its RDR for me, I liked GTA4, but everything about RDR was better, I know someone said the story was half filler, but at least it was somewhat interesting, unlike GTA4 were it was just endless killing

its great, super cheap and probably the best DLC ever I think

Red Dead, by a mile.

red dead, but the ending still sucked balls

did you unlock the real ending? because I thought it was great, sad, but great

I got lost in the world of red dead it was so much more fresh than the same old urbanstreets of GTAIV. Not to take away anything from GTa though because rockstar is the master of open world games. I will buy them as long as they make them.

Definitely RDR. It's going to go down as one of my favourite games of this generation.

The undead nightmare is fantastic!

RDR

Does everything better than GTA IV (except content)

I dunno....RDR being released later is technically superior and imo has better VO. Gamplay wise I say they are fairly similar though RDR does have Dead Eye which is cool and the horse riding is pretty neat. Story wise probably GTAIV though I think RDR has better story telling ...personally I probably prefer RDR but it was released later.

there is only one ending lol...and after missions which i did complete. It sucked