Besides Gameplay, what aspect of a game is most important to you?

Graphics
Music
Multiplayer
Storyline
Replay Value
Other

graphhics duh..

Storyline for me because I want to be entertained in more than one way. I love to have a reason to play and to get immersed in a Story.

replay value

Storyline

Storyline can make up for a lack of multiplayer

But storylines requires graphics for me to become really immersed, although I'm not concerned particually about sound because half the time I play games without sound, although it can be really good. I sell nearly all my games after I'm done with them, so relay value does not matter hugely to me. I also have a monthly rental service (gamesfrenzy) so I play many games through that

Depends on the genre...

Replay Value

It really depends.

Like I expect a great storyline from a adventure/RPG/FPS, but I hold replay value highest if it's a platformer or sports game.

I voted replay value btw...because you want a game to be fun to play several times...

Storyline -> Gameplay ->Graphics -> Audio -> Multiplayer -> Replay value .... I dont care if a game only lasts 60 minutes . If its fun enough , or if it has a good enough story , I will buy it ....