By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Why were these FF7, FF8, & FF9 Remakes for PS2 Cancelled?

You don't remember the ball room dance sequence from FFVIII that was rendered in real-time on PS2?



Around the Network

i'm sure remakes of those 3 are coming, but they are probably just gonna do it in order, they have only done the first 4 so far.



currently playing: Skyward Sword, Mario Sunshine, Xenoblade Chronicles X

Kenryoku_Maxis said:
AkibaFan said:
Kenryoku_Maxis said:

Sales are going down.  Its a lopsided and gradual decline, but sales are going down.

Its also a case of different goals.  Wada and the 'CEOs' (or financial and advertising side) excpected FFXIII to do as good or better than FFVII, simply because it was on a new platform and was 'bigger and better' than FFVII.  Plus because they were pumping more money into it than any FF game ever seen.  Where the developers of the game such as Kitase and Nomura were just trying to make a game and didn't have any real goal in mind.

That's the problem.  They don't have a focus.  The same thing happened with FFX as well.  People consider that game a success because it sold well, but it still didn't reach the sales of FFVII.  And the goal set by the company was to surpass the sales of FFVII, as they put a lot more money and advertising into FFX.

I already corrected u on this in another thread. U keep saying this all the time but ur wrong. When they wer talking to their investors they sed FF13 is expcted to ship 6 Million. Later on they told a magazine they "hope" it can sell like ff7, duh, they did tht to hype it. Their tru expctations are those they laid out in financial meeting. And that was 6 Million.

http://uk.gamespot.com/news/6230719.html

Wht is the point in correcting u in the othr thread if u jst ignore it?

So FF13 will do bettr than expcted in sales. Wit FF10 however they sed they expcted 10 million in the financial investors meeting, so tht did underperform.

First of all, the link you just provided me was to another magazine interview.  Not an investors briefing.  Second of all, stating to the press or stating to investors you want a game to sell a certain amount wasn't my main point here.  My main point was each title, they keep pumping more and more money into the advertising and funding of each game.  As if they EXPECT it to sell more.  They can say to either their investors, magazines or Jack Thompson for all it matters that they expect it to sell a certain amount, but their effort shows that they want it to perform better.

If someone sells 100 apples by putting forth $10 in advertising, and then turns around and sells only 80 apples with $50 woth of advertising, they can't say it was all 'as planned'

 

Yeah i think your on to something with that; i mean you really think that Wada, Kitase & the FF team said to themselves, lets spend all this time and money on a game that dosent exceed what we did before. i'm not saying they set out with the goal of outselling FF7, but i think it was something they had thought about. and i bet they spent loads on advertising.

i think it was on finalfantasy.net or somthing, i have heard rumours that wada wanted to surpass the sales of FF7, but he never provided a figure, i think after it became unrealistic he brought that figure down to 6 mil. in that release data trailer, Kitase said that FF13 will exceed all expectations and the presenter mentioned how FF13 was possibily the most anticipated game of all time. theres no doubt in my mind they wanted to top FF7.

 



A203D said:
Kenryoku_Maxis said:
 

First of all, the link you just provided me was to another magazine interview.  Not an investors briefing.  Second of all, stating to the press or stating to investors you want a game to sell a certain amount wasn't my main point here.  My main point was each title, they keep pumping more and more money into the advertising and funding of each game.  As if they EXPECT it to sell more.  They can say to either their investors, magazines or Jack Thompson for all it matters that they expect it to sell a certain amount, but their effort shows that they want it to perform better.

If someone sells 100 apples by putting forth $10 in advertising, and then turns around and sells only 80 apples with $50 woth of advertising, they can't say it was all 'as planned'

 

Yeah i think your on to something with that; i mean you really think that Wada, Kitase & the FF team said to themselves, lets spend all this time and money on a game that dosent exceed what we did before. i'm not saying they set out with the goal of outselling FF7, but i think it was something they had thought about. and i bet they spent loads on advertising.

i think it was on finalfantasy.net or somthing, i have heard rumours that wada wanted to surpass the sales of FF7, but he never provided a figure, i think after it became unrealistic he brought that figure down to 6 mil. in that release data trailer, Kitase said that FF13 will exceed all expectations and the presenter mentioned how FF13 was possibily the most anticipated game of all time. theres no doubt in my mind they wanted to top FF7.

 

I agree, with what your saying. because, ofcourse they wanted it to sell as much as 7 (if I'm not mistaken Square-Enix's) best selling game. You don't hope for it to sell less. And when you create something... just being an artist myself... sometimes you think you created something great, and then a lot of people don't like it etc.. so you get excited.

However, I don't know what wada does besides running the company or how much influence he has on the actual game. But Kitase and the FF team, were probably proud of their work so, you get a little hyped up, about what you did, granted... I love FFXIII to death, but I understand why many don't.

And one more thing. FF7 was the spearheaded (with about 5 games I think) of 100 million dollar advertising campaign paid for by sony. And I'm pretty certain that's the biggest ad campaign FF's had. And theirs rumors though I'm not sure whats true is that Microsoft paid for some of the FFXIII commercials.

@ Kenryoku, SE wanted FF to outsell 7 since 7 that's a logical thing to want. But that is not SE as a company expectation. They're not expecting it to outperform what they expect, because  their marketing people get paid to project sales, as with any company, and a responsible company which I'd assume SE is as they have made money for atleast the past 3 years. You don't base company prosperity on unrealistic goals.  Because It's irresponsible to be like  a baseball player thinking I'm going to hit a home run off this pitch, or I fail. That would be the equivalent to SE expecting it to outsell FF7.

Hell for 2 examples from nintendo that would fit your staggering decline definition are 3D mario, and Zelda

3D Mario, Mario 64 11.89m, Mario Sunshine 6.28m, Mario Galaxy 8.62m, did nintendo expect each of them to outsell mario 64?
Zelda  OoT 7.6m, Majora's Mask 3.36, Wind Waker 4.55m, Twilight princess 7.08m, did nintento expect each of them to outsell OoT?
Metroid fits the patern as well, but in terms of sales it's never been close to FF's or 3D mario or Zelda.

So by your description of Final Fantasy being on the decline. That would mean Zelda and 3D mario are as well. And Nintendo and Square Enix have never achieved what they expected in those games since, Mario 64, OoT, and FF7.

 

 



AkibaFan said:
Kenryoku_Maxis said:
A203D said:
Kenryoku_Maxis said:
AkibaFan said:

ff10 didnt get 10 million because evn though it is seen as classic nw, when it relesd ther ws lots of negativty about it & ppl sed it wsnt as gud as ff9, ff8 & ff7. so word of mouth stpped it getting to 10 million.

I thnk FF10 is overtracked here, on wikipedia it has link to investor report saying FF10 has shipped 6.6 Million.

FF15 won't. RPG's dnt sell tht much anymore. FF15 wnt even sell more than FF13 which will do betwn 6 - 7 Million. Expect ff15 to do ff9 level sales

FF10 also didn't get to 10 million because its not as big of a series as Square thinks it is.  And none of the following games have.  They do this every gen.  They try and make a bigger and better Final Fantasy and think it'll sell just because they made it prittier and threw more money and hype behind it.

And I agree.  In the next gen, they'll probably try to do the exact same thing.  Make an even MORE expensive game to try to build up the hype again from what they lost with FFXIII...and instead, it'll only sell 3/4 the amount of FFXIII.  Because instead of focusing on what's important, they'll just completely change everything again.

On that last point, i dont think sqaure will ever let this type of thing happen again. i'm not saying FF13 is a bad game, but i am saying that i dont think they'll make a game like that again. it wasnt recieved as well by western reviewers as they had hoped. and it has 3 stars out of 5 on amazon japan, and thats out of 2000 japanese fans, which is their home market. so i'm hoping they realise what they have to focus for the next one. also hopefully it will be helmed by a different team, not Kitase, Toriyama, Normora etc, so it wont neccessarily be another expensive cutscene fest.

the reason i think that FF15 could hit the 8-10 million mark, is because of assassins creed 1&2, i know they're not RPGs, but they have similar elements, like character driven narrative, and a strong single player story driven game. and thats why i think theres a market out there for this type of game.

We'll see.  But they've done it multiple times now.  And we've seen in multiple interviews that the people who work on the Final Fantasy series don't really seem to care about critisism or reviews, or even sales.  Just about 'their vision'.  And that can be a bad sign, as even if they think their vision is the 'right' one and just keep pressing on...when sales are going down.

u cnt blame them. They did cater to fans once. whn old skool fans wnted ld school FF they gave them FF9 & it sold the worst out of all PS FF's (FF13 will outsell it soon). 

Sales aren't going dwn, ff13 will do more than ff9 & 12. When a  FF does below 5 Million its time to wrry.

Why are you always comparing sales with quality? The only reason why FF8 sold as much as it did was because of FF7's success. It was a quick money maker for Square at that point. The reason why FF9 sold poorly compared to FF8 was because a lot of fans were disappointed with 8 because of it's magic system , junction abilities and because it was over shadowed by the release of FFX and the PS2.

Can you also try to use proper grammer in your posts? I can barely understand what you are writing and it's hurting my eyes.



3DS Friend Code:   4596-9822-6909

Around the Network
AkibaFan said:

http://uk.gamespot.com/news/2679121.html?tag=result%3Btitle%3B0

Why wer they cancelled? i ws luking for ff remake info on google & this link came up, its old But was ther evr a explnation given for cancellation?

lol it was because of final fanyasy the spirits within, it was a brilliant film imo opinion but it toatlly failed at cinema's, and they lost a whole shed load of money, the money they was going to make they was going to use for the remakes:):)



it's the future of handheld

PS VITA = LIFE

The official Vita thread http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=130023&page=1

Christian973 said:
AkibaFan said:
Kenryoku_Maxis said:
A203D said:
Kenryoku_Maxis said:
AkibaFan said:

ff10 didnt get 10 million because evn though it is seen as classic nw, when it relesd ther ws lots of negativty about it & ppl sed it wsnt as gud as ff9, ff8 & ff7. so word of mouth stpped it getting to 10 million.

I thnk FF10 is overtracked here, on wikipedia it has link to investor report saying FF10 has shipped 6.6 Million.

FF15 won't. RPG's dnt sell tht much anymore. FF15 wnt even sell more than FF13 which will do betwn 6 - 7 Million. Expect ff15 to do ff9 level sales

FF10 also didn't get to 10 million because its not as big of a series as Square thinks it is.  And none of the following games have.  They do this every gen.  They try and make a bigger and better Final Fantasy and think it'll sell just because they made it prittier and threw more money and hype behind it.

And I agree.  In the next gen, they'll probably try to do the exact same thing.  Make an even MORE expensive game to try to build up the hype again from what they lost with FFXIII...and instead, it'll only sell 3/4 the amount of FFXIII.  Because instead of focusing on what's important, they'll just completely change everything again.

On that last point, i dont think sqaure will ever let this type of thing happen again. i'm not saying FF13 is a bad game, but i am saying that i dont think they'll make a game like that again. it wasnt recieved as well by western reviewers as they had hoped. and it has 3 stars out of 5 on amazon japan, and thats out of 2000 japanese fans, which is their home market. so i'm hoping they realise what they have to focus for the next one. also hopefully it will be helmed by a different team, not Kitase, Toriyama, Normora etc, so it wont neccessarily be another expensive cutscene fest.

the reason i think that FF15 could hit the 8-10 million mark, is because of assassins creed 1&2, i know they're not RPGs, but they have similar elements, like character driven narrative, and a strong single player story driven game. and thats why i think theres a market out there for this type of game.

We'll see.  But they've done it multiple times now.  And we've seen in multiple interviews that the people who work on the Final Fantasy series don't really seem to care about critisism or reviews, or even sales.  Just about 'their vision'.  And that can be a bad sign, as even if they think their vision is the 'right' one and just keep pressing on...when sales are going down.

u cnt blame them. They did cater to fans once. whn old skool fans wnted ld school FF they gave them FF9 & it sold the worst out of all PS FF's (FF13 will outsell it soon). 

Sales aren't going dwn, ff13 will do more than ff9 & 12. When a  FF does below 5 Million its time to wrry.

Why are you always comparing sales with quality? The only reason why FF8 sold as much as it did was because of FF7's success. It was a quick money maker for Square at that point. The reason why FF9 sold poorly compared to FF8 was because a lot of fans were disappointed with 8 because of it's magic system , junction abilities and because it was over shadowed by the release of FFX and the PS2.

Can you also try to use proper grammer in your posts? I can barely understand what you are writing and it's hurting my eyes.

You can't really tell if VIII affected IX sales like that. The only reason it sold less than the previous installments is because it was released months after the launch date of PS2. Plus, Final Fantasy X was released a year after IX.



Haven't you heard? The reasons were the towns!



As awesome as a remake would be, I don't really want one. In all honesty, these games all blew me away at the time of their release. On top of that, I already know how they'd all end. The big draw in an RPG isn't the tech, it's the story. Unless they change the story, there isn't much reason for them to pump all of their resources into remaking the games. And, if they do change the story, wouldn't you rather have a new game instead of a snazzier copy of an old game? No matter what they change, we wouldn't be satisfied, anyway.

-the only exception is Resident Evil for the Gamecube.



d21lewis said:
As awesome as a remake would be, I don't really want one. In all honesty, these games all blew me away at the time of their release. On top of that, I already know how they'd all end. The big draw in an RPG isn't the tech, it's the story. Unless they change the story, there isn't much reason for them to pump all of their resources into remaking the games. And, if they do change the story, wouldn't you rather have a new game instead of a snazzier copy of an old game? No matter what they change, we wouldn't be satisfied, anyway.

-the only exception is Resident Evil for the Gamecube.

Yeah i agree, and besides i think FF8 & 9 have aged very well compared to FF7, especially FF8's photorealistic look. but you know i'm sure they will get on this when they make can games of FF13 quality in one year, this crystal tools engine is designed to last the generation. and recently square have been rereleasing and remaking so many FF games.