By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Microsoft - Alan wake Review. Selnor

Why are people attacking this guy, Its only his opinion....So take it for what its worth
I have seen many other wild claims that Uncharted2 and GOW3 deserve a 10/10 which I think is rediculous from users......So leave selnor alone.......Still a great review Btw



Around the Network

LEAVE SELNOR ALONE!!!
*in the style of Chris Croker but manlier*



trunkswd said:
I just finished the game. The atmosphere, the mood and tone it sets its the best I have ever seen in a video game and up there with some of the best movies. The story is up there with some of the best written novels. I agree with the 10/10, its definitely the best game I have played this generation, if not of all time. Before anyone gets on my back this is just my opinion I know not everyone will agree with me.

If this game or some of the novel's Alan Wake wrote were ever released I would definitely read them.

Just out of curiosity, what do you consider some of the best movies / novels?



Try to be reasonable... its easier than you think...

Twilight



Lyrikalstylez said:
Why are people attacking this guy, Its only his opinion....So take it for what its worth
I have seen many other wild claims that Uncharted2 and GOW3 deserve a 10/10 which I think is rediculous from users......So leave selnor alone.......Still a great review Btw

Because in here, people often answer an OP based on the posting history he/she has rather than the content of the post itself. Its called prejudice I believe. By all means, Selnor has made quite a few threads that aren't very productive (a lot of people have but many of them get away with it) but this isn't one of them. I can't comment on the score since I haven't played the game myself just yet but the OP itself is well written and I honestly believe that he gave the score out of love for the game and not out of sheer spite for having hyped the game beforehand.

Lord Flashheart; no, can't be, he's not a thirteen year old female... I checked his profile.



Around the Network

Was you disappointed after you checked his Profile?

No wait, too far. I'm sorry.



Mummelmann said:
Lyrikalstylez said:
Why are people attacking this guy, Its only his opinion....So take it for what its worth
I have seen many other wild claims that Uncharted2 and GOW3 deserve a 10/10 which I think is rediculous from users......So leave selnor alone.......Still a great review Btw

Because in here, people often answer an OP based on the posting history he/she has rather than the content of the post itself. Its called prejudice I believe. By all means, Selnor has made quite a few threads that aren't very productive (a lot of people have but many of them get away with it) but this isn't one of them. I can't comment on the score since I haven't played the game myself just yet but the OP itself is well written and I honestly believe that he gave the score out of love for the game and not out of sheer spite for having hyped the game beforehand.

Lord Flashheart; no, can't be, he's not a thirteen year old female... I checked his profile.


:)

I more than anyone realise I made some silly threads in the past. But I'm making sure from now on, I contribute to the site, rather than turn this site into NeoGaf 2!

I'm actually really sad my Fun loving Top 10 Exclusive thread is locked. How the hell did that happen. It was going amazing yesterday. And people were having fun!



Lord Flashheart said:
Was you disappointed after you checked his Profile?

No wait, too far. I'm sorry.

Assuming you're referring to my probably obvious question... I'm not saying.  Love threTwilight answer though!



Try to be reasonable... its easier than you think...

ok i'll buy it (once it's cheap)



OoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoO

I dont think any game is perfect. But Alan Wakes story line & the TV like presentation are great as are the graphics, you can stand on a peak and just see fantastic vistas everywhere.the puzzles arent so great i would have liked them to be a little more taxing . But id give this game 9 and id recomend this game to anyone with a 360 FANTASTIC.