Okay basically i want to know what everyone thinks about the pros and cons of each.

Will sony have something that is just a knockoff of the wii? or will it be something that is amazing and sell a lot?

Will Natal Revolutionize the gameing industry or will it be an expensive piece of equipment that no one will care for?

I just want to know what everyone on this site thinks about the two motion controllers, will they be great or not so great?

we haven't seen much of either... SONY just gave there device a official name.

We can't talk pros and cons of each as we have yet to see the final product of them, or the games they will have available.

Okay obviously we cant talk concrete things but what do you think will happen based on the current market and attempts at this stuff in the past?

Can't really talk about the games yet, but even without that I just want a natal unit for minority report style menu browsing...

Well... i really don't care. As a videogame collector, Ill buy both of 'em.

Errr...we don't know much about either one...so what is there to debate?

Well, Sony isn't really doing a lot to hype their device... so I'm thinking it won't be that successful.

Microsoft is hyping there's up like crazy so I think it will have a bit of an impact, at least at first. It could fail terribly as well.

I think long run neither will be a core focus for the companies this generation. They will be little side project that will be more of a test run for the next generation than something that seriously impacts game sells this generation.