Mass Effect 2 is better in almost every way. U2 had better melee combat though.

Fanboy journalists pointing fingers...oh funnnnn

meh i am a sony fan and i tried both (i own all consoles) the only thing better in U2 is that it has better graphics but in my opinion mass effect 2 is much funner

Right, everyone's entitled to their opinion.

Uncharted 2 was a mindblowing experience though, my one Platinum trophy, I could not put that game down at all, lol

HUH, since when does 1 guy speak for everyomne, last i checked UC2 was overall my highly rated. None are as God of war 3, so moot. Me 2 is a shooter with lite rpg elements.

96% for UC2, 94% me 2. Uc2 wins.

IGN is my favorite reviewer now because of this classic article. Anyway I totally agree.

Uncharted 2 wins in online mode by default over Mass Effect 2. Uncharted 2 has the better graphics over Mass effect 2 and it is easily the best game available on the PS3. The single player in Uncharted 2 was a linear ride through the 26 chapters in the game. Sure there is finding those treasures and gun trophies but it is an Action/Adventure game. Uncharted is the modern day version of Tomb Raider.

Single player campaigns Mass effect 2 with its 500 characters and its 31,000 dialogue options makes it an amazing gaming experience. Your character changes if you used a Mass effect character to start off the game. Your actions in Mass effect 1 and Mass effect 2 will impact on Mass effect 3. There is a lot of possibilities in the game. Customisation of character and 6 classes and the interaction of your character with other characters. Play through on Insane mode and it is a totally different experience and you are trying to survive in ME2- instead of over powering the enemies on the lower difficulty levels.

the awards uncharted 2 won, would tell another story...

As much as I think that Mass Effect 2 is ten times better than Uncharted 2 which is an over-hyped, over-rated, uninnovative, poorly written, mess of a game, IGN just sickens me sometimes.

again these are opinions as i much prefer dragon age over mass effect and i prefer neverwinter nights over both of them (comparable) uncharted 2 is not a rpg lol how can we even compare them i hope they do realize that some people dont even play rpgs and much prefer an action adventure game

they are both wicked games period

why not compare rpgs

demons souls >>>>>> mass effect any day of the week

again this is my opinion but i could probably write for an hour why i think demons souls is probably my favorite game this gen people are still playing it on my list , its crazy innovative much more than mass effect will ever be and the combat is overly more rewarding plus online integrated within the single player experience, endless leveling , pvp and coop massive insanely hard bosses to me the only rpg in my mind that comes close is neverwinter nights.

demons souls is a real gamers game , mass effect is a great game but very streamlined

eitherway my opinion