NAH !

Core games with motion gaming
FPS where u can throw ur grenade using ur hand (precision ? range ?)
FPS where u can move the camera using ur head (but if i look left then ... i cant see the screen anymore !)

well, the grenade looks functionnal but not really "needed" for classic core games

In a way, it confirms we dont "need" motion gaming for classic core games

The best advert MS can possibly make for Kinect is to give a big, online multiplayer two control schemes -  FPS classic controls and hybrid. The core will flock to buy Kinect when they find they are unable to compete at their favourite shooter without it

People, people.people,

Halo 4 would be much better with kinect, You will play halo 4 with the controller in the same way, but with kinect you also have the ability to strafe left and right with your body and peek over objects by moving your head up.

This will give kinect players a slight advantage, but wont mean you need it.

Also watch out for a few new single handed controllers coming next christmas

Nidan

true but we will soon see how it does with FPS released for the PS3 like Socom or Killzone

we will see how online is affected by the controller

The best advert MS can possibly make for Kinect is to give a big, online multiplayer two control schemes -  FPS classic controls and hybrid. The core will flock to buy Kinect when they find they are unable to compete at their favourite shooter without it

Why would Socom or Killzone do anything? Motion control such as that employed by Move has been known to be better for FPS since the release of Red Steel. If you want to argue that Kinect will not be able to do as well then that would be a more interesting conversation, but I shan't be drawn into a discussion that was settled years ago.

I seriously doubt yelling "grenade" and hardware to process this to mean hit the "A" button will be faster than simply hitting the "A" button. Yelling "grenade" just translate in the game as hitting a button. I also doubt you will have a big FPS title with cause players using a controller to be at a disadvantage. This is why console shooting will not give players the option to use a keyboard/mouse.  Remember Kinect just like Move are still add-ons (not cheap either) as both parties will try to avoid splitting up their user base.

 It's still an interesting point; what if both Move and Kinect gives FPS gamers a huge advantage. Will this cause everyone to buy into motion controls or will it just end up splitting up their user base which is still smaller than Wii.