Karts, those can only be done justice on a real portable console.

So which side are you on?

--Sentry/Void (aka d21!)



Around the Network

Captain America dies at the end of Civil War.



Gaming Devices definitely. I see no reason to game on smart phones as opposed to gaming devices. As of now, smart phone games are only good for a few minutes in one sitting. Phone games simply lack the depth found in game on dedicated handhelds.



game devices most def.



I'm Bucky!

anyway I love that companies like Square ENix are giving much love to us iPhone users.. sure they are old ports but still.. FF1 2 and 3, Secret of Mana, Chaos Rings and the upcoming FF tactics... love it.. they show when you take the time and money you can have the full portable console gaming on a smartphone..



 

Face the future.. Gamecenter ID: nikkom_nl (oh no he didn't!!) 

Around the Network

voted for both but sides smartphones as the vast majority of my gaming time. my phone is always with me, i couldn't live without it with phone, text, maps/gps, internet, email, music. games are just the icing on the cake. since mostly i'm looking to kill just a few minutes of time (20 min daily train commute) it fits my needs perfectly without the hassle of also bringing a dedicated device and the cartridges (i have a ds not a psp). plus, my smartphone allows for online play, 3DSs wifi is laughable in terms of useability as wifi access is so limited and psVita has 3G but i'm guessing it will be laughably expensive monthly fees.

i have a ds and will get either a 3DS/psVita most likely just for those longer trips (3+ hour plane ride for instance) but it won't be getting nearly as much love as my iphone.



Dedicated mostly... phones combine bad controls with weak battery life and stupid high prices... so...



RolStoppable said:
Dedicated gaming device for me, because I already own one unlike a smartphone or something similar which I actually had to buy first. I still own the same ten year old cellphone which wasn't even state-of-the-art back then.




It's fine either way really I think it just comes down to preference.