A203D said:
highwaystar101 said:
A203D said:
Mistershine said:
David Attenborough: Planet Earth or Life. Programs like this are the only reason I have found to warrant a HDTV.
|
The other reason i find is some of the space documentaries, like the stephen hawking ones or universe, look abosolutely stunning in HD.
|
I love Stephen Hawking's books, but I often find his documentaries disappointing. Especially his latest 'Stephen Hawking's Universe', I thought it largely just pandered to what people want to hear and not what should be heard, if that makes sense.
|
Well i've only read a 'brief history of time' and its a good book, complex towards the end, but very good. i found his recent docummentary 'Universe' was a lot of the same stuff we already knew, still great though. i think i know what you mean, because he talks about things like slowing down time and worm holes. i didnt see the last one, but i dont think he went into string theory at all; but i think part of his quest is to simplify these concepts and theories so there understandable to people who are overwhealmed by science.
|
It's documentaries about things like aliens and time travel. It's so easy with those topics to fall into the trap of saying things the viewer wants to hear. It's easy to say "Yeah aliens exist" for most of the documentary, but only mention how extremely unlikely it is once or twice. Take the viewer on some fantasy trip.
It's just my personal preference that I find with documentaries. I imagine that I'm in the minority to be honest, I think most people would like that kind of documentary.
One person who falls into that trap a lot (even though I think he's ace) is Michio Kaku.
That and action. Documentaries should have a little action as possible, unless completely justified. So many documentaries about the big bang have been ruined by having a CGI explosion every five minutes to represent the big bang (which is just as misleading as anything else too).
Luckily BBC understand this very well, and that's why they are the best at making documentaries lol.