Not really. I was able to subtly insult roughly half of this thread in one fell swoop. I consider that efficiency, not harshness. Several people here seem to have read one line of the article and then based an opinion from that. It wasn't aimed at you, BTW.

Agreed. That was exactly the sort of immature outburst that IGN were pushing for when the wrote this article.

Yeah sure you were! xD

Also why you gotta hate on EVE Online? Is it too difficult for you?

But Uncharted 2 also has good online mode and their is a lot of stuff to unlock.  Anyway they are two completly different games and shouldn't be compared head to head.

It's fine if he prefers ME2. It's a perfectly valid opinion. Being that he works for a review site, he has the right to post this opinion, if he gives reasons for it. Which he does.

The "deal with it, fanboy" is a little inappropriate, though. It is also a valid opinion to prefer Uncharted 2 if you have played both. If, however, you have played only one of the two games, you CANNOT JUDGE, and I think that's what this is about.

Uncharted 2 scored 96 on metacritic with MORE REVIEWS than ME2, it has online, better graphics, more replay value... im not saying ME2 is worse (since i haven't played it yet), but looking at the facts, uncharted 2 looks lke a better game

You might want to consider that "more replay value" comment, ESPECIALLY if you haven't played ME2. It's hard to find a game with more replay value than that title. There are something like six (!) vastly different ways to play through the game and probably tens of thousands of small differences available to the player depending on their ME1 playthrough and how they react to NPCs in ME2.

also, IGN is doing this for the hits only. their reviews are excellent but their community sucks rel bad IMO

When you've played both games, people will take your opinion more seriously.

QFT