Time will tell.

Single platform games that did redefine genres, did so by raising the bar so high that competitors had to copy and improve on what was there so that quality of said genres were raised across all platforms.

If Uncharted influences others to copy game play elements then it is indeed possible that it helped redefine the genre.

I preferred the first to the second, but I think they were both great games, and my favorites on the PS3.

I agree with him.

It didn't redefine it. It perfected it

Well, this guy doesnt seem very inteligent, what does being in all platforms have to do with redifining a genre? Besides, no one said U2 did that, its an espectacular game, an awesome product which will almost surely still be better than what this guy produces.

It upped the bar at the very least.

I don't think anyone said it redefined anything, but enough talk have at you!

Sounds like someone is jelious, So many developers are not supporting exclusives any more, sure games could make more money on more then 1 console, but shit , if every game was on every console , then it would not matter what console you buy, and with no reason to buy a certain console, there would be no best or no reason for companies like Sony and MS to make better games. Uncharted 2 in my opinion is the best 3rd person shooter, and I would hate to see it on any console other then the PS3, just like I don't want to see Halo on any console other then Xbox, I really hope the industry does not go away from exclusives, if they did, I would stop gaming.

lol what is this argument? wow, simply wow!

Too bad :(, im a huge fan of castlevania, the ones that mix action and RPG element are awesome. But I think weve just receive confirmation its going to suck.

WiiFit could have redefined and/or defined at home console fitness.

Wii Sports and the WiiRemote could have redefined the way we play games.

Zelda OoT could have redefined the way we play adventure games.


Unfortunately all of these were limited to just one platform so they didn't redefine anything.

Nintendo could have done so much better if all of these were on competing platforms even though they are first party titles and/or peripherals.

Sony should have realized this error and released their first party title on the Xbox360.

Jealous much?
That's like saying like:
"Super Mario didn't change anything because it wasn't multiplatform! " (only NES at that time)

^ this... (cut out the rest of the statement cause this said it all).