By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Website Topics - The VGC 3.0 Complaint/Suggestion Thread

a redesign without a spell check? we need a spell check.



Around the Network
makingmusic476 said:

I do appreciate many of the subtler improvements that have been made to the site with 3.0.  The way your sidebar auto-updates when you recieve wall posts, PMs, etc. without having to refresh in particular is quite nice.

I think the reason this thread is filled mostly with criticism while little praise is given to some of the great improvements you guys have made is because:

1.  People like to bitch.

2.  Most of the improvements are, like I said, quite subtle.

Many of these improvements go a long way towards making the site a more streamlined and swifter experience, however, I must stress yet again that these improvements are outweighed by other issues as things currently stand.  Small time savers like not having to refresh to find out you've been messaged mean squat when you're clicking pages left and right anyway, and in the end the fragmented and rather convoluted layout of 3.0 means that you'll ultimately spend far more time going from page to page in an attempt to find information that was right in front of your face under 2.0 anyway.  All these little time savers are outweighed heavily by having to use four different websites to perform what used to be fairly simple tasks under the old design.

My biggest issue so far is having two entirely separate game databases, neither of which you can search through via gamrConnect DESPITE the fact that you manage your game collection entirely via gamrConnect.

In the end, VGChartz is a site dedicated to the reporting, analyzing, and discussing (via the forums) of sales numbers.  Yeah, over time we've added on news and reviews and whatnot to make the site a more fully featured gaming site, but the focus at its core has never changed.  The issue with the new site deisgn is that it breaks apart some of the site's most basic features (notably the relationship between front page sales, our database of games and their sales, and the forums), thus making the core of what made this site so unique and awesome less of a core.  It feels like there's no center to the site anymore, and the four pages feel fairly unrelated.  Having to go a to a different website from gamrConnect to find anything worth discussing on gamrConnect, for example, inhibits discussion, and it makes it seem like this isn't even VGChartz anymore.

Honestly, gamrConnect now feels like it's JUST a forum.  Yeah, it has links to the other VGChartz sites at the top, but other than that, what does it have over any other random forum?  Despite all the features like wall posts and whatnot, I could easily replace it with any other forum and browse VGChartz at the same time.  Granted, the community keeps me here, but why did that community build up?  Because they liked the forums that were a part of VGCharts.  Fully integrated into the whole.  Not tacked on at the end.  They were the VGChartz forums.

I'm sure the quitetness of the forums this past week (despite news like the Killzone 3 trailer, the MotorStorm 3 and Infamous 2 announcements, Xenoblade's release and live streaming, the Portal 2 delay, among other things) can be attributed to the redesign.  The thread about MotorStorm has been up for almost 20 hours and it hasn't even broken a page (50 posts/p)!  It's averaging 1.5 posts an hour.  Though I suppose that means we've finally managed to cut down on the number of Sony fanboys running around.  :P

I was trying to bold the 'Xenoblades release' but it doesn't work. Strange, i've been around everyday and must have missed that news because im looking at the wrong pages???

Sad to say but it just is too much of a hassle to look everywhere to get the same information we had on 1 page before. And indeed the forums are terribly slow this week...



Whenever I go into a thread where I'm not directed to the last read post, I get sent to the bottom of the first page. It's pretty annoying.

Chrome 5.0



I do believe reason for ban and when to return should be back on profiles, when I was banned I had no idea when I was unbanned. or at least notify us via email



2010 WW Software Sales is down again.

I want to see how Just Dance has surpassed God of War III!



Around the Network

how do i search for a specific thread?

where is the PS3 trophy league, why is it not a sticky?

Fuck this is frustrating



̶3̶R̶D̶   2ND! Place has never been so sweet.


morenoingrato said:

I do believe reason for ban and when to return should be back on profiles, when I was banned I had no idea when I was unbanned. or at least notify us via email

yeah, i agree.



when ever i click on a thread in a new tab it always takes me to the bottom of the page first so i always have to scroll up to get to the top

 

also there should be a forum section of the most recent posts like vg chartz 2.0 had instead of going to each section of the forum seperately



Predictions

GT5 will sell 3.2million + first week on ps3 (made 06 March 2010)

FFXIII Versus will have higher Metacritic scores than FFXIII after the first month.... Bet going on with perpride - loser changes sig for a month

KH3 will be PS3 EXCLUSIVE - willing to bet removal from vgchartz for a month


ultraslick said:

how do i search for a specific thread?

where is the PS3 trophy league, why is it not a sticky?

Fuck this is frustrating


See, I'm definitely not the only one. I'm bitching about the new site, because it's fustrating to go from a site that worked pretty well to another site that is very hard to manage and get where you want to be. With the old site, I could get to forums, charts, reviews, news and just about everything else from the front page with either 1 or 2 clicks. On the new site, I can't find anything. I have to click to specific websites and then search that site in hopes of finding what I want. The fact that the site has less color and appeal makes coming here even more of a burden. Please put this new site back into Beta and bring the old site back. Once you get the new site BUG FREE and easy to navigate, then bring it back out. I even tried editing a post. I made changes, click "DONE" and refreshed and none of my changes were in my post. Sigh... uuuhgg!!



__________________________________________

'gaming till I'm gone'

NJ5 said:

makingmusic476 I see a contradiction in your post. You apparently agree with much of the criticism, which one wouldn't find by just reading your summarized 2 points.

Apparently what you meant was that people are bitching because:

1- People like to bitch.

2- The improvements were subtle.

3- The disadvantages of VGC 3.0 are quite obvious.

Apologies if I misunderstood you.

Well, I suppose I meant that the improvements were subtle in comparison to the main issues with the redesign.  I probably should've worded it better.  The whole post was a bit of a rant, to be honest.

Cactus said:

@makingmusic476 

This thread is specifically for complaints and suggestions.

I guess that would also be a reason for why we've seen few positive comments in this thread.  :P

However, I think this thread evolved into a more general feedback thread fairly soon after it was created.