By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

The thread you're trying to post in is currently locked.

Original Message (newest first):

Conegamer said:
Stefl1504 said:
I thought someone is planning to host next round?

I am, hopefully. Will probably put the signup thread up tomorrow and (hopefully) start the game proper on the weekend.




Around the Network
padib said:

Traitor is just a name. My win condition didn't affect yours and I still won with mafia. I just had an extra win condition and it only minimally affected my play in the mafia QT.

Anyway, good for you: you know Nickles better than I do. Doesn't make me any more the fool.


Wasn't trying to imply you lost. The traitor part ended up not mattering.



Stefl1504 said:
I thought someone is planning to host next round?

I am, hopefully. Will probably put the signup thread up tomorrow and (hopefully) start the game proper on the weekend.



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.

I thought someone is planning to host next round?



padib said:

So erm, I was a fool but I was still right about his "trap" being WIFOM.

Doesn't make sense.


No, you went to far with the WIFOM. I told you that Nickles was just going to think you were petting him and go after you, and that he wouldn't see what you thought he would see, but you didn't listen. Probably for the best, since you were actually the traitor. Should have known there'd be a traitor with there being a recruitable SK, but it ended up not mattering.



Around the Network
Nicklesbe said:

You guys deserve credit where credit is due. Just be sure to give it where it's just the same. town didn't "stumble" into the ninja day one. I set a trap that caught him. That same trap made me 70% sure hylian was mafia. 

You guys made a shit ton of mistakes. One of which was keeping me alive for so long. If you really wanted to take out the most invested players i sohuld have been your number 1 target especially since I had the whole mafia team finger day one AGAIN. Fact is you guys got lucky Cone poisoned me, and then you guys went and killed him.

So go through the thread again. Town handed you this game. You won becuase you dragged out the clock and basically exhausted the remaining town until they pretty much didn't care anymore. The remaining town lost all grip on logic and forgot everything that happened previously. Don't get me wrong you guys get credit for win and I'm not trying to discredit you or Hylian, you guys hung in there just don't be so prideful as to think you both weren't completely transparanet to anyone that was paying attention. I'm only telling you that so you can learn from it in the future. I think ya did well but ya got lucky and if cone hadn't of killed me there is no way you guys would have won.

I want to just correct something here. It's not that mafia exhausted the town, it's like I said the first game: I am one of the only people who actually contributes, and it's why I die early usually.
The big contributors were taken out. Nickles, wonk, etc.

That's the problem in vgc mafia, so many people just stop contributing, it makes it easy for mafia to just take out the main voices and take over.

I get suspected for always pointing my finger everywhere, but without reactions, you get what we saw this game in day 5,6, and 7



Mafia deserved the win, surely. They played better than the town.
I can't really say that town did that well though either. One of them should have been dead when imp was told to protect wonk and didn't.
I dunno. It's hard to say if mafia only won because town lost, all I can say is that mafia won against a stacked town.

However, this now marks the third anti-town win in a row. The saying usually goes 'once is happenstance, twice a coincidence, three times is enemy action'.

This would translate to, maybe there is actually something wrong with townplay. I would agree.
Not downplaying mafia win.



Nicklesbe said:

You guys deserve credit where credit is due. Just be sure to give it where it's just the same. town didn't "stumble" into the ninja day one. I set a trap that caught him. That same trap made me 70% sure hylian was mafia. 

You guys made a shit ton of mistakes. One of which was keeping me alive for so long. If you really wanted to take out the most invested players i sohuld have been your number 1 target especially since I had the whole mafia team finger day one AGAIN. Fact is you guys got lucky Cone poisoned me, and then you guys went and killed him.

So go through the thread again. Town handed you this game. You won becuase you dragged out the clock and basically exhausted the remaining town until they pretty much didn't care anymore. The remaining town lost all grip on logic and forgot everything that happened previously. Don't get me wrong you guys get credit for win and I'm not trying to discredit you or Hylian, you guys hung in there just don't be so prideful as to think you both weren't completely transparanet to anyone that was paying attention. I'm only telling you that so you can learn from it in the future. I think ya did well but ya got lucky and if cone hadn't of killed me there is no way you guys would have won.

Lol, again? Ha! You were mafia the first game, and the second game you got it all wrong. This game you would have overlooked imp, and really, if I had actually been town, I'd have still gone after Khan. Even as mafia I thought Khan was mafia! You actually thought I wasn't playing town, but the first day is how I actually play as town! If I ever play here again, get vigilante role, and am not totally sure you're town, I'll be killing you. You rely on gambits and think you're logical, but you're really just cocky. Someday you're going to get your ass handed to you and that's the only way you'll learn. Before I even joined the thread I knew who mafia was, except for Sony Girl because she hadn't posted. Once I joined though, Khan really did start to look mafia. Had I been the town voyeur I claimed, he'd have been my only mistake.

 

And I didn't want you around, Nickles. Padib thought he could use you because he was a fool. I warned him and he didn't listen. Even then, the logic behind your "trap" is flawed, as padib pointed out. Padib played the meta even harder than you did, because he knew you were playing the meta and thought it would help him. But I knew you wouldn't see it, and would drive him anyway. That doesn't make your gambit some great feat of logic, it makes it luck. Padib could just as easily been town. You were only lucky you were on to me and padib with your gambit, but you tunneled the whole lynch train like an idiot. You tunnel people all the time. You'd have tunneled Astro and killed him, you'd have tunneled spurge and killed him, and while my voting for Smeags was because I didn't get back in time to take my vote off, his winning was specifially your fault, Nickles. The fact that you didn't see he was a jester immediately is hilarious. We knew he was either a jester or SK, and only because we knew there was an SK did we even consider that. So you lost the game for everyone, really, by considering him at all. Go ahead. Comfort yourself by calling us arrogant. You're just as arrogant. That arrogance gamble was based off of your real arrogance, after all, don't try to deny it. What you call us being prideful dicks is really just us watching your big head deflate and enjoying the sweet justice of it.



Someone poke me somehow for next game sign-up once they are there, since I will join again



impertinence said:

Prof or Trucks, could one of you change the thread title to reflect that I didn't do shit and Nickles played amazing? It's a little misleading right now.



There you go. But I'm gonna have to change it back...

This whole thing has got a little silly don't you think? It's just a game, and you won from a very difficult location via luck and good play. That's all there is to it!



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.