90% of Halo owners probably haven't even played Killzone 2, so they can't really say which gameplay is better. I don't say that they would change their opinion then because in the end everything depends on personal taste and opinion, but seriously... without playing both it's not possible to judge which has the better gameplay, and well... we are not able to know if 90% thought that way, so... pretty unnecessary to discuss that I think.

Are people really comparing Halo 3's gameplay to Killzone 2's one?

lulz

We all know the controls were kind of broken in Killzone 2. Perhaps some of you got used to them but I know I and a lot of people never did.

The gameplay is actually Halo 3's biggest strength.

LMAO!!!

i'm actually pretty sad that in KZ3 they're changing it to "Normal" it was awesome in KZ it felt real, and it required skill to aim,  not noob friendly like every other FPS.

its not broken, its just that its not logical to do 900 Degree turn while jumping in real while holding a massive gun.

its also not logical that it takes 2 full seconds for a soldier to do a full 360 degree turn on ground...

And Gabe Newell is one luck chump!!!!

Well....you're the ones that brought in sales saying "12M people feel the same way"

oh yeah, everytime we complain about HL Episode 3 , he gets laid.

Oh god this thread is awesome flame bait. I actually read through all the comments on this site and N4G ahaha i love  system wars.

killzone 2 tried to put in work, but the controls were a big problem for me.

gameplay is most important to gamers which is where halo will mostly win.

Killzone will never be a Halo killer. But Killzone games will ALWAYS be better than Halo games. Every single Halo game is crap. I have played all of them and not a single one was fun. (Excluding Halo 3, only watched that) 

Hell man Bungie are probably the worst level designers in the industry! Worst level I ever played was the snowy mountain level in Halo 1.... it was soooooooo repetitive and boring, so bad I didn't finish it and sold my Xbox lol. 

Then my friend raved about Halo 2 saying it was going to be the best game they've ever played. I played it for 20 minutes before I couldn't take anymore and had to put the pad down it was that bad. 

Watched Halo 3 be played by others, looks alright and more fun than the previous 2. 

Halo: ODST played co-op with friends, another terrible game. 

And Halo: Reach the trailer made it look dull. It did not look like an interesting game in the bloody slightest and it just showed exactly how rubbish Bungie are at level designing. 

Also just because more people play a game doesn't mean it is better. Look at the number of sales for Call of Duty: Modern Warefare 2. The game is AWFUL! MW2 has one good thing, Spec-Ops. The rest of it.... OMG I've never played a single player so bad! And the competitive multiplayer's maps... seemed to just been slapped together. Sorry but Infinity Ward just suck at developing games these days, they know they can make anything and get stupid amount of sales.