FFXIII EASILY on a personal note unless MGS5 is a surprise E3 announcement due for PS3 THIS FALL roflroflroflroflrofl!

BUT due to its metacritic most sites won't give it GOTY, so out of those I'd say SMG2 as it has extremely positive previews.

Half of those haven't been released. Of the ones that have been released, it's easily Mass Effect 2.

I think SMG2, but I want Zelda to win.

on the liist, SMG2. but if Zelda wii is released this year, its over.
(IMHO)

Probably Zelda Wii or Metroid: Other M. If I have to pick from the list, as much as I love ME2, the Halo fanbase is just too big and yes, it's a popularity contest like it or not.

god of war 3.
followed by ff13 for me

Of those games, the only one that would merit the recognition is ME2.

i would have put zelda on the list and picked it as well, if i knew for sure it was coming out this holiday.

Probably not FFXIII and Fable 3. Also doubt it's going to be ME2 (released too early)

I'm secretly hoping for Red Dead Redemption :P

So far me2 for me. But I can't judge gow3 since I don't have a ps3.

Personally I don't think ff13 belongs on that list, it really doesn't measure up to the competition so far.