...Why is suggesting we hang Kamal suspicious?

Not at all......but Kamal turning up as mafia is.

1) Khuutra is always like that.

2) Why would he propose lynching a fellow mafioso? That makes no sense whatsoever.

3) Explainable in many ways.

Khuutra being innocent is the second most certain I am in the innocence of any living player not including myself.

2- Mafia members do that alot to make them self look trust worthy

3- Now your making me less suspicious of khuutra and more suspicious of you.

It works like this.

We have four generally confirmed townies. It's not absolute, but we can pretend. I can say with absolute certainty that Homer and Metal_Gear are town. For the sake of this conversation let's pretend you and I are.

Five unconfirmed townies sit on the other side.

We have a vigilante. We can kill two unconfirmeds per day, while the Mafia can only kill one confirmed per day.

In addition to this, the cop could - in theory - eliminate one more suspect per day, either confirming them as Mafia or Town. Homer's power is less useful in this situation, so I'm not going to put it down as an elimination sort of thing.

We are on Day 3. By Day 4, there will be 2 unconfirmed townies left and 3 (more or less) confirmed. It doesn't matter WHAT the Mafia does at that point, they've lost. They can kill the vig or the cop but not both, and at that point it won't matter. Game over, Mafia. We win by the end of Day 4 or the dawn of Day 5, no questions asked.

We are, thanks to rampant modkilling, in the endgame. It could be close, but only if we play this very, very stupidly.

I'm thinking that all townies with power roles should reveal themselves, BUT NOT UNTIL I SAY SO. Is anyone against this?

2- Mafia members do that alot to make them self look trust worthy

3- Now your making me less suspicious of khuutra and more suspicious of you.

Suggesting that Khuutra just decided he wanted to kill a fellow scum is stupid. You're grasping at straws - no, scratch that... you're clutching at straws for dear life.

HoS: You for this.

You mentioned a hierarchy of townies whom you "want to see hanging" or "want to strangle" or some such thing.

The original list was noname2200, dtewi and myself (Kantor)

You then realised (intelligently) that you didn't want to strangle me at all.

nen-suer at some point was added to your suspicion list.

Could I ask why those three are more suspicious than the others?

____________________________________

On the subject of power roles, I think we should keep the same policy as before - if you discover something important, reveal it. But "important" can be used more loosely here. Definitely if you find out that somebody is guilty. Perhaps if you realise a high-level suspect is innocent.

WTH is this crap ?

I'm not in danger of being lynched,  so......no I'm not "grasping" for dear life.

I sometimes wonder if you read 1 post per page and guess what the situation is.

Nen is problematic in his behavior, his attitudes, and his defenses

I'm tempted to shift the trian over to nen