"The result is a triumphant toolset attached to a decent stab at the karting genre. Although LBP has the edge in terms of visual charm and broke the ground for this expansive genre, in its detailsModNation is not an unworthy successor. Should Play, Create, Share continue expanding, Modnation’s take on it may well be its broadest achievement. It sacrifices a little complexity and depth, but the result is a less intimidating toolset, one that far more people will find easy to use, and far less liable to result in a cluttered hard drive of half-finished masterpieces. [8]"

Source

8 out of 10, that's amazing for Egde

Phew. I was expecting 6 or 7.

meh, i do not really trust their reviews anymore

Great score from EDGE

i don't understand their scoring thing, as if their reviews don't reflect on the scores at all.

on the mario one they talked about how its more of the same but good fun none the less then gave it a 10/10
on this one they're talking about new ideas and the game being solid , but they gave it a 8/10

do they throw a dice to make these scores ?

Just wondering, what did they give Mario Kart Wii/DS, and Sonic & SEGA Allstars Racing? I'd like to see how it compared to these games in particular since they're from the same genre...

Awesome score since this is coming from EDGE who seem to be in the mind of giving games that are well known good scores (even if they are complete and utter tripe) and new unknown games lower scores... So this result is nice to see

@jbrist

Mario Kart Wii - 6
Mario Kart DS - 8
S&S All Stars Racing - ?

Mario Kart: Double Dash!! (GC) - 5/10
Mario Kart DS - 8/10
Mario Kart Wii - 6/10

They didn't review Sonic & Sega All-Starts Racing.

Nice score, I was hoping for a 5 or something...