LOL yeah, but even if it didn't work that good, remember that the average consumers doesn't know that. Just like there was many people believing that the standalone wiimote could do 1:1

Natal plus Wii like controllers would put Sony off the game.

Don't make me report you for spamming/offtopic please. It would be too far for my civilized tastes.

If you don't have anything to add to the discussion you shouldn't post.

Also you've got a proper button to report any post you may consider as trolling or flaming.

Explain to me how it's off topic, or even spamming... Please.

You even say in the OP... "Thoughts?". You don't specify on what you want the thoughts to be on. You simply say "Thoughts?". So go ahead and report if you must...

It wouldn't surprise me if they had a one handed control similar to the nunchuck but I can't imagine them doing a wii mote/move thing

That's a very big IF

OMFG!!11!!copycatsSonydiditfirstNintendoFTWROFLWTFXBotsHypocritesBananasBELIEVE!!112211!!ARGGGGHHHHH!!!

!!Micro$$$$$$oftGabeNewellISFat!!IhateNintendofansPikaPikaSonyfansaretheworst!!11!!!11!

!11!LOLOLOLOL!!!LUL@MICROSPORTS!!NOTOWNZZZZ!!!!lotsofevillaughter.

It will be great.

No but that would be killer.

they won't, but it would be funny. Playstation fanboys would be screaming copycats, microsoft fanboys would be screaming NO U. Wii fanboys would be screaming we did this 3 years ago. I find its amazing how so many people are embracing motion censoring who previously talked about the wii sucking because of its controls. I still think the wii is garbage, but at least i am not exited about the controls that are the reason i didn't buy a wii.
But seriously, if your excited about motion controls. Get a wii, it will be a far funner experience with their amazing first party lineup, instead of playing high resolution sports games the same as you would in real life, which you might as well just play in real life.

That would be a fail from MS because of the fact that they're heading towards the "You Become the Controller" idea and if they introduce a Controller, then they're not sticking to their words.

So they won't release one. Stick with the plan!

I think that just like guitar hero, if the game producer feels the need to push the envolope in any one direction they can, with there own controller+natal........ not have a controller forced if not needed... this way they can have any design or feel for the game....