By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo - Against the grain: Why is the Wii so rubbish at mature games?

Reasonable said:

The Wii's main problem in this area, I believe, is simply imagne.  All the adverts, branding, etc. for the Wii is about family games.  Period.  I've never seen any branding or adverts or any positioning that say - adult or hardcore games.

Technically, the Wii's as capable of supporting such titles as any other platform, but it has a huge disadvantage (relative to its install base) by owner demographic.

My wife, for example, doesn't bat an eyelid at mature games on PS3/360 but basically dislikes the idea of them on Wii and doesn't want us to have mature titles in the house.  The Wii is for the family, for fun, not for playing adult games after the kids have gone to bed.

Now of course, with an install base of 80 million there is certainly a slice of owners up for such titles, but I really think they're in the minority vs those who bought a Wii based on its branding for family games, Wii Fit, etc.

At this point the Wii, I believe, will never escape this branding.

It can support mature titles.  But it'll never see a mature title sell anywhere like they can on the HD consoles.

On the flip side, and I believe backing this up, it's pretty obvious that the HD consoles are unlikely to see a family title sell anything like they can on the Wii.  This may change with Kinect/Move of course, which is part of the reason for their existence - particularly Kinect.

The Wii though has no such easy get out IMHO.  It's whole world conquering image that has driven it to 80 million does not allow it.

True. But still, perhaps the Wii can, somehow, turn things around, if Nintendo wanted it...

if it can be done so swiftly with the 360, then Nintendo could swoop in, steal some of its consumers with heavy advertsising and pull it out of the "blue ocean"

As you say, however, there are countless good mature games for the Wii, however, its reputation muddies its sales and any new potential projects. I expect this to change with the SUPERWii however!



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.

Around the Network
LordTheNightKnight said:
huaxiong90 said:
LordTheNightKnight said:

I should add that the vulume of m rated games on the other systems increase sales, but the costs are so high that only a few make money, and that only a few really sell that well anyway.

I wonder how big the development budget for The Last Story and Xenoblade are.


Hard to say, since budget disclosure is so rare among the gaming industry.

It is, but I'd guess

Xenoblade-£9 million

The Last Story- £12 million

(Typical Wii game- £7 million)

(Typical HD game- £16-20 million)

These are all just guesses, but likely in the right area



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.

Gojimaster said:
Conegamer said:
Gojimaster said:

Honestly, I tend to buy most of my mature/hardcore games on 360 or PS3 as opposed to Wii.  I enjoy Wii for Nintendo 1st party games, for party games like Just Dance, and for other niche games like Zach and Wiki that can't be found elsewhere.

For other games I like to see pretty HD graphics, superior online play, and more DLC options.  Most hardcore games have an element that pushes technology-- I simply can't play a game like ME2, Uncharted 2, GOW3, or Red Dead Redemption on the Wii.  The Wii simply cannot run a game like that.  Since there are so many great hardcore games on HD consoles right now, I never even consider buying hardcore games like Madworld, Red Steel 2, and No More Heroes 2 which are vastly inferior to what can be found on an HD console.  I would never even consider playing CoD on the Wii since the graphics and online are going to be so scaled back compared to the version I play on 360. 

My dream is that I can one day play all my favorite Nintendo and hardcore games all on 1 console again.  This dream probably won't happen anytime soon though. 

I agree with you, but I'd say that missing out on such great Wii games as Monster Hunter Tri and Red Steel 2 is a travesty. The others, yeah OK, not great. But those two (especially Tri) need to be in any gamers collection!

As for your dream, wake up. Look what's happening with the 3DS. Nintendo is learning, and no doubt the Wii2 will have amazing 3rd party support to boot!

I was more referring to a home console.
I am excited about 3DS, but I don't play hardcore games on handhelds anyway.  I actually really like the DS the way it already is-- Professor Layton, Ace Attorney, Zelda, New Super Mario Bros, etc.  When I want to play an immersive game with good graphics I go straight to the console. 

Yes, but surely the 3DS shows a strong thrid-party line-up, which we can expect to be followed in the SuperWii?



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.

Yakuzaice said:
Conegamer said:

2. There has been no advertising for the Wii version. Ever

--------------------------

http://gamrreview.vgchartz.com/sales/47589/nba-jam/

First 4 weeks for PS3: 27,507

http://gamrreview.vgchartz.com/sales/42594/nba-jam/

First 4 weeks for Wii: 69,874

Difference- Wii has sold 240% more by this time than the HD versions

--------------------------

2. No More Heroes

First, let's just remember the outcry there was for this game being on the PS3...

Remembered? OK, here's the Japan-numbers

http://gamrreview.vgchartz.com/sales/40816/no-more-heroes-heroes-paradise/

PS3 version (first 10 weeks): 25,289

http://gamrreview.vgchartz.com/sales/7667/no-more-heroes/

Wii version (first 10 weeks): 35,532

 

Hindsight is a wonderful thing Sega...but Madworld was niche on the Wii, and will be niche anywhere else. You should be thankful Wii development costs are so much lower, because 500k isn't a flop, they'd have made money. Developers won't port games off Wii when they sell worse anyway...

Clearly these are good sales anyway; after all, 380k for Conduit got a sequel, as did Okami!

Would Madworld have sold better on the PS360? Doubtful, but maybe (5% increase)

Would it have made a profit, like the Wii version? No

World at War had specific Wii advertising, and all the Black Ops commercials I've seen seem to be platform neutral.

For NBA Jam, why do you say HD versions when you ignore the 360 version?  Also 240% more than 27,507 is 93,523.  Not to mention it was supposed to be a stripped down download that came with NBA Elite 11 up until about a month before it released.  But to be fair, the lead up of what features would be in what was a mess for both versions of the game.

No More Heroes.  Once again you ignored the 360, which normally wouldn't mean much in Japan.  However, it was the uncensored version, and that had a very noticable impact on sales.  Plus it is a late port on systems with much smaller install bases, and it sold more than the sequel on the Wii.

As for Madworld, keep in mind that the price collapsed fairly quickly and sharply.  So while the conduit might not have sold as much, it seems like the price has held up much better than Madworld.  Similar case to Mirror's Edge where it sold 2 million, but didn't do great because the price dropped to $20 less than a month after release.

Madworld is a strange case, but no doubt made a profit!

I chose the PS3, because it has NHM sales, but both are acceptable!

NBA JAM failed no matter how you look at it (simple Maths error :O)

I didn't realise about the WoW commercials, but every BlOps commercial I've seen says "only for 360 and PS3 on", some of which don't eve acknowledge the Wii version!



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.

Conegamer said:

I didn't realise about the WoW commercials, but every BlOps commercial I've seen says "only for 360 and PS3 on", some of which don't eve acknowledge the Wii version!



I can back him up on that one CG, they do have the Wii logo on them.



 And proud member of the Mega Mario Movement!
Around the Network

Its not realy the fact the wii cant do maure ames because it ca. The problem is the 3rd party saport for the wii is...well somehwat lacking. As for the example of no more hero the ps3 vertion came out so long aftaerwards im surprised it sold that much ^^



Yeah i know my spelling sucks but im dysgraphic so live with it :3    

---------------------------------------------------Bets--------------------------------------------------

Conegamer - I say that the PS3 will beat the DS next week in Japan  (for hardware sales) Forfeit is control over others avatar for 1 week.

Immortal said:

Honestly. it depends on the specific genre/game. To say that Wii can or cannot sell "core" or "mature" games is stupid. If every CoD game till the last one has been handicapped on the Wii, obviously the CoD fanbase will be on PS360. All those small new IPs, if they're not attempting to directly steal from a PS360 fanbase, will almost certainly sell better on Wii than on the PS3 or 360, simply because of the larger base.

And they'll definitely make more profit.


The wii fanbase in general isnt that botherd about third part games anyway ^^ for the most part wii ownder buy nintendo games hense they sell so much. Thats my opinion anyways ^^



Yeah i know my spelling sucks but im dysgraphic so live with it :3    

---------------------------------------------------Bets--------------------------------------------------

Conegamer - I say that the PS3 will beat the DS next week in Japan  (for hardware sales) Forfeit is control over others avatar for 1 week.

Conegamer said:

True. But still, perhaps the Wii can, somehow, turn things around, if Nintendo wanted it...

if it can be done so swiftly with the 360, then Nintendo could swoop in, steal some of its consumers with heavy advertsising and pull it out of the "blue ocean"

As you say, however, there are countless good mature games for the Wii, however, its reputation muddies its sales and any new potential projects. I expect this to change with the SUPERWii however!

Why would Nintendo need to "swoop in and steal some of their customers".  It would be wasted dollars on advertising for third party companies since third parties are the only ones releasing M rated games on the Wii.  Nintendo could go the route of N64 and release some M rated games such as Perfect Dark or Conkers.  However, the "hardcore" gamers that don't own a Wii probably wouldn't go buy one just because a few more M rated games came out on the Wii.  It would be a failed campaign from the beginning serving no point in selling more systems.  Nintendo didn't have to rely on the Microsoft and Sony M rated game fans to finally get them back in first again and they don't have to rely on them ever. 

Sure a few more M rated games would be nice but I don't give a damn what the game is rated.  I buy whatever I view is good.  If you shop around only for M rated games then you are a closed minded gamer.  The entire hardcore / causal debate pisses me off most of the times.  Just like the comic that was posted a few posts up.  Kids these days don't know shit.  Few titles are very hard anymore compared to what they used to release.  Give a kid Ninja Gaiden 1 on NES and see if they can even make it to area 6-2 when shit really hits the fan. 



Conegamer said:
LordTheNightKnight said:
huaxiong90 said:
LordTheNightKnight said:

I should add that the vulume of m rated games on the other systems increase sales, but the costs are so high that only a few make money, and that only a few really sell that well anyway.

I wonder how big the development budget for The Last Story and Xenoblade are.


Hard to say, since budget disclosure is so rare among the gaming industry.

It is, but I'd guess

Xenoblade-£9 million

The Last Story- £12 million

(Typical Wii game- £7 million)

(Typical HD game- £16-20 million)

These are all just guesses, but likely in the right area

Your guess is somewhat over estimated on all front i would i have to say. I dont know the exact figures myself but consider crysis cost 20 million to make i highly doubt thats the general amoutn spent. It probably more around 5 million for a trypicle wii game and 10 million for hd game. With very high buget wii games being about 15 million and very high budget HD games being about 50 million.

To be honest though the obveous reaosn ti costs more is that the budget is mostly spent og the graphicle sid eof things which the wii is slightly lacking in.



Yeah i know my spelling sucks but im dysgraphic so live with it :3    

---------------------------------------------------Bets--------------------------------------------------

Conegamer - I say that the PS3 will beat the DS next week in Japan  (for hardware sales) Forfeit is control over others avatar for 1 week.

RolStoppable said:

If you have an interest in M-rated games, you'll try to get to play the best there is. That definitely isn't on the Wii and it's for reasons that go beyond graphical and online limitations: Nintendo doesn't make M-rated games and third parties don't put their best teams on Wii games in general, so what you can buy in terms of M-rated games on the Wii is limited to at best second rate titles, but usually worse.

Short, succinct and straight to the point. If you can grasp the basic idea outlined above, you won't have to wonder why, out of the three current generation home consoles, M-rated games sell the worst on the Wii despite its clear installed base advantage.



My thoughts exactly, and at this point anyone hoping for more M games on Wii has given up and gotten an HD console.