I think the PS Move sounds awesome with head tracking and 1:1 precision and the games coming out for it, however imo its far too expensive, and Kinect dosent really interest me too much. but i think the wii is the best choice, if purely for Mario Galaxy.

I'd buy a Wii again, it's the proven default motion console. The other add-ons still have to prove themselves.

Never the less I would be interested in buying Kinect and use it for my MCPC if it works good enough, I read that Microsoft was going to make it available for Windows. Controlling my media from the sofa sans controller is a dream come true, I would no longer use my Wii Remote as a mouse.

If motion controls were the only factor, I'd go for the Wii. I don't like the idea of completely controller-free gameplay, and Move just doesn't have nearly as many quality games as the Wii.

If all three consoles launched with those devices (at these prices), then I'd go with Move, because the Wii's motion gaming library would be no better than that of the PS3, Move would be standard for PS3 games, and I could play Sony first party titles.

If we adjust for the amount of games available for all three motion devices, I'd still go with the Wii. It just has more games I'd like to play, and I find Nintendo's track record to be a lot more reliable than other companies.

I don't see how it's trolling. He's absolutely correct. The Kinect library looks like utter garbage, and many other gamers share the same opinion.

If this is bannable material, so be it, but it's my honest opinion. MS is in for quite the rude awakening if they really think they can get away with selling these so called "games" at a $60 pricetag. They are playing gamers for fools.

I dunno, Metallicube...I'd say they're playing everyday consumers to be fools, and they'd probably be right, because you know what? Microsoft is Awesome to normal consumers...big name, big company, big products....Just so happens that imo none of them come with the features that are advertised from launch, Microsoft loves to say "Well we Could do this, but we're not going to for several years, and after you forget about it, we're going to make you pay extra to get it through an add-on"

where have you been this generation? M$ specialize in the art of "rape de consumars" there gonna do fine, and with their marketing kinect is  going to explode, I predict a situation like this Wii>Kinect>>>Move.

and @ Seece: Achievement Unlocked:   --teh ? dogerer--   10pts

as far as motion controls go, i think the move is the most accurate and natural,  but wii has the library of great games.  i had a wii but at the time the only games that interested me were twilight princess and smash brothers, now theres alot more games.  the kinect still looks a little glitchy/buggy to me but i could be wrong.   im probably getting a move myself around christmas time.

both, ive already got a library and with kirby, donkey kong, zelda ,and sonic, and cant remember what else. im set for a good while.

Well, I already know what the Wii plays like so I assume I know what the Move plays like so if I had to pick I'd pick Kinect since it's fresh.