By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 20 Game Thread

radishhead on 18 September 2010

All right then :P

Vote: Homer_Simpson

 



Click this button, you know you want to!  [Subscribe]

Watch me on YouTube!

http://www.youtube.com/user/TheRadishBros

~~~~ Mario Kart 8 drove far past my expectations! Never again will I doubt the wheels of a Monster Franchise! :0 ~~~~

Around the Network
theprof00 on 18 September 2010
Kantor said:

I was beginning to think that voting H_S so abruptly was a bad idea. But no edits allowed

Ordinarily, I would HoS Homer like I did MetalGear, but...somehow I don't get the same vibe. As someone said before me (sorry, can't remember whom) he's posted some three times saying the exact same thing, and pretty much every post of his has been some variant on "this is confusing" or some other generic comment.

Seems like the behaviour of somebody who is scum and doesn't know how to effectively conceal it whilst actively partaking in the discussion. But prove me wrong, Homer, please.

I agree, Homer is super suspicious, but then again so are these two. Though, I'm totally willing to put pressure on Homer.



Homer_Simpson on 18 September 2010

im not scum, my role cant be revealed without me losing my powers it says, but trust me, im a good guy!

ive been busy last few days so havent been able to post much, for that, I apologize, but my life is a bit hectic at the moment, I do find it odd how quick people are to try and get me lynched though...not even suspecting me first, seems to me some people are overly eager to see me die...



Kantor on 18 September 2010
theprof00 said:
Kantor said:

I was beginning to think that voting H_S so abruptly was a bad idea. But no edits allowed

Ordinarily, I would HoS Homer like I did MetalGear, but...somehow I don't get the same vibe. As someone said before me (sorry, can't remember whom) he's posted some three times saying the exact same thing, and pretty much every post of his has been some variant on "this is confusing" or some other generic comment.

Seems like the behaviour of somebody who is scum and doesn't know how to effectively conceal it whilst actively partaking in the discussion. But prove me wrong, Homer, please.

I agree, Homer is super suspicious, but then again so are these two. Though, I'm totally willing to put pressure on Homer.

I'm also slightly suspicious of Heph and radishhead, but:

Heph: His roleclaim makes sense now, though it's still a little overpowered. I more or less believe him, though his logic seems a little twisted.

Radishhead: He's too intelligent and experienced to be playing this poorly as a Mafia.

Homer_Simpson, on the other hand, has been pretty deliberately evasive, and as you said earlier, dense. If he had a powerful pro-town role, he'd be posting more. He's most probably Mafia, IMO, but could be vanilla townie. In the first case, it's a huge gain. In the second, it's only a small loss.



(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective

Homer_Simpson on 18 September 2010
Kantor said:
theprof00 said:
Kantor said:

I was beginning to think that voting H_S so abruptly was a bad idea. But no edits allowed

Ordinarily, I would HoS Homer like I did MetalGear, but...somehow I don't get the same vibe. As someone said before me (sorry, can't remember whom) he's posted some three times saying the exact same thing, and pretty much every post of his has been some variant on "this is confusing" or some other generic comment.

Seems like the behaviour of somebody who is scum and doesn't know how to effectively conceal it whilst actively partaking in the discussion. But prove me wrong, Homer, please.

I agree, Homer is super suspicious, but then again so are these two. Though, I'm totally willing to put pressure on Homer.

I'm also slightly suspicious of Heph and radishhead, but:

Heph: His roleclaim makes sense now, though it's still a little overpowered. I more or less believe him, though his logic seems a little twisted.

Radishhead: He's too intelligent and experienced to be playing this poorly as a Mafia.

Homer_Simpson, on the other hand, has been pretty deliberately evasive, and as you said earlier, dense. If he had a powerful pro-town role, he'd be posting more. He's most probably Mafia, IMO, but could be vanilla townie. In the first case, it's a huge gain. In the second, it's only a small loss.

so you defend two other posters whilst saying that I should die if im scum or not...great, clearly you are a good person



Around the Network
c03n3nj0 on 18 September 2010

EVERYBODY!

Answer this question:

Are you Sephiroth?

I bet you there's a Lie detector in this game. 

I'll go first: No I am not



 Tag (Courtesy of Fkusumot) "If I'm posting in this thread then it's probally a spam thread."                               

Homer_Simpson on 18 September 2010
c03n3nj0 said:

EVERYBODY!

Answer this question:

Are you Sephiroth?

I bet you there's a Lie detector in this game. 

I'll go first: No I am not


no, Sephiroth is not my role.



theprof00 on 18 September 2010
Kantor said:

 

Heph: His roleclaim makes sense now, though it's still a little overpowered. I more or less believe him, though his logic seems a little twisted.

Radishhead: He's too intelligent and experienced to be playing this poorly as a Mafia.


If you say so man, I knew Heph was lying and feel that radish is lying. They're both important roles. Why claim these things so quickly. I understand Heph was in a weird situation that led up to this recent doctor claim. I'm still suspicious. And if you want to talk about eerie, talk about how I bring up Homer as someone I'd like to lynch and suddenly he has three votes.. I was planning him for a while but this just feels odd.



theprof00 on 18 September 2010

I am not.



Kantor on 18 September 2010
Homer_Simpson said:
Kantor said:
theprof00 said:
Kantor said:

I was beginning to think that voting H_S so abruptly was a bad idea. But no edits allowed

Ordinarily, I would HoS Homer like I did MetalGear, but...somehow I don't get the same vibe. As someone said before me (sorry, can't remember whom) he's posted some three times saying the exact same thing, and pretty much every post of his has been some variant on "this is confusing" or some other generic comment.

Seems like the behaviour of somebody who is scum and doesn't know how to effectively conceal it whilst actively partaking in the discussion. But prove me wrong, Homer, please.

I agree, Homer is super suspicious, but then again so are these two. Though, I'm totally willing to put pressure on Homer.

I'm also slightly suspicious of Heph and radishhead, but:

Heph: His roleclaim makes sense now, though it's still a little overpowered. I more or less believe him, though his logic seems a little twisted.

Radishhead: He's too intelligent and experienced to be playing this poorly as a Mafia.

Homer_Simpson, on the other hand, has been pretty deliberately evasive, and as you said earlier, dense. If he had a powerful pro-town role, he'd be posting more. He's most probably Mafia, IMO, but could be vanilla townie. In the first case, it's a huge gain. In the second, it's only a small loss.

so you defend two other posters whilst saying that I should die if im scum or not...great, clearly you are a good person

NONONONONONONONO

That is NOT what I am saying. A pro-town player dying is always a bad thing, to be avoided if at all possible.

What I'm saying is that, from what I've seen, you're more likely to be Mafia than anyone else. And that on the off chance that you are not Mafia, lynching a vanilla townie is, while still bad, not as bad as lynching, say, a Doctor, or a...Stonebreaker?

Oh, and "my role becomes useless if the Mafia know about it"...seriously? Would I be correct in saying that is the most common way of attempting to get out of a lynch?

But don't worry, you're not near a lynch. Yet. If you don't start explaining, though, you may be very soon.



(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective