Unfortunately my worst fears seem to be coming to fruition. We have quasi confirmation that three of the maps that are going to come with the game are Damnation, Hang em High, and Battle Creek. Apparently popular is exactly the same as done to death. Logically speaking this game should be an excuse for them to remake maps that they have not gotten around to remaking in the past. What we have so far is two maps that have already been remade once before, and another map that has been cooked up in map editing by players countless times. What this is amounting to is maps you have played in the last five years.
Perhaps more damning is the fact that you can play all of these maps right now in Reach. With the forge, and half a dozen hours to spare you can make them yourself. You can even download the versions created by other players. It has actually become old hat to remake the simple Halo maps. What isn't at all easy is to make the larger maps. That would require more resources then the players are given.
Analytically speaking their is a failed logic at play here. They understand the power of the new technology to create drastic improvements in the visuals, but they aren't grasping the fact that it can enhance the game play. Plus provide old, but novel experiences for the console fans. Halo players have been pitching camp in medium sized maps for years. The original Halo on the PC actually had the muscle power to push through large maps for the players. With the grander scale the play changed up dramatically. The bigger size made for a different style of play.
Anyway it is all rather uninspired, and probably lazy. There is nothing innovative about what they are doing. There are a lot of games that get modern makeovers. However the original Halo has enough breadth that they really had a chance to make something really powerful. Instead it is coming across as all gimmick. They could have had a game that really made a splash. There isn't a real good reason that a remake cannot be a clearing house for new options to play. A rather disappointing showing.